- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Qualitative tools and the transmission of policy
Learn selective credit controls, moral suasion and how a change in the policy rate reaches loan rates, spending and prices.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Quantitative tools change how much credit exists; qualitative tools change who gets it and for what. Beyond tools, policy works only if the change travels through the banking system to ordinary borrowers. That journey is called transmission.
Qualitative (selective) tools
- Margin requirements: the central bank can fix the margin, meaning the portion of a loan's security value that must be paid by the borrower. A higher margin means a smaller loan against the same security.
- Credit rationing: caps on lending to particular sectors or on the total loans of a bank.
- Directed or priority sector lending: banks must direct a share of loans to specified sectors such as agriculture and small business.
- Moral suasion: persuasion, advice and informal requests to banks, with no legal force behind them.
- Direct action: penalties on banks that do not follow directions.
Margin example
A bank lends against grain stored in a warehouse worth Rs 10,00,000. With a margin of 20%, it lends 80% of the value, that is Rs 8,00,000. If the central bank, wanting to discourage hoarding, raises the margin to 40%, the loan falls to Rs 6,00,000. This reduces credit to that particular activity without changing credit overall.
Transmission
When the central bank changes its policy rate, the effect flows through steps.
- Banks' cost of funds changes.
- Banks revise deposit and lending rates, sooner for loans linked directly to an external benchmark and slowly for fixed-rate ones.
- Borrowing, investment and consumption respond.
- Total demand changes, and later prices and growth change.
Transmission is never instant or complete. It can take months, and it works poorly if banks are short of funds, if borrowers are already heavily indebted, or if a large share of borrowing happens outside the regulated system.
Worked example 1
A bank passes on a policy-rate cut of 0.5 percentage points fully to a loan linked to that rate. For a loan of Rs 20,00,000, annual interest falls by 0.5% of 20,00,000 = Rs 10,000, so about Rs 833 per month on interest alone.
Worked example 2
If the central bank raises the margin on loans against shares from 25% to 50% (illustrative), a person with shares worth Rs 4,00,000 can borrow Rs 3,00,000 before and only Rs 2,00,000 afterwards. This chokes speculative borrowing without a rate change.
Key takeaways
- Qualitative tools target the use of credit.
- Margins, rationing, moral suasion are the main ones.
- Policy transmits through bank rates to spending and prices.
- Transmission is slow and imperfect.
Check your understanding
-
1. Qualitative credit tools mainly change
- the total quantity of money only
- who gets credit and for what purpose
- the tax rates on income
- the exchange rate of the rupee
Show answer
Answer: B. Quantitative tools change the overall volume of credit; qualitative tools direct its use towards or away from particular purposes.
-
2. Advice and informal requests by the central bank to banks, with no legal force, are called
- direct action
- credit rationing
- open market operations
- moral suasion
Show answer
Answer: D. Moral suasion rests on persuasion and influence. Direct action, by contrast, means penalties on banks that ignore directions.
-
3. Goods worth Rs 6,00,000 are pledged as security and the margin is 25%. How much can be lent against them?
- Rs 1,50,000
- Rs 6,00,000
- Rs 5,75,000
- Rs 4,50,000
Show answer
Answer: D. With a 25% margin the borrower puts in 25% and the bank lends 75%: 75% of 6,00,000 = Rs 4,50,000.
-
4. Raising the margin requirement on loans against a stored commodity is meant to
- increase credit for that activity
- reduce credit for that particular activity, such as hoarding
- raise the cash reserve ratio of all banks
- cut interest rates across the economy
Show answer
Answer: B. A higher margin means a smaller loan against the same security, so credit to that use falls without changing credit overall.
-
5. Which of these slows the transmission of a policy-rate cut to borrowers?
- Loans are linked directly to an external benchmark rate
- Banks have ample funds
- A large share of borrowing happens outside the regulated banking system
- Borrowers have little existing debt
Show answer
Answer: C. Transmission works through banks. Borrowing outside the regulated system does not respond to the policy rate, so the effect is weaker. Benchmark-linked loans actually pass changes on faster.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.