| Point | Hindustani | Carnatic |
|---|---|---|
| Region | North, central and western India | Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana |
| Influences | Persian and Central Asian, through medieval courts | Developed largely on its own lines, close to temple and devotional song |
| Emphasis | Extended improvisation | Composition-centred; improvisation built around the kriti |
| Ornamentation | Glides (meend) and fast runs (taans) | Gamaka - oscillations and slides on notes - is central |
| System of parent scales | 10 thaats (V. N. Bhatkhande) | 72 melakartas |
| Time of performance | Ragas traditionally tied to times of day and seasons | Time associations much less strict |
| Main vocal forms | Dhrupad, khayal, thumri, tappa, tarana | Kriti, varnam, tillana, ragam-tanam-pallavi |
| Main drums | Tabla, pakhawaj | Mridangam, ghatam, kanjira, thavil |
| Melodic instruments | Sitar, sarod, sarangi, santoor, shehnai, bansuri, rudra veena | Saraswati veena, violin, nadaswaram, flute (venu) |
| Schools | Gharanas (Gwalior, Agra, Kirana, Patiala...) | Lineages of teachers and composers rather than gharanas |
| Shared | Raga, tala, drone (tanpura), guru-shishya learning | Raga, tala, drone (tambura), guru-shishya learning |
Same: raga, tala, drone. North: thaat (10), gharana, tabla and pakhawaj, shehnai. South: melakarta (72), kriti, mridangam, nadaswaram, gamaka.
Key takeaways: learn the table row by row and test each item of a statement separately. Most errors come from moving a term across the line: gharanas to the south, the mridangam to the north, or the nadaswaram and shehnai into each other's tradition.