- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
From princely states to statehood: what each status meant
Explain the constitutional route by which Gujarat was created, using Articles 3 and 4, the categories of states in 1950 and the changes of 1956.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions on the making of Gujarat do not ask for dates alone. They ask what a status meant, which Article allowed the change and whether the Constitution had to be amended. This lesson builds that reasoning, using statement and assertion-reason forms.
The categories of 1950
| Category | Who headed it | Examples linked to Gujarat |
|---|---|---|
| Part A | Governor with an elected government | Bombay |
| Part B | Rajpramukh, usually a former ruler, with an elected government | Saurashtra |
| Part C | Administered by a head chosen by the President | Kutch |
The Seventh Amendment, 1956, did away with the Part A, B and C classification. From November 1956 there were only States and Union Territories. The Governor became the head of each state, and the post of Rajpramukh ended.
Article 3 and Article 4
Article 3 gives Parliament, by ordinary law, the power to form a new state, to increase or reduce the area of a state, to alter its boundaries and to alter its name. Two conditions apply. A bill under Article 3 can be introduced only on the recommendation of the President, and where it affects the area, boundaries or name of a state, the President must refer it to that state's legislature to give its views. Parliament is not bound by those views. Article 4 says that such a law is not an amendment of the Constitution for the purpose of Article 368, so it needs only a simple majority in Parliament and not the special majority.
Route of a law under Article 3
- President's recommendation Bill may be introduced in Parliament
- Reference to the state legislature Views are obtained
- Parliament debates Views are not binding
- Passed by simple majority Article 4: not an amendment under Article 368
The Bombay Reorganisation Act, 1960 is the law of this kind that divided Bombay State. The 1956 Act came together with the Seventh Amendment, because abolishing categories changed the Constitution's own text, while the redrawing of boundaries only needed an ordinary law.
Worked example 1: statement question
Statement I: Parliament can create a state by ordinary law. Statement II: Parliament must accept the view of the state legislature. Working: I is true (Article 3). II is false, because the views are asked for but not binding. So only I is correct.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: the creation of Gujarat needed no amendment under Article 368. Reason: Article 4 says laws under Article 3 are not amendments for the purpose of Article 368. Working: both are true and the reason explains the assertion, so the answer is that R correctly explains A.
Worked example 3: match
Match Saurashtra, Kutch and Bombay with Part B, Part C and Part A. Working: Saurashtra went with Part B because it had a Rajpramukh; Kutch went with Part C, the centrally administered class; Bombay was a Part A state. So Saurashtra with B, Kutch with C, Bombay with A.
Article 3: Parliament forms or alters states by law. Article 4: not an Article 368 amendment. 1956: Part A, B, C ended.
Key takeaways: Part A, B and C were abolished in 1956. Article 3 lets Parliament create states by ordinary law, with the state legislature's views obtained but not binding. Article 4 keeps such a law outside Article 368. Gujarat was created by this route in 1960.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statement I: A bill under Article 3 needs the President's recommendation. Statement II: Parliament is bound by the state legislature's views. Which is correct?
- Only I is correct
- Only II is correct
- Both I and II are correct
- Neither I nor II is correct
Show answer
Answer: A. I is true: the recommendation is required. II is false: the views are only sought, and Parliament may differ.
-
2. Assertion (A): Gujarat's creation in 1960 needed a special majority under Article 368. Reason (R): Article 4 declares that laws under Article 3 are not amendments for Article 368.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: D. A is false: the law needed only a simple majority. R is true and is exactly why no special majority was needed.
-
3. The Seventh Amendment, 1956 is linked to:
- setting up panchayats
- creating the High Court of Gujarat
- abolishing the Part A, B and C classification of states
- fixing the age of Governors
Show answer
Answer: C. The amendment replaced the old categories with states and Union Territories.
-
4. Arrange in order: I Saurashtra is formed. II The Constitution begins. III Saurashtra and Kutch join Bombay State. IV Gujarat is formed.
- II, I, III, IV
- I, II, III, IV
- I, III, II, IV
- II, III, I, IV
Show answer
Answer: B. Saurashtra was formed in 1948, the Constitution began in 1950, the merger was in 1956 and Gujarat in 1960.
-
5. Which match is correct?
- Saurashtra, Part C; Kutch, Part B; Bombay, Part A
- Saurashtra, Part A; Kutch, Part C; Bombay, Part B
- Saurashtra, Part B; Kutch, Part C; Bombay, Part A
- Saurashtra, Part B; Kutch, Part A; Bombay, Part C
Show answer
Answer: C. Saurashtra was Part B, Kutch Part C and Bombay Part A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.