- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Governor, Chief Minister and council: who appoints whom
Trace the chain from President to Governor to Chief Minister to ministers, with the articles, ages and terms that examiners swap.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The state executive is the most testable part of Haryana's government, but the rules are the ones shared by every Indian state. Haryana's own facts are few: it began on 1 November 1966, its first Chief Minister was Bhagwat Dayal Sharma, and its capital is Chandigarh. The rest of the lesson is a chain of appointments, and the trick is to hold the chain in order.
The chain of appointment
Who appoints whom
- President Appoints the Governor of the state
- Governor Appoints the Chief Minister
- Chief Minister Heads the council of ministers; ministers are appointed on the Chief Minister's advice
- Council of ministers Collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha
Revision table: articles and rules
| Point | Rule | Trap |
|---|---|---|
| Governor appointed by | The President | Not the Chief Minister, and not elected |
| Article 153 | Each state shall have a Governor | Not Article 52, which is for the President |
| Minimum age of Governor | 35 years (Article 157) | Not 25, which is the age for a member of the Vidhan Sabha |
| Governor's term | Five years in normal terms, but holds office at the President's pleasure (Article 156) | 'Pleasure' means the President can end it earlier |
| Chief Minister appointed by | The Governor (Article 164) | The Governor appoints, but the majority in the Vidhan Sabha decides who can be |
| Council of ministers | Collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha (Article 164) | Not responsible to the Governor |
| Advocate General | Appointed by the Governor (Article 165) | Legal adviser of the state government |
Reading the table
The Governor is the formal head of the state, but normally acts on the advice of the council of ministers. The real power lies with the Chief Minister and the cabinet, who must keep the confidence of the Vidhan Sabha. If the house withdraws its confidence, the government must go. In rare cases of breakdown of the constitutional machinery, Article 356 allows the President to take over, known as President's rule. That is a national provision, not a Haryana one.
Worked example 1: who appoints
Question: The Chief Minister of Haryana is appointed by whom? Working: Article 164 says the Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor, usually the leader who commands a majority. The President appoints the Governor, not the Chief Minister. Answer: the Governor.
Worked example 2: collective responsibility
Question: To whom is the council of ministers of Haryana collectively responsible? Working: Collective responsibility is owed to the elected house. The Governor may appoint, but cannot be the body that holds the ministers to account. Answer: the Vidhan Sabha.
Worked example 3: the age trap
Question: What is the minimum age for a person to be appointed Governor, and what is the minimum age to contest the Vidhan Sabha? Working: Governor 35 (Article 157). Member of the Vidhan Sabha 25 (Article 173). The two numbers are often swapped. Answer: 35 and 25.
Common traps
- Swapped appointer: the President appoints the Governor; the Governor appoints the Chief Minister.
- Wrong article: keep 153 (Governor), 164 (CM and ministers), 165 (Advocate General) together.
- Elected Governor: the Governor is appointed, never elected directly.
- First CM: Bhagwat Dayal Sharma, not a later name.
President appoints Governor. Governor appoints CM. CM heads ministers. Ministers answer to the Vidhan Sabha. Governor 35 (Art. 157); MLA 25 (Art. 173).
Key takeaways: say the appointment chain aloud, then pin each link to its article. Arguments about who the Governor 'really' is are less important than the written rule.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Governor of Haryana is appointed by
- The Vidhan Sabha
- The Chief Justice
- The President of India
- The Chief Minister
Show answer
Answer: C. Under Article 155 the President appoints the Governor. The Chief Minister is appointed by the Governor, not the other way round.
-
2. Which article provides that each state shall have a Governor?
- Article 153
- Article 52
- Article 164
- Article 356
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 153 provides for a Governor of each state. Article 52 is the President, 164 the Chief Minister and ministers, 356 President's rule.
-
3. The minimum age for the Governor is
- 25 years
- 21 years
- 35 years
- 30 years
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 157 sets 35 years for a Governor. 25 is the age for the Vidhan Sabha.
-
4. The council of ministers of Haryana is collectively responsible to the
- Governor
- Vidhan Sabha
- President
- Rajya Sabha
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 164 makes the council collectively responsible to the legislative assembly.
-
5. Who was the first Chief Minister of Haryana?
- Hukam Singh
- Bhagwat Dayal Sharma
- Gaya Lal
- Aaya Ram
Show answer
Answer: B. Bhagwat Dayal Sharma was the first Chief Minister. Gaya Lal is remembered for defection and Hukam Singh headed the 1965 parliamentary committee.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.