- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Language and the Constitution: Goa as a case study
Link Goa's language choices to Articles 343, 345, 29, 350A and 351 and the Eighth Schedule, and answer statement and assertion-reason questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions rarely ask a date alone. They ask you to connect a fact about Goa with a rule of the Constitution. This lesson builds that link. The aim is not to memorise many articles, but to know five of them well and to see exactly what each one does and does not do.
Five provisions and their jobs
| Provision | What it does | Link with Goa |
|---|---|---|
| Article 343 | Hindi in Devanagari is the official language of the Union | Union level; not Goa's state language |
| Article 345 | A state legislature may adopt one or more languages for the state's official purposes | Basis for choosing Konkani in 1987 |
| Article 29(1) | A section of citizens with a distinct language, script or culture has the right to conserve it | Supports the keeping of Konkani, its scripts and its culture |
| Article 350A | Facilities for instruction in the mother tongue at the primary stage for children of linguistic minorities | Concerns instruction, not official status |
| Article 351 | A directive to promote the spread of Hindi | Directive for the Union |
The Eighth Schedule is a list. It is referred to in the articles on the Official Language Commission and on the development of Hindi, and it records the languages that the Constitution recognises. Being listed does not by itself make a language the official language of any state. Konkani's place in the list came in 1992, five years after Goa chose it as its own official language.
Two ways a language is recognised
-
By the state
- Under Article 345
- Goa's Act of 1987
- Konkani in Devanagari
- Marathi allowed for official purposes
-
By the Constitution
- Eighth Schedule
- Added in 1992
- Does not itself fix a state's language
- Recognition at the national level
Reading the logic of the case
Goa's story shows the two levels working one after the other. First the people of Goa and their elected representatives decided, through a law, what language the state would use. Then the Constitution itself recognised Konkani among its listed languages. The order matters for exam logic: the state act did not wait for the listing, and the listing did not replace the state act.
Worked example 1: find the article
Question: which provision most directly gave Goa the power to adopt Konkani for official work? Working: the power of a state legislature to adopt a state's language for official purposes is in Article 345. Article 343 deals with the Union. The answer is Article 345.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: Konkani's listing in the Eighth Schedule made it the official language of Goa. Reason: the Schedule lists languages recognised by the Constitution. Working: the reason is true. The assertion is false, because Goa's own Act of 1987 had already made Konkani official, and listing does not by itself fix a state's official language. So A is false and R is true.
Worked example 3: protect or instruct
Question: a Konkani-speaking community in another state wants primary classes in its mother tongue. Which provision speaks to this? Working: Article 350A deals with facilities for instruction in the mother tongue at the primary stage for linguistic minority children. Article 29(1) speaks of the right to conserve a distinct language, script or culture. For primary instruction, choose 350A.
Worked example 4: the sequence
Question: which came first: Konkani's listing in the Eighth Schedule or its adoption as Goa's official language? Working: the adoption in 1987 came first. The listing followed in 1992.
Where students lose marks
The commonest loss is to read Article 345 as the article that gives a language its status in the whole country. It does not. It lets a state legislature choose for the state's own official purposes. A second loss is to treat Article 29(1) as a rule about official work. It protects the right of a group to conserve its own language, script or culture, which is a different matter from the language of government. A third loss is to forget that the Eighth Schedule is a list. Each of these errors comes from remembering a word without remembering the job. When you revise, say the job of each provision in one short phrase: Union language, state language, conserve, primary mother-tongue teaching, spread of Hindi.
Worked example 5: Question: a club of Konkani speakers says its script and culture must be protected. Which provision fits best, and does it make Konkani an official language anywhere? Working: Article 29(1) fits, as it protects a group's right to conserve its language, script or culture. It does not make any language official. Official status in Goa came from the Act of 1987.
Article 345 chooses a state's language. The Eighth Schedule lists recognised languages. They are different things.
Key takeaways: Know the five provisions and their jobs. Keep state choice and national listing apart. Test every assertion-reason pair for each part separately.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which provision lets a state legislature adopt a language for official purposes?
- Article 343
- Article 345
- Article 350A
- Article 351
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 345.
-
2. Assertion: Konkani became Goa's official language because of the Eighth Schedule. Reason: the Schedule lists recognised languages. Which is correct?
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: D. The Act of 1987 made Konkani official; the Schedule step came in 1992.
-
3. Article 350A is about...
- instruction in the mother tongue at the primary stage for linguistic minority children
- official language of the Union
- the right to conserve language, script or culture
- the promotion of Hindi
Show answer
Answer: A. That is Article 350A.
-
4. Which of these is concerned with a group's right to conserve its language, script or culture?
- Article 343
- Article 345
- Article 29(1)
- Article 351
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 29(1).
-
5. Which statement is correct?
- The Schedule listing came in 1987
- Article 343 gives Goa its language
- Goa's Act came before the Schedule listing of Konkani
- Article 351 makes Konkani official
Show answer
Answer: C. 1987 then 1992.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.