- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Statement and assertion-reason questions on natural vegetation
Learn how to judge several statements, and how to test an assertion and its reason separately, using vegetation examples with full reasoning.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many exam questions on vegetation do not ask you to name a forest. They give two or three statements, or an assertion with a reason, and ask which are correct. These questions reward careful reading more than extra facts. The method has two moves: judge each statement separately, then look for the traps in the wording.
Move 1: judge each statement on its own
Take each statement, decide True or False, and only then look at the options. Do not let a tempting option influence your judgement of a statement. Watch for words such as all, only, always and never, since one exception makes them false. Words such as generally, mostly or usually make a statement safer.
Worked example 1: three statements
Question: Consider the statements. (1) Deciduous trees shed their leaves in the dry season to reduce water loss. (2) Mangroves have breathing roots called pneumatophores. (3) Alpine meadows lie below the coniferous forests on a Himalayan slope. Which are correct? Working: statement 1 is true, because shedding leaves reduces transpiration. Statement 2 is true, as breathing roots rise above the water in waterlogged mud. Statement 3 is false, since alpine meadows lie above the coniferous belt, near the tree line. Answer: 1 and 2 only.
Move 2: assertion and reason
In an assertion-reason question you decide three things in order. First, is the assertion (A) true? Second, is the reason (R) true? Third, if both are true, does R actually explain A? Only then can you choose 'both true and R is the correct explanation'.
| Case | What it means |
|---|---|
| A true, R true, R explains A | The reason gives the cause of the assertion |
| A true, R true, R does not explain A | Both are facts, but they are not linked as cause and effect |
| A true, R false | The assertion is a fact, the reason is wrong |
| A false, R true | The assertion is wrong, the reason is a true fact |
Worked example 2: A true and R explains it
Assertion: The windward slopes of the Western Ghats have evergreen forests. Reason: They receive very heavy rainfall from the south-west monsoon winds. Working: the assertion is true. The reason is also true, and heavy rain with no dry season is exactly what evergreen forests need. So the reason explains the assertion. Answer: both true and R is the correct explanation.
Worked example 3: A true, R false
Assertion: Thorn forests have thick, waxy stems and deep roots. Reason: Thorn forests receive very heavy rainfall. Working: the assertion is true, since these are adaptations to dryness. The reason is false, because thorn forests grow where rainfall is low. Answer: A is true but R is false.
Worked example 4: both true but unrelated
Assertion: Mangroves grow along deltas. Reason: Teak is a valuable timber tree. Working: both statements are true facts, but the value of teak says nothing about why mangroves grow on deltas. Answer: both true, but R does not explain A.
Typical traps
- A reason can be a true fact and still not explain the assertion.
- An extreme word such as 'only' or 'all' can make an otherwise good statement false.
- A statement may be true of one place but is offered as if true of all places.
- Reverse statements, such as 'the Eastern Ghats are higher than the Western Ghats', are wrong in the same way a map would be wrong.
Judge A. Judge R. Then ask: 'Does R say why A is true?'
Key takeaways
- Decide each statement separately before looking at the options.
- Absolute words are dangerous; hedging words are safer.
- For assertion-reason, test both and then test the link between them.
Check your understanding
-
1. Assertion: Deciduous trees shed leaves in the dry season. Reason: Shedding leaves reduces loss of water. Which is correct?
- Both true; R explains A
- Both true; R does not explain A
- A true; R false
- A false; R true
Show answer
Answer: A. Trees shed leaves to cut transpiration when water is scarce, so the reason explains the assertion.
-
2. Assertion: Thorn forests are found in regions of high rainfall. Reason: Thorny plants lose less water. Which is correct?
- Both true; R explains A
- A false; R true
- A true; R false
- Both false
Show answer
Answer: B. Thorn forests grow where rainfall is low, so the assertion is false. The reason is a true fact about thorny plants.
-
3. Which word makes a statement about vegetation most likely to be false?
- generally
- mostly
- always
- usually
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Always' allows no exceptions, and in geography there are nearly always exceptions.
-
4. Statement: Alpine meadows lie above the tree line. Statement: Conifers are found at the top of the snow zone. Which is correct?
- Both are true
- Only the second is true
- Neither is true
- Only the first is true
Show answer
Answer: D. Alpine meadows lie above the tree line, so the first is true. Conifers are trees and do not grow in the snow zone, so the second is false.
-
5. Assertion: Mangroves have breathing roots. Reason: Teak sheds its leaves in the dry season. The best conclusion is:
- R explains A completely
- A is false and R is true
- Both true; R does not explain A
- R is false while A is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Both statements are true facts, but the teak fact has no bearing on the breathing roots of mangroves.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.