- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Quotas, subsidies and dumping: price, revenue and duty problems
Solve short problems on the licence premium under a quota, countervailing duty against a subsidy and the dumping margin that limits an anti-dumping duty.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Earlier lessons treated the tariff, the most open form of protection. This lesson covers three other tools and two remedies: the import quota, the export subsidy, dumping, the countervailing duty and the anti-dumping duty. The problems are short, and each has a single formula. Learn the formula and the definition together.
Import quota
A quota limits the quantity of imports. It restricts supply, so the domestic price rises above the world price. The difference between the domestic price and the world price (plus any duty) is the licence premium or quota rent per unit, collected by whoever holds the import licence. Total rent = premium per unit x quota quantity.
Export subsidy and countervailing duty
An export subsidy is a payment by the government to exporters, which lets them sell abroad at a lower price. The importing country may respond with a countervailing duty, a tax set to offset the subsidy (it should not be more than the subsidy). Subsidies that distort trade are restricted under the WTO rules.
Dumping and anti-dumping duty
Dumping is the sale of a good abroad at a price lower than its normal value, which is usually its price in the home market of the exporter. The dumping margin is normal value minus export price. It is often expressed as a percentage of the export price. An anti-dumping duty may be imposed on a dumped import that harms the domestic industry, and it should not be more than the dumping margin.
Worked example 1: quota rent
The world price of a good is Rs 50. The import quota is 80 units and the domestic price becomes Rs 70. The licence premium is 70 - 50 = Rs 20 per unit. The total quota rent = 20 x 80 = Rs 1,600, which goes to the licence holders. If the same quantity were allowed by a tariff of Rs 20 per unit, the government would receive the Rs 1,600 as revenue instead.
Worked example 2: a countervailing duty
A foreign government gives its exporters a subsidy of Rs 12 per unit. The importing country may set a countervailing duty of up to Rs 12 per unit. If it sets Rs 15, the extra Rs 3 is not justified by the subsidy and the other country can object. If the subsidy is Rs 12 on a good whose export price is Rs 96, the subsidy is 12/96 = 12.5% of the export price.
Worked example 3: the dumping margin
A firm sells a good at Rs 120 in its home market and at Rs 90 for export. The dumping margin is 120 - 90 = Rs 30 per unit. As a percentage of the export price, 30/90 = 33.3%; as a percentage of the normal value, 30/120 = 25%. The question must say which base to use; the usual practice is the export price. An anti-dumping duty cannot be more than Rs 30 per unit. If the duty is Rs 30, the landed price rises from Rs 90 to Rs 120, equal to the home price, and the dumping is removed.
Quota rent = (domestic price - world price) x quota. Countervailing duty is no more than the subsidy. Anti-dumping duty is no more than the dumping margin.
Traps
- Dumping is not just a low price; it means a price lower than normal value, usually the exporter's home price.
- A countervailing duty answers a subsidy, and an anti-dumping duty answers dumping; do not swap them.
- The quota rent goes to licence holders unless the licences are auctioned.
- Check the base when a dumping margin is given as a percentage.
Key takeaways: name the situation first, then apply its one formula, and check the cap on the remedy.
Check your understanding
-
1. The world price is Rs 50, the quota is 80 units and the domestic price is Rs 70. The quota rent is:
- Rs 1,600
- Rs 20
- Rs 5,600
- Rs 4,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Premium 20 x 80 units = Rs 1,600.
-
2. An exporter sells at Rs 120 at home and at Rs 90 abroad. The dumping margin per unit is:
- Rs 120
- Rs 90
- Rs 30
- Rs 210
Show answer
Answer: C. Normal value minus export price: 120 - 90 = Rs 30.
-
3. The dumping margin of Rs 30 on an export price of Rs 90 is what percentage of the export price?
- 25.0%
- 33.3%
- 30.0%
- 75.0%
Show answer
Answer: B. 30/90 = 33.3%. The 25% is on the normal value of Rs 120.
-
4. A tax imposed to offset a subsidy given by a foreign government is a:
- quantitative restriction
- revenue tariff
- specific duty on every import
- countervailing duty
Show answer
Answer: D. A countervailing duty offsets a subsidy; an anti-dumping duty offsets dumping.
-
5. The anti-dumping duty on the good with a dumping margin of Rs 30 should be:
- at least Rs 120 per unit
- no more than Rs 30 per unit
- exactly the export price
- unlimited in amount
Show answer
Answer: B. The duty is meant to remove the dumping and should not exceed the margin.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.