• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Choosing the best mode: load, distance and speed

Learn a simple three-question method for choosing a mode of transport and use the idea of cost per tonne-kilometre in gentle worked examples.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

A farmer, a factory owner and a hospital all need to move things, yet each should choose a different mode of transport. In this lesson you will learn a simple way to decide. The numbers in the examples are made up for practice. They are not real freight rates.

Three questions

Before choosing a mode, ask three questions. What is being carried? Heavy coal, fresh flowers and crude oil need very different handling. How far must it go? A short trip suits a truck, while a long trip may suit a train or a ship. How soon must it arrive? Medicines in an emergency cannot wait for a slow cargo ship.

Matching the answers to a mode
LoadDistanceTimeBest choice
Heavy, bulky, not urgentLongCan waitShip or rail
Light, valuable or perishableLongUrgentAir
Mixed goods from door to doorShort or mediumSoonRoad
Oil or gas, steady flowAny fixed routeContinuousPipeline

Cost per tonne-kilometre

To compare modes fairly, transport planners use the tonne-kilometre. One tonne carried for one kilometre is one tonne-kilometre. Multiply the weight in tonnes by the distance in kilometres to get the total. Then multiply by the cost of one tonne-kilometre to find the bill. Roads usually cost more per tonne-kilometre than railways, and water usually costs least, but road wins when goods must go from door to door.

Worked example 1: cost of two modes

A mill must send 200 tonnes of sugar a distance of 500 km. Suppose, only for practice, that road costs Rs 1.50 per tonne-kilometre and rail costs Rs 0.50. Step 1: total tonne-kilometres = 200 x 500 = 100,000. Step 2: road cost = 100,000 x 1.50 = Rs 150,000. Step 3: rail cost = 100,000 x 0.50 = Rs 50,000. Rail saves Rs 100,000, so for this bulky, long-distance, non-urgent load rail is the better choice.

Worked example 2: journey time

Average speed is distance divided by time, so time is distance divided by speed. A goods train averages 50 km/h over 600 km: time = 600 / 50 = 12 hours. A truck averaging 40 km/h over the same 600 km takes 600 / 40 = 15 hours. The train is faster here, but remember that the train also needs time to reach the station and to unload. If the goods must reach a shop's door, the truck may still save effort.

Worked example 3: three cargoes

  • 5,000 tonnes of iron ore to a seaport 800 km away: heavy, long, not urgent, so rail (and then ship).
  • A small box of life-saving medicine to a cut-off hill town: light, urgent, difficult terrain, so air.
  • Vegetables from a village to a market 30 km away: short, perishable, door to door, so road.

Ask three questions: what, how far, how soon. Heavy and slow, use rail or ship. Light and urgent, use air. Door to door, use road.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Choose a mode by load, distance and time.
  • Tonne-kilometres = tonnes x kilometres; cost = tonne-kilometres x rate.
  • Time = distance / speed.
  • No mode is best for everything; the cargo decides.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which mode is usually cheapest per tonne for a very heavy, non-urgent cargo sent across an ocean?

    1. Air transport
    2. Ship transport
    3. Road transport
    4. Cycle carts
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Water transport is cheapest for heavy and bulky goods, and ocean routes link countries. Air is the costliest and roads are not suited to oceans.

  2. 2. A lorry carries 50 tonnes over 200 km. How many tonne-kilometres is that?

    1. 250
    2. 4
    3. 1,000
    4. 10,000
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Tonne-kilometres = tonnes x kilometres = 50 x 200 = 10,000.

  3. 3. At Rs 0.50 per tonne-kilometre, what does it cost to move 100 tonnes over 300 km (a made-up rate)?

    1. Rs 15,000
    2. Rs 1,500
    3. Rs 150,000
    4. Rs 150
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Tonne-kilometres = 100 x 300 = 30,000. Cost = 30,000 x 0.50 = Rs 15,000.

  4. 4. A train averages 60 km/h on a 480 km journey. How long does the journey take?

    1. 6 hours
    2. 10 hours
    3. 8 hours
    4. 12 hours
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Time = distance / speed = 480 / 60 = 8 hours.

  5. 5. Fresh flowers must reach a far-away city the same day. Which mode is the best fit?

    1. Air transport
    2. Goods train
    3. Cargo ship
    4. Pipeline
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The flowers are light, perishable and urgent, and a long distance is involved. Air is fastest. Trains and ships are too slow, and a pipeline carries only fluids.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery