• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Diagnosing work culture problems in a case

Use a symptoms-causes-levers method to diagnose the culture of an office described in a case, and choose interventions that reach the real causes.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The Foundation course described healthy and toxic cultures. In case studies you must go further: diagnose why a particular office behaves as it does and choose interventions that work. Treating symptoms alone, such as issuing a circular on punctuality, rarely changes a culture.

The symptoms-causes-levers method

  1. Symptoms: list what you see: delays, absenteeism, rudeness, complaints, petty corruption.
  2. Causes: ask why for each symptom, at least twice. Look at structure (workload, process), incentives (what is rewarded or punished), leadership (example and attention) and beliefs (what staff think is normal).
  3. Levers: choose interventions that act on causes: change processes, incentives, leadership behaviour and shared beliefs together.

Worked example: the land records office

Case: you take charge of a land records office. Citizens wait weeks for record extracts; agents hang around the gate; staff arrive late; morale is low. Symptoms: delay, agents, lateness, low morale.

SymptomFirst whySecond whyLever
Weeks of delayEach extract needs three signaturesRules were never simplified after records went digitalDelegate signature to one officer; set a time limit
Agents at gateCitizens cannot track applicationsNo acknowledgement or online statusToken system, receipts, online status and an SMS on readiness
LatenessNobody checks attendancePrevious head was also irregularNew head arrives on time; biometric attendance reviewed weekly
Low moraleGood work never noticed; blame for delaysLeadership focused only on faultsMonthly recognition; fix problems jointly

Notice that most levers change structure or leadership rather than lecturing staff. Once delays fall and agents lose their role, staff beliefs about what is 'normal' begin to change, which is the deepest level of culture.

A second short case

A health centre's staff are rude to patients. Asking why: the centre sees three times its planned patient load with half the sanctioned staff; staff are exhausted. Lecturing on courtesy will fail. Levers: request vacant posts to be filled, use a token system and seating to reduce crowding, schedule breaks, and then set courtesy standards with recognition. Culture problems often have resource and structural roots.

Traps to avoid

  • Assuming staff are simply 'bad people'.
  • Relying only on circulars and warnings.
  • Changing one thing while leaving incentives that reward the old behaviour.
  • Ignoring workload and resources.

List symptoms, ask why twice, and pull levers in process, incentives, leadership and beliefs together.

Key takeaways

  • Diagnose before you prescribe.
  • Causes often lie in structure, incentives and leadership, not only in individuals.
  • Change several levers at once so the old behaviour stops being rewarded.
  • Beliefs change after people see new practices work.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the land records case, the main reason agents hung around the gate was that:

    1. Citizens enjoy using agents to deal with the office
    2. Citizens could not track applications and had no receipts
    3. Agents were officially appointed by the office to help
    4. The office was too large for citizens to find the counter
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Without receipts or status information, citizens depended on intermediaries.

  2. 2. Staff at an overcrowded health centre are rude. The weakest response is to:

    1. Request vacant posts to be filled
    2. Use tokens and seating to reduce crowding
    3. Issue a circular on courtesy and do nothing else
    4. Schedule breaks for staff
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Lecturing alone ignores the structural cause: overload and understaffing.

  3. 3. The 'ask why twice' step is meant to:

    1. Reach deeper causes behind a symptom
    2. Delay action while the cause is found out
    3. Blame individuals for the faults in the system
    4. Increase paperwork and the number of records
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Repeated 'why' moves from symptom to underlying cause.

  4. 4. Why should several levers be changed together?

    1. To confuse staff and test their loyalty
    2. To spend more money on the section
    3. Because one change is always enough on its own
    4. So that incentives no longer reward the old behaviour
    Show answer

    Answer: D. If old incentives remain, isolated changes are undone.

  5. 5. Which lever acts on leadership?

    1. Online status tracking for every application
    2. Delegating signatures to lower-level officers
    3. The new head arriving on time and recognising good work
    4. SMS alerts to citizens about their applications
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Example and recognition are leadership levers; the others are process levers.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery