• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Integrity and impartiality under pressure

Work through recruitment, transfer and procurement cases where relatives, seniors or money push against integrity and impartiality, and frame defensible courses of action.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Integrity and impartiality are easy to praise and hard to practise when the pressure comes from a senior, a relative or one's own career. This lesson works through three typical case types and shows the steps of a sound response, so that you can reproduce them quickly in an exam.

The response ladder

When pressure is applied, an officer has more than two options. Think of a ladder: (1) clarify the rule and the facts; (2) explain politely why the request cannot be met; (3) put the request and your response on record; (4) escalate to a higher or independent authority if pressure continues; (5) as a last resort, refuse and accept the personal cost. Most cases are resolved on the lower rungs. Jumping straight to dramatic confrontation, or straight to giving in, are both weak answers.

Case 1: the cousin in the recruitment list

You chair a committee for contractual staff in a district hospital. Your cousin has applied and asks you to 'look after' her application. Analysis: the value at stake is impartiality, and the risk is a conflict of interest. Steps: tell your cousin you cannot discuss her application; declare the relationship in writing to the appointing authority; withdraw from the committee for that post or ask that another member assess her; make sure criteria and marks are recorded for all candidates. Note what you do NOT do: you do not ask her to withdraw, because she has the same right to apply as anyone else.

Case 2: the transfer recommendation

A local legislator asks you, an executive engineer, to recommend that an efficient junior engineer be transferred because she refused to approve a contractor's inflated bill. Analysis: integrity (yours and hers) and impartiality are both at stake; acting on the request would punish honesty. Steps: examine her record objectively; if her work is sound, decline to recommend the transfer and record your reasons; inform your superior about the request; support the junior engineer, because protecting honest staff is part of leadership. A strong answer also notes that the legislator may have genuine grievances from the public, which should be heard and checked on facts.

Case 3: the convenient supplier

Your office needs computers urgently. A supplier known to your senior offers to deliver in two days at a slightly higher price than the rate available through the open tender process. Analysis: financial integrity and objectivity versus urgency. Steps: check whether the rules allow emergency purchase and under what conditions; if they do, use the permitted procedure with recorded justification; if not, use the fastest lawful route, such as an existing approved rate contract. Pay a higher price only where the rules permit and the urgency is real and recorded. Friendship with a senior is never a reason.

Common traps in these cases

  • Resigning or going to the media in the first step: disproportionate and usually not the best option.
  • Silently refusing without recording anything: leaves you and the institution unprotected.
  • Assuming every request from a politician is improper: some are legitimate public grievances.
  • Treating 'nobody will know' as relevant: integrity does not depend on detection.

Clarify, explain, record, escalate, refuse: climb the ladder only as far as the pressure requires.

Key takeaways

  • Declare interests and step aside; do not deny others their rights.
  • Record pressure and your reasons in writing.
  • Protecting honest subordinates is part of integrity in leadership.
  • Urgency is handled through lawful emergency procedures, not personal connections.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Your relative applies for a post your committee is filling. The best first step is to:

    1. Ask the relative to withdraw the application from the committee
    2. Declare the relationship in writing and step aside from assessing that candidate
    3. Assess the relative extra strictly without telling anyone on the committee
    4. Cancel the recruitment altogether so that no one can accuse the committee
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Declaring the interest and recusing protects impartiality without denying the relative the right to apply.

  2. 2. A legislator asks for an honest junior to be transferred for refusing an inflated bill. Which response is strongest?

    1. Recommend the transfer to avoid friction with the legislator and keep the peace
    2. Publicly accuse the legislator in the press before taking any other step
    3. Ignore the request without any record and hope that it will not be repeated
    4. Examine her record, decline with written reasons, inform your superior and support her
    Show answer

    Answer: D. This uses the response ladder: objective check, refusal with reasons, record, escalation and protection of honest staff.

  3. 3. The response ladder suggests that an officer under pressure should usually:

    1. Begin with the mildest effective step and move up only if pressure continues
    2. Resign immediately so as not to be part of any pressure or wrongdoing
    3. Comply first with the request and complain later through the proper channel
    4. Go to the media first, before telling any senior officer about the pressure
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Proportion matters: clarify and explain first, record, then escalate, keeping refusal at personal cost as a last resort.

  4. 4. An urgent purchase is needed and a senior's friend offers fast delivery at a higher price. The correct approach is to:

    1. Buy from the friend because the need is urgent and delivery is fast
    2. Wait for a full tender even if the urgent need is real and cannot wait
    3. Use a lawful emergency or existing rate-contract route with recorded justification
    4. Split the order into small bills to avoid scrutiny by the audit
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Urgency must be met through permitted procedures with written reasons; splitting orders to avoid scrutiny is itself an integrity failure.

  5. 5. Which statement about requests from elected representatives is most accurate?

    1. All such requests are improper and should be refused at once without a reply
    2. All such requests must be obeyed to maintain good relations with the government
    3. Requests should be judged on facts and rules; some carry genuine public grievances
    4. Such requests should never be recorded on the file, so that the matter stays private
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Representatives often carry real grievances; the officer should consider them on merits and rules, and record improper pressure.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery