• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why corruption happens: causes and the Klitgaard formula

Explain the causes of corruption at individual, organisational and social levels, and use Robert Klitgaard's formula, corruption equals monopoly plus discretion minus accountability, to analyse a situation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Why do some offices become known for bribes while others in the same city stay clean? Why do honest people sometimes pay and take bribes? Understanding causes is the first step towards cures. This lesson explains the causes at three levels and introduces a simple formula that is popular in exams.

Causes at three levels

Causes of corruption
LevelCausesExample
IndividualGreed, weak values, pressure from family expectations, belief that 'everyone does it'A new clerk starts taking money because colleagues mock him for refusing
OrganisationalWide discretion, complex procedures, delays, weak supervision, no record of reasons, low risk of punishmentA licence that needs twelve signatures creates twelve chances to demand money
Social and politicalTolerance of corruption, costly elections, patronage, lack of awareness of rightsCitizens pay without complaint because they think nothing can change

The Klitgaard formula

The economist Robert Klitgaard summarised the organisational causes in a simple formula: Corruption = Monopoly + Discretion − Accountability (often written C = M + D − A). It is not arithmetic; it is a checklist. Corruption tends to grow where one official or office has a monopoly over a service, where that official has wide discretion to decide, and where there is little accountability for the decision.

  • Monopoly: the citizen has nowhere else to go. Only this office issues the certificate.
  • Discretion: the official can decide yes, no or 'later' without clear rules.
  • Accountability: whether the decision is recorded, reviewed, time-bound and open to complaint.

Worked example 1: the driving licence office

Situation: one office issues all licences in a district; the inspector can pass or fail a driving test on his own judgement without any record; there is no time limit and no complaint system. Monopoly: high. Discretion: high. Accountability: low. Prediction: high risk of corruption. Remedies from the formula: allow tests at more than one centre (reduce monopoly), use a recorded or automated test track with clear scoring (reduce discretion), publish timelines and a complaint number (raise accountability).

Worked example 2: an online fee payment

Situation: university fees are paid online, the amount is fixed and printed, the receipt is automatic. Monopoly: the university still collects fees, so there is some monopoly. Discretion: almost none, because the amount and process are fixed. Accountability: high, because every payment is recorded. Prediction: low risk of corruption at this step. This shows how process design can reduce corruption even without changing people.

A caution about 'low pay'

Low salaries are often cited as a cause. Pay matters, because a decent salary removes one excuse and makes the job worth protecting. But well-paid officials also take bribes when discretion is high and accountability is low. Pay alone is never a full explanation. The same is true of culture: saying 'corruption is in our culture' ignores that the same people behave differently when systems change, for example when a service moves online and the counter disappears.

C = M + D − A: reduce monopoly, limit and structure discretion, and raise accountability.

Key takeaways

  • Corruption has individual, organisational and social causes.
  • Klitgaard's formula, C = M + D − A, is a checklist for diagnosing risk.
  • Good process design can reduce corruption even before attitudes change.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Klitgaard's formula, what does 'A' stand for?

    1. Administration
    2. Authorisation
    3. Accountability
    4. Appropriation
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The formula is Corruption = Monopoly + Discretion − Accountability. Accountability reduces corruption, so it is subtracted.

  2. 2. Which change reduces discretion in a licensing process?

    1. Clear, published criteria with an automated test
    2. Allowing the inspector to decide on his own impression
    3. Removing time limits
    4. Closing the complaint office
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Clear rules and automated scoring narrow the official's room to decide arbitrarily, removing a lever for demanding bribes.

  3. 3. Which of these is an organisational cause of corruption?

    1. A citizen's lack of awareness of his legal rights
    2. The expensive election campaigns of the parties
    3. The personal greed of the officer concerned
    4. A procedure requiring many unnecessary signatures
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Procedural complexity is a feature of the organisation. Each extra signature is a chance to demand payment. The others are individual or social causes.

  4. 4. Why is 'low pay' not a complete explanation of corruption?

    1. Because salaries are always high in government service, so low pay is never a real problem
    2. Because well-paid officials also take bribes where discretion is high and accountability is low
    3. Because pay has no effect on behaviour, so salaries could be cut without any risk to honesty
    4. Because only private employees are paid a salary, while public servants work for allowances
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Pay can reduce temptation, but the opportunity created by monopoly and discretion without accountability remains.

  5. 5. A district has only one office for land records, staff decide cases without recording reasons, and there is no time limit. What does the Klitgaard formula predict?

    1. Low risk of corruption
    2. No effect
    3. High risk of corruption
    4. Risk depends only on salaries
    Show answer

    Answer: C. High monopoly, high discretion and low accountability all point to high corruption risk.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → The harm corruption does

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery