• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mutual funds and derivatives: exit loads, SIPs, futures and options

Work out redemption value with an exit load, the average cost under an SIP, and the profit or loss on futures and simple option positions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

This lesson brings together two areas that produce many calculation questions. Mutual fund questions test NAV, loads and systematic investment. Derivative questions test the basic pay-off of futures and options. Both need only careful arithmetic once the definitions are clear.

Mutual funds: loads and SIPs

An exit load is a charge deducted when you redeem units, usually within a stated period, as a percentage of NAV. A Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) invests a fixed sum at regular intervals. Because the same sum buys more units when the NAV is low and fewer when it is high, the average cost per unit ends up below the simple average of the NAVs. This is called rupee-cost averaging. Mutual funds may be open-ended (units bought and redeemed any day at NAV) or close-ended (fixed period, units traded on an exchange).

Derivatives: the basic idea

A derivative is a contract whose value comes from an underlying asset such as a share, an index, a commodity or a currency. The two basic types:

  • Futures: an obligation for both sides to buy or sell at a fixed price on a future date. Gains and losses can be unlimited on both sides.
  • Call option: the buyer gets the right, not the obligation, to BUY at the strike price. The buyer pays a premium.
  • Put option: the buyer gets the right, not the obligation, to SELL at the strike price, also for a premium.
  • The option seller (writer) receives the premium and must perform if the buyer exercises.
Pay-offs at expiry
PositionGain at expiry per shareBreakeven
Long futures (buy)Final price − futures priceFutures price
Long callMax(price − strike, 0) − premiumStrike + premium
Long putMax(strike − price, 0) − premiumStrike − premium

Worked examples

Worked example 1. Sameer redeems 1,000 units at an NAV of ₹50 with a 1% exit load. Gross value = ₹50,000. Load = 1% of 50,000 = ₹500. He receives ₹49,500.

Worked example 2. An SIP invests ₹1,000 a month for three months at NAVs of ₹10, ₹20 and ₹25. Units = 100 + 50 + 40 = 190. Total invested = ₹3,000. Average cost = 3,000 ÷ 190 = ₹15.79. The simple average NAV is (10 + 20 + 25) ÷ 3 = ₹18.33, so the SIP bought more cheaply on average.

Worked example 3. A trader buys one futures lot of 100 shares at ₹500 and the price at expiry is ₹530. Gain = (530 − 500) × 100 = ₹3,000. Had the price fallen to ₹470, the loss would have been ₹3,000.

Worked example 4. Buy a call with strike ₹200 for a premium of ₹10. At expiry the share is ₹225: gain = (225 − 200) − 10 = ₹15 per share. If the share is ₹190, the call is not exercised and the loss is the premium, ₹10. Breakeven = 200 + 10 = ₹210.

An option buyer's loss is limited to the premium; a futures position has no such limit. Call breakeven = strike + premium; put breakeven = strike − premium.

— Rule to remember

Open-ended and close-ended in practice. In an open-ended fund the fund itself issues and buys back units every business day at the NAV, so the number of units keeps changing. In a close-ended fund the units are fixed at launch and, until the fund closes, an investor who wants to leave must sell on an exchange, where the price can be above or below NAV. Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) also trade on an exchange, usually tracking an index. When a question asks why a close-ended fund's market price differs from its NAV, the answer is that its price is set by buyers and sellers on the exchange, not by the fund.

Hedging, the main purpose of derivatives. Derivatives are not only for speculation. A farmer who expects to harvest wheat in three months can sell futures today to fix a price; a company that holds shares can buy puts to limit its loss if prices fall, much as one buys insurance. The premium is the cost of that insurance. Examiners often ask for the position that protects against a fall: holding the asset plus buying a put.

Key takeaways

  • Redemption amount = units × NAV × (1 − exit load).
  • SIP average cost = total invested ÷ total units, which is below the average NAV when NAVs vary.
  • Futures oblige both sides; options give the buyer a right for a premium.
  • The most an option buyer can lose is the premium paid.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. 2,000 units are redeemed at an NAV of ₹30 with a 2% exit load. What is received?

    1. ₹60,000
    2. ₹58,800
    3. ₹59,400
    4. ₹61,200
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Gross = 2,000 × 30 = ₹60,000. Load = 2% = ₹1,200. Received = ₹58,800.

  2. 2. An SIP of ₹600 a month buys at NAVs ₹12, ₹15 and ₹20. What is the average cost per unit?

    1. ₹15.67
    2. ₹14.75
    3. ₹15.00
    4. ₹15.33
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Units = 50 + 40 + 30 = 120. Invested = ₹1,800. Average cost = 1,800 ÷ 120 = ₹15. The simple average NAV is ₹15.67.

  3. 3. A put option has strike ₹300 and premium ₹12. At expiry the share is ₹270. What is the buyer's gain per share?

    1. ₹30
    2. ₹42
    3. ₹12
    4. ₹18
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Put value = 300 − 270 = ₹30. Gain = 30 − 12 = ₹18.

  4. 4. What is the maximum loss for the BUYER of a call option?

    1. Unlimited
    2. The premium paid
    3. The strike price
    4. The futures price
    Show answer

    Answer: B. If the price stays below the strike the buyer simply does not exercise, losing only the premium.

  5. 5. Which statement is correct?

    1. A futures contract gives only the buyer a right, not an obligation
    2. A close-ended fund lets investors redeem at NAV on any day
    3. The breakeven for a call buyer is strike price + premium
    4. An exit load is added to the amount received
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The call buyer needs the price to cover both strike and premium. Futures oblige both sides; close-ended funds have a fixed term; an exit load is deducted.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery