- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Hindustani and Carnatic compared: a revision table and common traps
Revise every major difference between Hindustani and Carnatic music in one table and answer statement questions that mix the two traditions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The most common way to test Indian music is to mix the two traditions in one question: a list of terms, instruments or names, some Hindustani and some Carnatic, and you must sort them. A single revision table, learned well, answers most of these. This lesson gives that table and the traps examiners set around it.
The revision table
| Point | Hindustani | Carnatic |
|---|---|---|
| Region | North, central and western India | Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana |
| Influences | Persian and Central Asian, through medieval courts | Developed largely on its own lines, close to temple and devotional song |
| Emphasis | Extended improvisation | Composition-centred; improvisation built around the kriti |
| Ornamentation | Glides (meend) and fast runs (taans) | Gamaka - oscillations and slides on notes - is central |
| System of parent scales | 10 thaats (V. N. Bhatkhande) | 72 melakartas |
| Time of performance | Ragas traditionally tied to times of day and seasons | Time associations much less strict |
| Main vocal forms | Dhrupad, khayal, thumri, tappa, tarana | Kriti, varnam, tillana, ragam-tanam-pallavi |
| Main drums | Tabla, pakhawaj | Mridangam, ghatam, kanjira, thavil |
| Melodic instruments | Sitar, sarod, sarangi, santoor, shehnai, bansuri, rudra veena | Saraswati veena, violin, nadaswaram, flute (venu) |
| Schools | Gharanas (Gwalior, Agra, Kirana, Patiala...) | Lineages of teachers and composers rather than gharanas |
| Shared | Raga, tala, drone (tanpura), guru-shishya learning | Raga, tala, drone (tambura), guru-shishya learning |
Traps examiners set
- Both traditions use ragas. A statement that only one tradition uses raga or tala is false.
- Gharana is a Hindustani term. Kirana, Patiala or Agra never describe a Carnatic singer's school.
- The violin is Carnatic too. It came from Europe but is now the standard melodic accompaniment in Carnatic concerts, where it is played seated, resting between the chest and the foot.
- Barrel drums differ by tradition. The pakhawaj is Hindustani; the mridangam is Carnatic.
- Double reeds differ by tradition. The shehnai is Hindustani; the nadaswaram (with the thavil drum) is Carnatic.
- Thaat and melakarta are not the same number. There are 10 thaats and 72 melakartas.
Worked example 1: sort the list
Question: Sort into Hindustani and Carnatic - khayal, kriti, sarod, mridangam, gharana, tillana, pakhawaj. Working: take each item against the table. Khayal (vocal form, north), sarod (instrument, north), gharana (school, north) and pakhawaj (drum, north) are Hindustani. Kriti, mridangam and tillana are Carnatic. Answer: Hindustani - khayal, sarod, gharana, pakhawaj; Carnatic - kriti, mridangam, tillana.
Worked example 2: a statement question
Question: Consider: (1) Carnatic music organises its parent scales in a scheme of 72 melakartas. (2) Hindustani ragas are traditionally associated with times of day. (3) Carnatic singers are classified into gharanas. Which are correct? Working: (1) true - 72 melakartas. (2) true - the Hindustani time theory links ragas to hours and seasons. (3) false - gharanas belong to Hindustani music. Answer: 1 and 2 only.
Same: raga, tala, drone. North: thaat (10), gharana, tabla and pakhawaj, shehnai. South: melakarta (72), kriti, mridangam, nadaswaram, gamaka.
Key takeaways: learn the table row by row and test each item of a statement separately. Most errors come from moving a term across the line: gharanas to the south, the mridangam to the north, or the nadaswaram and shehnai into each other's tradition.
Check your understanding
-
1. Consider: (1) The gharana system is a feature of Hindustani music. (2) Carnatic music uses a scheme of 72 melakartas. Which is correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: C. Both are correct: gharanas are schools of Hindustani music, and Carnatic music organises its parent scales as 72 melakartas.
-
2. Which statement about the time of performance is correct?
- Hindustani ragas are traditionally linked to particular times of day or seasons
- Carnatic ragas must be performed only at fixed hours
- Neither tradition links ragas to time
- Only folk music links songs to seasons
Show answer
Answer: A. The time theory of ragas is a well-known feature of Hindustani music; in Carnatic music such associations are much less strict.
-
3. The Carnatic double-reed instrument played in temples and at weddings, the counterpart of the northern shehnai, is the:
- Mridangam
- Veena
- Nadaswaram
- Ghatam
Show answer
Answer: C. The nadaswaram is the long double-reed wind instrument of South Indian temples and weddings, usually accompanied by the thavil.
-
4. Compared with Hindustani music, Carnatic music is generally:
- Without any improvisation
- More composition-centred, built around the kriti
- Without ragas
- Played without percussion
Show answer
Answer: B. Carnatic music is more composition-centred, with improvisation built around the kriti. It has ragas, improvisation and rich percussion.
-
5. Which instrument provides the drone in both traditions?
- Tabla
- Shehnai
- Santoor
- Tanpura (tambura)
Show answer
Answer: D. The tanpura, called tambura in the south, plays only the drone notes that support the singer or soloist in both traditions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.