- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Layers of culture and why change is slow
Use Edgar Schein's three levels of organisational culture to explain why reforms often change appearances but not behaviour, and plan change that reaches basic assumptions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Reformers often redesign offices, introduce new forms and publish value statements, only to find that behaviour stays the same. The organisational psychologist Edgar Schein offered a framework that explains why. Advanced answers on work culture use it to separate surface change from deep change.
Schein's three levels
| Level | What it includes | Ease of seeing | Ease of changing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Artifacts | Visible structures and practices: office layout, dress, forms, logos, ceremonies, written procedures | Easy to see | Easy to change, but changes may be superficial |
| Espoused beliefs and values | Stated strategies, goals and philosophies: mission statements, charters, codes | Moderately easy (they are announced) | Can be changed by declaration, but may not match behaviour |
| Basic underlying assumptions | Taken-for-granted beliefs: 'seniors are never questioned', 'citizens are a nuisance', 'everyone takes a little' | Hard to see; often unconscious | Hardest to change; they drive actual behaviour |
When espoused values (a charter promising courtesy) contradict basic assumptions (citizens are a nuisance), behaviour follows the assumptions. That is why a new charter alone rarely transforms an office.
How assumptions change
- New experience that disconfirms the old assumption: staff see that clearing files quickly brings recognition, not trouble.
- Leaders' consistent behaviour over time: assumptions follow what leaders actually reward and tolerate, not what they say.
- Psychological safety to learn: Schein argued that people change only when the anxiety of not changing outweighs the anxiety of learning, and when learning feels safe.
- Embedding in systems: new practices built into processes, appraisal and recruitment.
Worked example 1: the courtesy charter that failed
A transport department publishes a charter promising polite service, installs new counters (artifacts) and holds a launch event (espoused values). Six months later complaints are unchanged. Diagnosis using Schein: the basic assumption that applicants are suspected cheats, and that strictness equals honesty, was untouched. Deeper intervention: senior officers personally handle counters to model the new behaviour; staff discuss real cases where politeness and strict checking coexist; appraisal includes citizen feedback; staff who combine accuracy and courtesy are promoted to training roles. Assumptions begin to shift when experience and rewards consistently contradict them.
Worked example 2: the dilemma of speed versus depth
A reformist head has two years in post. Option A: quick visible changes (new furniture, digital displays) that impress visitors and seniors. Option B: slower work on assumptions (coaching, changed appraisal, consistent personal example) that may not show results before she is transferred. Ethical analysis: Option A risks the illusion of reform; Option B risks being undone by a successor. A balanced answer: use some visible changes to signal intent, but put most effort into embedding changes in systems (processes, appraisal, recruitment) so that they outlast her. Culture change must be institutionalised, not personal.
Artifacts are easy to change and espoused values easy to announce; behaviour follows basic assumptions, which change only through experience, consistent leadership and embedded systems.
Key takeaways
- Schein's levels: artifacts, espoused values, basic assumptions.
- Behaviour follows assumptions when they conflict with stated values.
- Assumptions shift through disconfirming experience, consistent leadership and psychological safety.
- Embed changes in systems so they survive leadership changes.
Check your understanding
-
1. In Schein's model, a new office layout and logo belong to:
- Artifacts
- Espoused values
- Basic assumptions
- Hygiene factors
Show answer
Answer: A. Visible structures and symbols are artifacts.
-
2. A charter promises courtesy, but staff believe applicants are cheats. Behaviour will most likely follow:
- The charter's promise of courtesy to applicants
- The office layout and the way the counters are arranged
- The underlying assumption that applicants are cheats
- The logo printed on the charter
Show answer
Answer: C. When espoused values conflict with basic assumptions, behaviour follows the assumptions.
-
3. According to Schein, people change most readily when:
- They are ordered to change by a senior, with a clear deadline and penalty
- The anxiety of not changing outweighs the anxiety of learning, and learning feels safe
- A new logo and slogan are introduced for the department
- Pay is cut until they accept the proposed change
Show answer
Answer: B. Schein linked change to the balance of anxieties and to psychological safety for learning.
-
4. Which intervention reaches basic assumptions most directly?
- Repainting the office and replacing the signboards
- Publishing a mission statement and distributing it to all staff
- Holding a launch ceremony with speeches by senior leaders
- Leaders consistently modelling and rewarding the new behaviour over time
Show answer
Answer: D. Assumptions follow what leaders actually reward and tolerate, consistently.
-
5. A head with a short tenure should put most effort into:
- Embedding changes in processes, appraisal and recruitment so they outlast her
- Only visible changes that the public and the press can easily notice
- Personal charisma alone, which will win staff over during her tenure
- Avoiding change so that nothing is disturbed before she leaves
Show answer
Answer: A. Institutionalising changes helps them survive leadership turnover.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.