- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Shruti, thaat and the 72 melakartas: the two scale systems compared
Work with shrutis and the 12 note positions, identify a thaat from its notes, explain why there are exactly 72 melakartas, and match thaats to their Carnatic equivalents.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, questions move from 'how many thaats are there?' to 'which thaat has komal Re and Dha?' or 'why are there 72 melakartas?'. Both traditions divide the octave the same way; they differ in how they name the notes and organise parent scales. Once the counting logic is clear, these questions become arithmetic.
From 22 shrutis to 12 swara positions
Ancient texts, beginning with the Natya Shastra, describe 22 shrutis in the octave: the finest pitch steps the ear can tell apart. In practice both traditions use 12 note positions (swarasthanas). Sa and Pa are fixed; Re, Ga, Dha and Ni each have two positions and Ma has two. Hindustani music calls the lower forms komal and the raised Ma tivra. Carnatic music numbers its notes - R1, R2, R3, G1, G2, G3, M1, M2, D1, D2, D3, N1, N2, N3 - giving 16 names for 12 positions, because some names share a pitch: R2 = G1, R3 = G2, D2 = N1 and D3 = N2.
The 10 thaats
| Thaat | Altered notes (all others shuddha) |
|---|---|
| Bilawal | None - all shuddha |
| Khamaj | Komal Ni |
| Kafi | Komal Ga, Ni |
| Asavari | Komal Ga, Dha, Ni |
| Bhairavi | Komal Re, Ga, Dha, Ni |
| Bhairav | Komal Re, Dha |
| Kalyan | Tivra Ma |
| Marwa | Komal Re, tivra Ma |
| Poorvi | Komal Re, Dha, tivra Ma |
| Todi | Komal Re, Ga, Dha, tivra Ma |
Every thaat has seven notes in order and is a way of grouping ragas; a raga is placed in the thaat whose notes it uses. The system is a classification tool, and some ragas fit it only loosely.
The 72 melakartas
A melakarta is a Carnatic parent scale with all seven notes in strict order in both ascent and descent. The scheme generates every possible such scale from the 12 positions. The first 36 melakartas use shuddha madhyama (M1) and the last 36 use prati madhyama (M2). Ragas derived from a melakarta are called janya ragas.
Worked example 1: why exactly 72?
Working: Re and Ga must be chosen so that Ga is not below Re. The possible pairs are R1-G1, R1-G2, R1-G3, R2-G2, R2-G3 and R3-G3: 6 pairs. Dha and Ni follow the same rule: D1-N1, D1-N2, D1-N3, D2-N2, D2-N3, D3-N3: 6 pairs. Each Re-Ga pair can go with each Dha-Ni pair: 6 x 6 = 36. Each of these can take M1 or M2: 36 x 2 = 72.
Worked example 2: name the thaat
Question: A raga uses komal Re and komal Dha, with all other notes shuddha. To which thaat does it belong, and what is the Carnatic equivalent scale? Working: from the table, komal Re and Dha alone define Bhairav. Its Carnatic equivalent is Mayamalavagowla - the same raga in which Purandara Dasa's beginner lessons are taught. Answer: Bhairav thaat; Mayamalavagowla.
| Thaat | Carnatic melakarta with the same notes |
|---|---|
| Bilawal | Dheerasankarabharanam (Sankarabharanam) |
| Khamaj | Harikambhoji |
| Kafi | Kharaharapriya |
| Asavari | Natabhairavi |
| Bhairavi | Hanumatodi |
| Bhairav | Mayamalavagowla |
| Kalyan | Mechakalyani (Kalyani) |
22 shrutis, 12 positions. 10 thaats. 72 melakartas = 6 Re-Ga pairs x 6 Dha-Ni pairs x 2 Ma. Bilawal = Sankarabharanam; Bhairav = Mayamalavagowla; Kalyan = Kalyani.
Key takeaways: both traditions use 12 positions drawn from the older idea of 22 shrutis. Identify a thaat by its altered notes. The 72 melakartas are every ordered seven-note scale: 6 x 6 x 2. Beware the name trap: Hindustani Bhairavi thaat equals Carnatic Hanumatodi, not a Carnatic 'Bhairavi'.
Check your understanding
-
1. How many shrutis do ancient texts such as the Natya Shastra describe in an octave?
- 7
- 12
- 22
- 72
Show answer
Answer: C. Ancient texts describe 22 shrutis, the finest pitch steps. In practice 12 note positions are used, and 72 is the number of melakartas.
-
2. Which thaat has tivra Ma with all other notes shuddha?
- Bilawal
- Kalyan
- Khamaj
- Bhairav
Show answer
Answer: B. Kalyan is the thaat with only tivra Ma. Bilawal is all shuddha, Khamaj has komal Ni and Bhairav has komal Re and Dha.
-
3. In the melakarta scheme, the second group of 36 melakartas uses:
- No madhyama at all
- Both forms of madhyama together
- Shuddha madhyama
- Prati madhyama
Show answer
Answer: D. The first 36 melakartas use shuddha madhyama (M1) and the second 36 use prati madhyama (M2); each melakarta has exactly one Ma.
-
4. The Carnatic equivalent of Bilawal thaat, in which all notes are shuddha, is:
- Mayamalavagowla
- Kalyani
- Dheerasankarabharanam
- Kharaharapriya
Show answer
Answer: C. Bilawal and Dheerasankarabharanam (Sankarabharanam) have the same notes. Mayamalavagowla matches Bhairav, Kalyani matches Kalyan and Kharaharapriya matches Kafi.
-
5. Consider: (1) Every melakarta uses all seven notes in both ascent and descent. (2) Bhatkhande's thaat system has 72 parent scales. Which is correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: A. Statement 1 is correct. Statement 2 is wrong: Bhatkhande set out 10 thaats; 72 is the Carnatic melakarta count.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.