- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Deficit identities, financing and ratios: drills and traps
Compute the effective revenue deficit, build the fiscal deficit from its parts, trace how a deficit is financed, and judge deficit ratios when GDP changes.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Earlier lessons gave the three deficit formulas. This drill set adds the effective revenue deficit, a quick identity for the fiscal deficit, the financing of the deficit, and the ratio traps that appear when GDP also changes. All figures are illustrative, in ₹ crore.
Three identities to know
Fiscal deficit = revenue deficit + capital expenditure - non-debt capital receipts. This is the same as total expenditure minus revenue receipts minus non-debt capital receipts, but it saves a step when the revenue deficit is already known. Primary deficit = fiscal deficit - interest payments. Effective revenue deficit = revenue deficit - grants given for the creation of capital assets. It corrects the revenue deficit for grants to states that become assets, because spending that builds assets is not consumption.
Financing the fiscal deficit
The fiscal deficit is met by borrowing. The sources are borrowing from the market (selling government securities), borrowing from abroad, and borrowing from the Reserve Bank. Borrowing from the central bank creates new money, so it is called monetised deficit and can feed inflation. The three sources must add up to the fiscal deficit exactly.
Deficit ratios when GDP changes
A ratio has two parts. It can fall because the deficit is smaller, or because GDP has grown faster than the deficit. Read both numbers before judging. Always use nominal GDP in the denominator when the deficit is in current rupees.
Worked example 1: all four measures
Example 1. Revenue receipts 900, revenue expenditure 1,050, capital expenditure 300, non-debt capital receipts 40, interest 250, grants for creating capital assets 70. Step 1: revenue deficit = 1,050 - 900 = 150. Step 2: effective revenue deficit = 150 - 70 = 80. Step 3: fiscal deficit = 150 + 300 - 40 = 410. Check: total expenditure is 1,350, and 1,350 - (900 + 40) = 410. Step 4: primary deficit = 410 - 250 = 160.
Worked example 2: financing
Example 2. The fiscal deficit is 410. Market borrowing is 300 and external borrowing is 40. The balance, 410 - 300 - 40 = 70, comes from the Reserve Bank. That is 70 / 410 x 100 = 17.1% of the deficit financed by new money, which is the inflation risk.
Worked example 3: the ratio trap
Example 3. The fiscal deficit is 600 and nominal GDP is 20,000, so the ratio is 3%. Next year the deficit is 660 and GDP is 22,000. Ratio = 660 / 22,000 = 3.0%. The deficit rose by 10%, but GDP rose by 10% too, so the ratio is unchanged. Had the deficit stayed at 600, the ratio would have fallen to 600 / 22,000 = 2.73%. A bigger deficit in rupees does not mean a worse ratio.
Common traps
- Subtracting interest from the revenue deficit; interest belongs only in the primary deficit.
- Treating borrowing as a receipt when finding the fiscal deficit.
- Subtracting grants for capital assets from the fiscal deficit; they adjust only the revenue deficit.
- Comparing ratios without checking that both years use nominal GDP.
FD = RD + capital expenditure - non-debt capital receipts. PD = FD - interest. ERD = RD - grants for capital assets. Sources of financing add up to FD.
Key takeaways
- Use the identity FD = RD + capital expenditure - non-debt capital receipts to save time.
- The effective revenue deficit removes grants that build assets.
- Money borrowed from the central bank is monetised deficit.
- A ratio can stay steady when both the deficit and GDP grow by the same percentage.
Check your understanding
-
1. Revenue expenditure 1,200, revenue receipts 1,000, grants for creating capital assets 80. The effective revenue deficit is
- 280
- 120
- 200
- 80
Show answer
Answer: B. Revenue deficit = 1,200 - 1,000 = 200. Effective revenue deficit = 200 - 80 = 120.
-
2. Revenue deficit 150, capital expenditure 300, non-debt capital receipts 40. The fiscal deficit is
- 260
- 490
- 450
- 410
Show answer
Answer: D. FD = 150 + 300 - 40 = 410. Adding the receipts, which gives 490, is the common error.
-
3. A fiscal deficit of 410 and interest payments of 250 give a primary deficit of
- 160
- 660
- 250
- 410
Show answer
Answer: A. Primary deficit = fiscal deficit - interest = 410 - 250 = 160.
-
4. The fiscal deficit rises from 600 to 660 while nominal GDP rises from 20,000 to 22,000. The deficit-GDP ratio
- falls to 2.7%
- rises to 3.3%
- stays at 3%
- rises to 6%
Show answer
Answer: C. Both grow by 10%. 600/20,000 = 3% and 660/22,000 = 3%, so the ratio is unchanged.
-
5. A fiscal deficit of 500 is financed by 350 of market borrowing and 50 of external borrowing. The balance borrowed from the central bank is
- 400
- 100
- 150
- 50
Show answer
Answer: B. 500 - 350 - 50 = 100. This is monetised deficit, 20% of the total.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.