- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Who lived when: lifespans, overlaps and time-gap problems
Solve hard sequence problems by working out lifespans, gaps and overlaps, and test whether two people or events could have been connected.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Hard questions on personalities do not ask for a single date. They ask whether two people could have met, whether an event happened in someone's lifetime, or how long a mission lasted. These need arithmetic on the dates you already know. This lesson shows the method, with the dates of the Portuguese-era figures at its centre.
The data
| Person | Dates to use | Span |
|---|---|---|
| Francis Xavier | In Goa from 1542; died 1552 | 10 years of work in Asia |
| Thomas Stephens | In Goa from 1579; Krista Purana printed 1616 | 37 years from arrival to the poem |
| Joseph Vaz | Born 1651; Sri Lanka 1687; died 1711 | 60 years of life |
| Abbe Faria | Born 1756; Pinto conspiracy 1787; died 1819 | 63 years of life |
Method: three checks
Three checks for an overlap problem
- Write the span Birth to death, or arrival to departure
- Draw the line Mark the second event on the same line
- Compare Is the event inside the span?
Take Xavier and the Goa Inquisition, which began in 1560. Xavier's span in Asia ended with his death in 1552. The event is eight years after the span, so Xavier was not alive when the Inquisition was set up. Now take Faria and the Pinto conspiracy of 1787. Faria was born in 1756, so he was thirty-one in 1787 and the event falls inside his lifetime. This explains why his name is linked with the plot in some accounts.
Could they have met?
Two people could have met only if their lifespans overlap. Vaz died in 1711 and Faria was born in 1756, so they never met; the gap is forty-five years. Stephens arrived in 1579 and Vaz was born in 1651, so Stephens's working life in Goa had ended long before Vaz was born. Vaz and Xavier were separated by nearly a century. When a question suggests a conversation between two of these, check the overlap before anything else.
Counting years inclusive and exclusive
When asked how long someone lived or worked, subtract the earlier year from the later. Xavier in Asia: 1552 minus 1542 is 10. Vaz in his Sri Lankan mission, from 1687 to 1711: 1711 minus 1687 is 24 years. Examiners do not usually add one, so do not do so unless the question says 'counting both years'.
A longer problem
Try one that joins several dates. A student claims that Xavier, Stephens and Vaz were all in Goa in 1600. Check each against the data. Xavier died in 1552, so he was not. Stephens had arrived in 1579 and was still working in 1616, so he was. Vaz was born in 1651, so he was not yet born. Only Stephens fits. The point of such a problem is not the answer itself but the habit: take each person separately, compare the year with the span, and write down yes or no. A neat table of three rows takes under a minute and prevents the common error of accepting a sentence because every name in it sounds familiar. In the same way, you can test claims about the freedom era, such as whether Cunha was alive in 1946 or whether Lohia was in Goa in 1928; for those, rely only on what the question tells you.
Worked example 1: lifespan
Question: 'For how many years did Abbe Faria live?' Working: 1819 minus 1756 is 63 years.
Worked example 2: overlap
Question: 'Could Joseph Vaz have attended the ceremony in which Xavier was declared a saint?' Working: the ceremony was in 1622, and Vaz was born in 1651. He was born 29 years after it. Answer: no.
Worked example 3: gap between a mission and a poem
Question: 'By how many years did the Krista Purana (1616) follow Stephens's arrival in Goa (1579)?' Working: 1616 minus 1579 is 37 years.
Worked example 4: an event within a life
Question: 'Was Vaz alive in 1695?' Working: he lived from 1651 to 1711, and 1695 lies between them. Answer: yes. He was in Sri Lanka at the time, and a question that places him in Goa that year would be asking for something we cannot assume.
Write the span, mark the event, compare. Overlap means the spans share years.
Key takeaways: always turn a story question into a time line. Lifespans, gaps and overlaps need only subtraction, but only if the dates are right.
Check your understanding
-
1. Faria lived from 1756 to 1819. How old was he at the time of the Pinto conspiracy (1787)?
- 30
- 31
- 63
- 24
Show answer
Answer: B. 1787 minus 1756 is 31.
-
2. Could Xavier have been alive when the Goa Inquisition began in 1560?
- Yes, he was in Goa that year
- Yes, he returned from Japan
- No, he had not reached Goa
- No, he died in 1552
Show answer
Answer: D. His death in 1552 was eight years before 1560.
-
3. How long was Joseph Vaz's mission period from 1687 to his death?
- 24 years
- 12 years
- 37 years
- 60 years
Show answer
Answer: A. 1711 minus 1687 is 24.
-
4. Which pair could never have met?
- Stephens and Xavier
- Xavier and the Basilica of Bom Jesus
- Vaz and Faria
- Faria and the Pinto conspiracy
Show answer
Answer: C. Vaz died in 1711 and Faria was born in 1756, so their lives did not overlap.
-
5. The gap between Xavier's sainthood (1622) and Vaz's sainthood (2015) is:
- 293 years
- 363 years
- 393 years
- 425 years
Show answer
Answer: C. 2015 minus 1622 is 393.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.