Weighing the grease hypothesis
Argument for 'grease'Counter-argument
Bribes help firms bypass slow proceduresOfficials then have reason to make procedures slower and more numerous
The highest briber is often the most efficient firm, so bribes allocate licences efficientlyThe highest briber may simply be the best at bribing, or may plan to cut quality to recover the bribe
Corruption lets excluded groups into politicsIt mostly entrenches those already powerful enough to pay
Speed money saves timeOnly for those who pay; the queue lengthens for everyone else

Where rules are bad, change the rules; bribing around them rewards those who keep them bad.

  • Leff and Huntington argued corruption might grease development under rigid rule.
  • Myrdal's soft-state critique shows corruption can create the very delays it claims to cure.
  • Kantian, virtue and Rawlsian analyses condemn corruption even when it appears efficient.
  • The ethical answer to bad rules is reform, not bribery.