- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The 1991 crisis: what a balance-of-payments crisis is
Explain the balance of payments in simple terms, show why India ran short of foreign exchange in 1991, and tell stabilisation measures apart from structural reforms.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In 1991 India nearly ran out of the foreign money it needed to pay for imports. This was a balance-of-payments crisis, and it pushed the country into its big reforms. You do not need any economics background for this lesson: we will build the idea from a simple household picture.
The balance of payments in plain words
A country earns foreign money, mostly dollars, when it sells goods and services abroad, when its people working abroad send money home, and when foreigners invest or lend to it. It spends foreign money when it buys imports, pays interest on foreign loans, and repays them. The balance of payments is the record of all these flows. It has two main parts:
- Current account: exports and imports of goods and services, money sent home by workers (remittances), and interest and profits paid or received.
- Capital account: foreign investment and loans coming in or going out.
If a country spends more foreign money than it earns on the current account, it has a current account deficit. It must cover this with loans or investment from abroad, or by using its savings of foreign money, called foreign exchange reserves. A crisis comes when the reserves run very low and nobody wants to lend any more.
Worked example 1: a simple current account
Suppose in a year a country exports goods worth $30 billion and imports goods worth $45 billion. It earns $10 billion from services and receives $3 billion in remittances, and pays $2 billion as interest abroad. Step 1: goods balance = 30 − 45 = −$15 billion. Step 2: add services and remittances: −15 + 10 + 3 = −$2 billion. Step 3: subtract interest paid: −2 − 2 = −$4 billion. The current account deficit is $4 billion, which must be financed from abroad or from reserves. (All numbers are illustrative.)
What went wrong by 1991
Several problems came together. The government had been spending much more than it earned for years, so its deficits and debts were high. Imports were growing faster than exports. In 1990-91 the Gulf War pushed up oil prices, raising India's import bill, and many Indian workers in the Gulf had to return home, cutting remittances. Political uncertainty and falling confidence made foreign lenders nervous, and some Indians living abroad withdrew deposits. By mid-1991 the reserves could pay for only a few weeks of imports. India pledged part of its gold abroad to raise loans and took support from the IMF.
Worked example 2: how many months of imports?
A common way to judge reserves is import cover: how many months of imports the reserves can pay for. Suppose reserves are $3 billion and imports cost $1.5 billion a month. Step 1: import cover = reserves ÷ monthly imports. Step 2: 3 ÷ 1.5 = 2 months. If reserves fall to $1 billion, cover becomes 1 ÷ 1.5 = about 0.67 months, or roughly 20 days. A cover this low means a country may soon be unable to pay for essentials such as oil. (Illustrative numbers.)
The response: two kinds of measures
Economists split the response into two kinds. Stabilisation measures are short-term steps to stop the immediate crisis: cutting the government's deficit, controlling inflation and fixing the balance of payments, for example by devaluing the rupee and borrowing from the IMF. Structural reforms are long-term changes to make the economy more efficient and competitive: removing licences, opening to trade and foreign investment, and reforming banks and taxes. The first puts out the fire; the second rebuilds the house so it does not catch fire again.
Balance-of-payments crisis = foreign exchange reserves too low to pay for imports and debts. Stabilisation fixes the short-term crisis; structural reform changes the economy for the long term.
Key takeaways. The current account covers trade, services, remittances and interest; the capital account covers investment and loans. In 1991, high government deficits, rising imports, the Gulf War and lost confidence drained India's reserves to a few weeks of imports. The response combined stabilisation (short term) and structural reform (long term).
Check your understanding
-
1. Money sent home by Indians working abroad is recorded in which part of the balance of payments?
- Capital account
- Current account
- Government budget
- Foreign exchange reserves only
Show answer
Answer: B. Remittances are part of the current account, along with trade in goods and services and interest and profits.
-
2. Exports $20 billion, imports $26 billion, services earnings $5 billion, remittances $2 billion, interest paid $3 billion. What is the current account balance?
- Deficit of $2 billion
- Surplus of $2 billion
- Deficit of $6 billion
- Surplus of $1 billion
Show answer
Answer: A. Goods: 20 − 26 = −6. Add services and remittances: −6 + 5 + 2 = +1. Subtract interest: 1 − 3 = −2. A deficit of $2 billion.
-
3. Reserves of $4 billion and monthly imports of $2 billion give an import cover of
- 8 months
- 6 months
- 2 months
- half a month
Show answer
Answer: C. Import cover = reserves ÷ monthly imports = 4 ÷ 2 = 2 months.
-
4. Which of these is a stabilisation measure rather than a structural reform?
- Cutting the government's fiscal deficit to control the crisis
- Removing industrial licensing
- Allowing new private banks
- Opening sectors to foreign investment
Show answer
Answer: A. Cutting the deficit is a short-term step to stop the crisis, so it is stabilisation. The others change the economy's structure for the long term.
-
5. Which event in 1990-91 raised India's import bill?
- A fall in world oil prices
- A sharp rise in exports
- A rise in remittances from the Gulf
- The Gulf War pushing up oil prices
Show answer
Answer: D. The Gulf War raised oil prices, which increased the cost of India's oil imports, and also cut remittances as workers returned home.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.