V. N. Bhatkhande's thaats
ThaatAltered notes (all others shuddha)
BilawalNone - all shuddha
KhamajKomal Ni
KafiKomal Ga, Ni
AsavariKomal Ga, Dha, Ni
BhairaviKomal Re, Ga, Dha, Ni
BhairavKomal Re, Dha
KalyanTivra Ma
MarwaKomal Re, tivra Ma
PoorviKomal Re, Dha, tivra Ma
TodiKomal Re, Ga, Dha, tivra Ma
Equivalent scales
ThaatCarnatic melakarta with the same notes
BilawalDheerasankarabharanam (Sankarabharanam)
KhamajHarikambhoji
KafiKharaharapriya
AsavariNatabhairavi
BhairaviHanumatodi
BhairavMayamalavagowla
KalyanMechakalyani (Kalyani)

22 shrutis, 12 positions. 10 thaats. 72 melakartas = 6 Re-Ga pairs x 6 Dha-Ni pairs x 2 Ma. Bilawal = Sankarabharanam; Bhairav = Mayamalavagowla; Kalyan = Kalyani.

Key takeaways: both traditions use 12 positions drawn from the older idea of 22 shrutis. Identify a thaat by its altered notes. The 72 melakartas are every ordered seven-note scale: 6 x 6 x 2. Beware the name trap: Hindustani Bhairavi thaat equals Carnatic Hanumatodi, not a Carnatic 'Bhairavi'.