- Practice
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Price indices compared: consumer prices, wholesale prices and the GDP deflator
Decide which index fits a question, see why imports and services affect each index differently, and compute the GDP deflator and its inflation rate.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The same economy produces several measures of inflation, and they can disagree. Exam questions ask which index covers what, which one a particular price change will move, and how to compute the GDP deflator. This lesson compares the three measures by what they cover. The indices India uses and the weights they carry are revised from time to time, so the weights below are invented.
What each index covers
| Index | Prices of | Covers services? | Covers imports? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consumer price index | What households pay at retail | Yes | Yes, if consumers buy them |
| Wholesale price index | Goods at the early trade stage | No, goods only | Imported goods traded in the country |
| GDP deflator | All goods and services produced in the country | Yes | No, only domestic output |
The GDP deflator has no fixed basket. It uses the current year's output, so its weights change every year. A consumer price index uses a fixed basket for a period. The index used for the central bank's target is a matter of current policy, so check a current source.
Worked example 1: the deflator and its inflation
Example 1. Nominal GDP is ₹1,500 crore and real GDP (at base-year prices) is ₹1,250 crore. Deflator = 1,500 / 1,250 x 100 = 120. Last year the deflator was 110. Inflation measured by the deflator = (120 - 110) / 110 x 100 = 9.09%. The error to avoid is to say 10%, which is the rise in points, or 8.3%, which divides by the new value.
Worked example 2: an imported price
Example 2. A country imports fuel and produces cars. The world price of fuel doubles. Households buy fuel, so the consumer price index rises. The GDP deflator measures only the prices of what is produced at home, so it does not capture the rise in an imported good, except where the price of domestic output is also affected. A question asking which index is directly affected by an imported good has the consumer index as its answer.
Worked example 3: why the consumer index can run ahead of the wholesale index
Example 3. In an invented consumer basket, goods have a weight of 70% and services 30%. Goods prices rise 3% and services rise 10%. Consumer inflation = 0.70 x 3 + 0.30 x 10 = 2.1 + 3.0 = 5.1%. A wholesale index covers only goods, so it shows 3%. The gap does not mean either index is wrong. They measure different baskets.
Choosing the index
- Cost of living or real wages: a consumer price index.
- Prices firms face for inputs or at the early stage of trade: a wholesale index.
- Prices of everything made at home, and for converting nominal to real GDP: the GDP deflator.
- Exports and capital goods are in the deflator but not in the consumer index.
Consumer index: what households pay, services included, imports included. Wholesale index: goods only. GDP deflator: domestic output only, with the weights of the current year.
Key takeaways
- Each index measures a different basket, so their inflation rates can differ.
- GDP deflator = nominal GDP / real GDP x 100, and has no fixed basket.
- Imported goods enter the consumer index but not the GDP deflator.
- Wholesale indices cover goods only.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these indices does not cover services?
- The consumer price index
- The wholesale price index
- The GDP deflator
- None of them
Show answer
Answer: B. A wholesale index tracks goods at the early stage of trade. The other two include services.
-
2. A rise in the price of an imported good directly affects
- the consumer price index but not the GDP deflator
- the GDP deflator but not the consumer index
- neither index
- both indices equally
Show answer
Answer: A. The deflator covers only domestic output, while households buy imported goods that enter the consumer index.
-
3. Nominal GDP is ₹1,500 crore and real GDP is ₹1,250 crore. The GDP deflator is
- 150
- 83.3
- 120
- 125
Show answer
Answer: C. 1,500 / 1,250 x 100 = 120.
-
4. The deflator rises from 110 to 120. Inflation by the deflator is about
- 12.0%
- 10.0%
- 8.3%
- 9.1%
Show answer
Answer: D. (120 - 110) / 110 x 100 = 9.09%.
-
5. Goods (weight 70%) rise 3% and services (weight 30%) rise 10%. Consumer inflation is
- 6.5%
- 5.1%
- 13%
- 3.0%
Show answer
Answer: B. 0.70 x 3 + 0.30 x 10 = 2.1 + 3.0 = 5.1%.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.