- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The Legislature and the Judiciary: Articles and traps
Link the Articles on the state legislature, Speaker, financial business and High Court to their subjects, and avoid typical Supreme Court and High Court mix-ups.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The legislature and the judiciary are both full of numbers in the Constitution. The numbers themselves are the exam. This lesson pairs each one with its idea and shows where students go wrong.
Legislature: the map
| Article | Subject |
|---|---|
| 168 | Legislature of a state: Governor and the House or Houses |
| 170 | Composition of Assemblies: not more than 500 and not less than 60 members |
| 172 | Duration: five years from the first sitting |
| 173 | Qualification: citizen and at least 25 years |
| 174 | Sessions; six-month gap rule |
| 178 | Speaker and Deputy Speaker |
| 200 | Assent to bills |
| 202 | Annual financial statement (budget) |
| 213 | Ordinance-making power |
Gujarat's Vidhan Sabha has 182 seats, within the limits of Article 170. Gujarat has no Legislative Council, so the Governor and the Vidhan Sabha together make up the legislature.
Judiciary: the map
| Article | Subject |
|---|---|
| 214 | A High Court for each state |
| 216 | Chief Justice and other judges |
| 217 | Appointment of judges; retirement at 62 |
| 226 | Writ power of High Courts |
| 227 | Superintendence over courts within the territory |
| 233 | Appointment of district judges by the Governor |
| 235 | Control over subordinate courts |
High Court and Supreme Court writs
-
High Court, Article 226
- Fundamental rights
- And any other purpose
- Within its territory
-
Supreme Court, Article 32
- Fundamental rights only
- A right in itself
- Whole of India
Traps
- Governor is part of the legislature. Under Article 168 the Governor is included with the House. Saying the legislature is only the Vidhan Sabha misses this.
- Retirement ages. High Court judges retire at 62; Supreme Court judges at 65. A decoy of 60 or 65 is common.
- Who appoints district judges. The Governor, in consultation with the High Court, not the Chief Minister.
- 226 versus 32. The High Court's power is wider, since it can reach beyond fundamental rights.
- Capital versus court. Gujarat's High Court is at Ahmedabad; the Vidhan Sabha meets at Gandhinagar.
A memory method
Use the sequence '214 sets up, 217 appoints, 226 writs'. For the legislature use '170 size, 172 life, 173 age, 174 sessions'. These rhyme with the order in the Constitution so one number recalls the next.
Worked example 1: the sessions rule
Question: a session ends on 5 April. What is the latest day for the next sitting? Working: Article 174 says six months may not intervene between the last sitting of one session and the first sitting of the next. Six months after 5 April is 5 October. So the House must meet by 5 October.
Worked example 2: choose the answer
Question: 'Who appoints the district judges of Gujarat?' Working: under Article 233, district judges are appointed by the Governor in consultation with the High Court. The Chief Minister has no such role. The answer is the Governor.
Worked example 3: retirement age
Question: a High Court judge was born on 1 June 1970. In which year does the judge retire? Working: the retirement age is 62, so the year is 1970 plus 62, which is 2032. A decoy using the Supreme Court's age of 65 would give 2035. The key is to use the right age for the right court.
214 sets up, 217 appoints and retires at 62, 226 writs. 172 life, 173 age 25, 174 six months.
Key takeaways: the Governor is part of the legislature; Gujarat's is a one-House body; the High Court's writ power in Article 226 is wider than the Supreme Court's in Article 32; High Court judges retire at 62; district judges are appointed by the Governor with the High Court's consultation.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Article provides for a High Court for each state?
- Article 214
- Article 217
- Article 226
- Article 233
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 214 sets up the High Court. Article 217 concerns appointment and Article 226 writs.
-
2. At what age does a High Court judge retire?
- 60
- 62
- 65
- 58
Show answer
Answer: B. High Court judges retire at 62; Supreme Court judges at 65.
-
3. Who appoints the district judges?
- The President
- The Chief Minister
- The Governor, in consultation with the High Court
- The Speaker
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 233 gives this power to the Governor, after consulting the High Court.
-
4. Under Article 168 the legislature of Gujarat consists of:
- the Vidhan Sabha alone
- the Governor, Vidhan Sabha and Legislative Council
- the Vidhan Sabha and the High Court
- the Governor and the Vidhan Sabha
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 168 includes the Governor. Gujarat has no Council.
-
5. A High Court can issue writs for:
- fundamental rights and any other purpose
- only fundamental rights
- only civil cases
- only matters sent by the Governor
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 226 gives the High Court a wider writ power than the Supreme Court's Article 32.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.