- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Born, worked, remembered: reading a personality question precisely
Separate where a person was born, where he or she worked and where he or she is remembered, and use two-clue elimination to solve hard personality questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
An Advanced personality question seldom asks 'who was Dr Y. S. Parmar?'. It asks 'which hero born in Shimla fought in Ladakh?' or 'which painter is remembered at a village but was not born in India?'. Every name has up to three places attached to it, and the whole skill is knowing which one the stem wants.
The three-place grid
| Person | Field | Born or belongs to | Worked or fought | Remembered at |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dr Y. S. Parmar | Public life | Sirmaur | Led the case for a hill state | First Chief Minister |
| Raja Sansar Chand | Ruler and patron | Kangra | Court at Sujanpur Tira | Kangra painting |
| Baba Kanshi Ram | Poet, freedom fighter | Kangra | Pahari verses | Pahari Gandhi |
| Shyam Saran Negi | Teacher, voter | Kalpa, Kinnaur | Voted in the first general election | First voter |
| Major Somnath Sharma | Soldier | Dadh, Kangra | Near Badgam, Srinagar | First Param Vir Chakra |
| Major Dhan Singh Thapa | Soldier | Shimla | Pangong Tso, Ladakh | Param Vir Chakra, 1962 |
| Captain Vikram Batra | Soldier | Palampur, Kangra | Kargil, 1999 | Param Vir Chakra |
| Rifleman Sanjay Kumar | Soldier | Bilaspur | Kargil, 1999 | Param Vir Chakra |
| Sobha Singh | Painter | Settled in the hills | Andretta, Kangra | Paintings of the Gurus; gallery |
| Nicholas Roerich | Painter | Russia | Naggar, Kullu | Roerich Art Gallery |
| Nirmal Verma | Hindi writer | Shimla | Writing | Jnanpith Award |
Stem words decide the place
- Born, home, native of - the second column.
- Fought, served, commanded - the third column.
- Gallery, house, memorial - the last column.
- Settled - the person was not born there; Sobha Singh at Andretta, Roerich at Naggar.
Two-clue elimination
- Read the stem's key verb Born, fought or remembered?
- Use the field Soldier, painter, writer, builder
- Use one place District or town
- Cross out options that break any clue Usually one survivor
Worked example 1: born versus fought
Question: Which Param Vir Chakra hero was born in Shimla but fought in Ladakh? Working: Of the four, Thapa was born in Shimla and the war with China in 1962 took him to the Pangong Tso area. Sharma fought near Srinagar and Batra and Sanjay Kumar at Kargil. Answer: Major Dhan Singh Thapa.
Worked example 2: native, not settler
Question: Which of Nirmal Verma, Nicholas Roerich and Sobha Singh was born in the hills of Himachal? Working: Verma was born in Shimla. Roerich was Russian by birth and settled at Naggar; Sobha Singh settled at Andretta. Answer: Nirmal Verma.
Worked example 3: statement set
Question: (1) Vikram Batra was born at Dadh. (2) Somnath Sharma was born at Dadh. (3) Both are from Kangra. Working: Batra was born at Palampur, so 1 is false. Sharma was born at Dadh, so 2 is true. Both districts are Kangra, so 3 is true. Answer: 2 and 3 only.
Born, fought, remembered. Stem verb first, then field, then place. Two Kangra soldiers: Dadh (Sharma) and Palampur (Batra).
Key takeaways: build the grid once and read each question for its verb. Settlers and natives are different groups, and two-clue elimination usually leaves one name.
Check your understanding
-
1. A Param Vir Chakra hero born in Shimla is
- Major Dhan Singh Thapa
- Major Somnath Sharma
- Captain Vikram Batra
- Rifleman Sanjay Kumar
Show answer
Answer: A. Thapa was born in Shimla. Sharma and Batra are from Kangra, and Sanjay Kumar from Bilaspur.
-
2. Consider the statements. (1) Nicholas Roerich was born at Naggar. (2) Nirmal Verma was born in Shimla. Which is correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: B. Roerich was Russian by birth and settled at Naggar, so 1 is false. Verma was born in Shimla, so 2 is true.
-
3. Which person is remembered through a gallery at the village where he settled, not where he was born?
- Nirmal Verma at Shimla
- Baba Kanshi Ram at Kalpa
- Sobha Singh at Andretta
- Shyam Saran Negi at Naggar
Show answer
Answer: C. Sobha Singh settled at Andretta, where his house is a gallery.
-
4. Which pair has the same district as the home of both people?
- Dhan Singh Thapa and Vikram Batra - Shimla
- Sanjay Kumar and Somnath Sharma - Bilaspur
- Shyam Saran Negi and Nirmal Verma - Kinnaur
- Somnath Sharma and Vikram Batra - Kangra
Show answer
Answer: D. Sharma (Dadh) and Batra (Palampur) are both from Kangra.
-
5. A stem says 'fought in the Pangong Tso area'. This points to
- 1962 and Major Dhan Singh Thapa
- 1947 and Somnath Sharma
- 1999 and Vikram Batra
- 1999 and Sanjay Kumar
Show answer
Answer: A. Pangong Tso is the place of the 1962 action of Thapa.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.