• Advanced
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

The state executive and legislature: who holds which power

Distinguish the Governor, Chief Minister, Council of Ministers, Vidhan Sabha and High Court of Haryana, and solve statement and assertion-reason questions on ordinances, collective responsibility and the shared High Court.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Government questions on Haryana are rarely about Haryana alone. They test whether you can apply the constitutional pattern of a state to Haryana's own facts: one chamber, a Governor, a Chief Minister, and a High Court that happens to be shared. The reasoning skill is to separate who holds the power in form from who uses it in practice.

The executive: form and practice

The Governor of Haryana is appointed by the President (Article 155 is the appointment article, but you need only the principle). The executive power of the state is formally vested in the Governor (Article 154), yet the Governor acts on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister (Article 163). The Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor, who invites the person able to command a majority in the Vidhan Sabha, and the other ministers are appointed on the Chief Minister's advice (Article 164). The Council is collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha: if the Assembly withdraws its confidence, the whole Council must go.

From the voter to the government

  1. Voters elect members Direct election to the Vidhan Sabha
  2. Governor invites the leader who commands a majority
  3. Chief Minister appointed
  4. Council of Ministers appointed on the CM's advice
  5. Collective responsibility to the Vidhan Sabha
Form: Governor appoints. Substance: the majority decides.

The legislature: one chamber

Haryana has a unicameral legislature, the Vidhan Sabha, with 90 directly elected members. It has no Vidhan Parishad, that is, no upper house, which a state may create only by a special procedure. A question that asks for the 'upper house of Haryana' is therefore a trap. The Governor summons the House, prorogues it and can dissolve it.

When the House is not in session and urgent action is needed, the Governor may promulgate an ordinance (Article 213). It has the force of a law but must be placed before the Vidhan Sabha when it reassembles, and it ceases to operate six weeks after reassembly unless passed or withdrawn earlier. A person who is not a member of the House can be made Chief Minister or minister but must be elected within six months (Article 164(4)).

A High Court shared by two states

The Punjab and Haryana High Court sits at Chandigarh and serves both states and the Union Territory. The Constitution allows a common High Court for two or more states (Article 231), and the 1966 Reorganisation Act kept one for the two new states. The court's power to issue writs for fundamental rights and other purposes comes from Article 226. Its seat in Chandigarh is not in Haryana, because Chandigarh is a Union Territory.

AuthorityConstitutional roleCommon trap
GovernorFormal head of the executive; appoints the CM; promulgates ordinancesNot elected by the people; does not run the departments personally
Chief MinisterHeads the Council of MinistersNot appointed by the Assembly's Speaker
Council of MinistersTakes the decisions and answers to the AssemblyResponsible to the Vidhan Sabha, not the Governor
Vidhan SabhaMakes state laws; the only HouseNo upper house
High CourtJudicial review and writs; shared with PunjabSeat is in Chandigarh, outside Haryana's territory

Worked example 1: the ordinance question

Question: The Vidhan Sabha reassembles on 1 March. By what date, at the latest, will an ordinance issued in January lapse if the House does not pass it? Working: The ordinance lapses six weeks (42 days) after reassembly. From 1 March, six weeks takes us to 12 April in a non-leap year (March has 31 days: 1 March + 31 days = 1 April, plus 11 days = 12 April). Answer: 12 April. The point is the six-week rule counted from reassembly, not from the issue date.

Worked example 2: collective responsibility

Question: The Vidhan Sabha passes a motion of no confidence in the Council of Ministers. Must only the Chief Minister resign, or the whole Council? Working: Article 164 makes the Council collectively responsible to the House. The Council is one team: if the House withdraws its confidence, the Chief Minister and all ministers go together, because the Council as a body has lost the majority. Answer: the whole Council. The mistake to avoid is treating each minister's fate as separate when the vote is against the government.

Worked example 3: the common High Court

Question: (1) A High Court judgment from Chandigarh may bind both Punjab and Haryana. (2) The High Court sits in Haryana's territory. Working: (1) is true because the court is shared. (2) is false because Chandigarh is a Union Territory. Answer: only (1).

Form: the Governor. Substance: the majority in the Vidhan Sabha. Remember that Haryana has one House and shares a High Court.

Key takeaways: The Governor acts on the Council's advice, the Council answers to the Vidhan Sabha, the Vidhan Sabha is the only House, and the High Court is common to two states.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Council of Ministers of Haryana is collectively responsible to

    1. The Governor
    2. The Vidhan Sabha
    3. The President
    4. The High Court
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 164 makes the Council collectively responsible to the Legislative Assembly.

  2. 2. Which statement about the legislature is correct?

    1. It has a Vidhan Parishad
    2. It has two directly elected Houses
    3. The Governor is a member of the House
    4. It has only one House, the Vidhan Sabha
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Haryana is unicameral. The Governor summons the House but is not a member of it.

  3. 3. An ordinance issued while the House is not in session ceases to operate how long after the House reassembles, if not passed?

    1. Six weeks
    2. Six months
    3. One week
    4. It never lapses
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 213 provides that an ordinance ceases six weeks after the House reassembles unless it is passed or disapproved earlier.

  4. 4. The Punjab and Haryana High Court sits in

    1. Panipat, Haryana
    2. Ambala, Haryana
    3. Chandigarh, a Union Territory
    4. Hisar, Haryana
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The common High Court sits at Chandigarh, which is a Union Territory shared by the two states.

  5. 5. A person who is not a member of the Vidhan Sabha is appointed Chief Minister. Within what period must he or she be elected?

    1. One month
    2. One year
    3. Six months
    4. There is no limit
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Article 164(4) allows six months for a non-member minister to become a member.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery