| Thaat | Altered notes (all others shuddha) |
|---|---|
| Bilawal | None - all shuddha |
| Khamaj | Komal Ni |
| Kafi | Komal Ga, Ni |
| Asavari | Komal Ga, Dha, Ni |
| Bhairavi | Komal Re, Ga, Dha, Ni |
| Bhairav | Komal Re, Dha |
| Kalyan | Tivra Ma |
| Marwa | Komal Re, tivra Ma |
| Poorvi | Komal Re, Dha, tivra Ma |
| Todi | Komal Re, Ga, Dha, tivra Ma |
| Thaat | Carnatic melakarta with the same notes |
|---|---|
| Bilawal | Dheerasankarabharanam (Sankarabharanam) |
| Khamaj | Harikambhoji |
| Kafi | Kharaharapriya |
| Asavari | Natabhairavi |
| Bhairavi | Hanumatodi |
| Bhairav | Mayamalavagowla |
| Kalyan | Mechakalyani (Kalyani) |
22 shrutis, 12 positions. 10 thaats. 72 melakartas = 6 Re-Ga pairs x 6 Dha-Ni pairs x 2 Ma. Bilawal = Sankarabharanam; Bhairav = Mayamalavagowla; Kalyan = Kalyani.
Key takeaways: both traditions use 12 positions drawn from the older idea of 22 shrutis. Identify a thaat by its altered notes. The 72 melakartas are every ordered seven-note scale: 6 x 6 x 2. Beware the name trap: Hindustani Bhairavi thaat equals Carnatic Hanumatodi, not a Carnatic 'Bhairavi'.