- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Choosing the best mode: load, distance and speed
Learn a simple three-question method for choosing a mode of transport and use the idea of cost per tonne-kilometre in gentle worked examples.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A farmer, a factory owner and a hospital all need to move things, yet each should choose a different mode of transport. In this lesson you will learn a simple way to decide. The numbers in the examples are made up for practice. They are not real freight rates.
Three questions
Before choosing a mode, ask three questions. What is being carried? Heavy coal, fresh flowers and crude oil need very different handling. How far must it go? A short trip suits a truck, while a long trip may suit a train or a ship. How soon must it arrive? Medicines in an emergency cannot wait for a slow cargo ship.
| Load | Distance | Time | Best choice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heavy, bulky, not urgent | Long | Can wait | Ship or rail |
| Light, valuable or perishable | Long | Urgent | Air |
| Mixed goods from door to door | Short or medium | Soon | Road |
| Oil or gas, steady flow | Any fixed route | Continuous | Pipeline |
Cost per tonne-kilometre
To compare modes fairly, transport planners use the tonne-kilometre. One tonne carried for one kilometre is one tonne-kilometre. Multiply the weight in tonnes by the distance in kilometres to get the total. Then multiply by the cost of one tonne-kilometre to find the bill. Roads usually cost more per tonne-kilometre than railways, and water usually costs least, but road wins when goods must go from door to door.
Worked example 1: cost of two modes
A mill must send 200 tonnes of sugar a distance of 500 km. Suppose, only for practice, that road costs Rs 1.50 per tonne-kilometre and rail costs Rs 0.50. Step 1: total tonne-kilometres = 200 x 500 = 100,000. Step 2: road cost = 100,000 x 1.50 = Rs 150,000. Step 3: rail cost = 100,000 x 0.50 = Rs 50,000. Rail saves Rs 100,000, so for this bulky, long-distance, non-urgent load rail is the better choice.
Worked example 2: journey time
Average speed is distance divided by time, so time is distance divided by speed. A goods train averages 50 km/h over 600 km: time = 600 / 50 = 12 hours. A truck averaging 40 km/h over the same 600 km takes 600 / 40 = 15 hours. The train is faster here, but remember that the train also needs time to reach the station and to unload. If the goods must reach a shop's door, the truck may still save effort.
Worked example 3: three cargoes
- 5,000 tonnes of iron ore to a seaport 800 km away: heavy, long, not urgent, so rail (and then ship).
- A small box of life-saving medicine to a cut-off hill town: light, urgent, difficult terrain, so air.
- Vegetables from a village to a market 30 km away: short, perishable, door to door, so road.
Ask three questions: what, how far, how soon. Heavy and slow, use rail or ship. Light and urgent, use air. Door to door, use road.
Key takeaways
- Choose a mode by load, distance and time.
- Tonne-kilometres = tonnes x kilometres; cost = tonne-kilometres x rate.
- Time = distance / speed.
- No mode is best for everything; the cargo decides.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which mode is usually cheapest per tonne for a very heavy, non-urgent cargo sent across an ocean?
- Air transport
- Ship transport
- Road transport
- Cycle carts
Show answer
Answer: B. Water transport is cheapest for heavy and bulky goods, and ocean routes link countries. Air is the costliest and roads are not suited to oceans.
-
2. A lorry carries 50 tonnes over 200 km. How many tonne-kilometres is that?
- 250
- 4
- 1,000
- 10,000
Show answer
Answer: D. Tonne-kilometres = tonnes x kilometres = 50 x 200 = 10,000.
-
3. At Rs 0.50 per tonne-kilometre, what does it cost to move 100 tonnes over 300 km (a made-up rate)?
- Rs 15,000
- Rs 1,500
- Rs 150,000
- Rs 150
Show answer
Answer: A. Tonne-kilometres = 100 x 300 = 30,000. Cost = 30,000 x 0.50 = Rs 15,000.
-
4. A train averages 60 km/h on a 480 km journey. How long does the journey take?
- 6 hours
- 10 hours
- 8 hours
- 12 hours
Show answer
Answer: C. Time = distance / speed = 480 / 60 = 8 hours.
-
5. Fresh flowers must reach a far-away city the same day. Which mode is the best fit?
- Air transport
- Goods train
- Cargo ship
- Pipeline
Show answer
Answer: A. The flowers are light, perishable and urgent, and a long distance is involved. Air is fastest. Trains and ships are too slow, and a pipeline carries only fluids.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.