- Foundation
- About 11 min
- 5 practice questions
Limitations of national income and green GDP
Understand what national income leaves out, why GDP is not a measure of welfare, and the idea behind green GDP.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
National income is useful but imperfect. A thoughtful student must know both what it measures and what it misses. Exam questions often ask why GDP is not a perfect indicator of well-being.
Problems in measurement
- Non-monetised activity: output used by the producer's own family (a farmer eating his own produce is partly counted by estimation, but housework by a homemaker is not counted).
- Informal and illegal activity: much economic activity is unrecorded, so it is under-counted.
- Double counting may creep in when intermediate goods are not separated.
- Unreliable data in a country with a large unorganised sector.
Problems in interpretation
- Distribution: a high average can coexist with deep inequality.
- Quality of life: leisure, health, safety and freedom are not priced.
- Composition of output: GDP counts weapons and schools alike.
- Environmental damage: cutting forests or polluting rivers can raise GDP while destroying natural wealth.
Green GDP
Green GDP adjusts conventional GDP by subtracting the cost of environmental damage and the depletion of natural resources. The idea is that if a country burns through its forests, soil and groundwater to produce more, it is consuming capital and not just earning income.
Green GDP = GDP - (depreciation of natural capital + cost of environmental damage)
Worked example 1
Illustrative: GDP is Rs 1,000 crore; depreciation of produced capital is Rs 80 crore; depletion of natural resources and pollution damage is estimated at Rs 60 crore. Net domestic product = 1,000 - 80 = 920. Green (environmentally adjusted) net product = 920 - 60 = Rs 860 crore. The growth looks lower once nature's loss is counted.
Worked example 2 - the clean-up paradox
After a river is polluted, a firm is paid Rs 20 crore to clean it. GDP rises by 20 because a service was bought, though society is no better off than before the pollution. This shows why GDP is not welfare, and why careful analysts look at what the spending achieved.
Key takeaways
- GDP misses unpaid work, informal activity, inequality and quality of life.
- Higher GDP does not always mean higher welfare.
- Green GDP subtracts environmental damage and resource depletion.
- Use national income as a measure of output, not of happiness.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is NOT counted in GDP?
- A doctor's fee
- A homemaker's unpaid cooking
- A teacher's salary
- Factory output
Show answer
Answer: B. Unpaid household work does not pass through a market, so it is not counted.
-
2. GDP = 1,500, depreciation of produced capital = 100, and resource depletion plus pollution damage = 80. Find the environmentally adjusted net product.
- 1,400
- 1,420
- 1,580
- 1,320
Show answer
Answer: D. NDP = 1,500 - 100 = 1,400. Adjusted = 1,400 - 80 = 1,320.
-
3. A firm is paid to clean a river after it was polluted. What happens?
- GDP rises, although society is no better off than before the pollution
- GDP falls
- GDP does not change
- Welfare rises above its level before the pollution
Show answer
Answer: A. Paying for the clean-up is a purchased service, so GDP rises, yet it only restores what was lost. GDP is not welfare.
-
4. Green GDP is GDP after deducting
- indirect taxes
- imports
- environmental damage and depletion of natural resources
- subsidies
Show answer
Answer: C. Green GDP subtracts the cost of environmental damage and natural resource depletion.
-
5. Why can a high per capita income mislead about well-being?
- It counts unpaid housework
- It is an average that hides inequality
- It subtracts pollution
- It is a stock
Show answer
Answer: B. An average can be high while many people earn little; it also ignores health, leisure and environment.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.