• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Harrod-Domar extended: depreciation, per-head targets and stability

Solve hard Harrod-Domar problems with depreciation and population growth, compare warranted and natural growth, and use the rule of 70.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the advanced level the plain formula g = s ÷ v is only the starting point. Questions add depreciation, ask for the saving needed to reach a per-head target, compare two economies, or test Harrod's idea of instability. This lesson derives each extension once, so you can rebuild it under pressure instead of memorising four formulas.

Deriving the extended formula

Let K be capital, Y output, and v the capital-output ratio, so Y = K ÷ v. Gross saving sY is invested, but a fraction δ of the capital stock wears out each year. The change in capital is ΔK = sY − δK. Divide by K: ΔK ÷ K = sY ÷ K − δ = s ÷ v − δ. Because Y moves in proportion to K, output grows at the same rate: g = s ÷ v − δ. Rearranged for the saving needed: s = v × (g + δ). With no depreciation these collapse to the familiar forms.

For targets per head, add population growth n: income per head grows at roughly g − n, so a per-head target p needs g = p + n, and therefore s = v × (p + n + δ). This single line answers most 'how much must the country save' problems.

Worked example 1: growth with depreciation

Gross saving 24% of income, capital-output ratio 4, depreciation 2% of capital a year. g = 24 ÷ 4 − 2 = 6 − 2 = 4%. Ignoring depreciation gives 6%, the usual wrong option.

Worked example 2: saving for a per-head target

A plan wants income per head to grow 5% a year. Population grows 2%, depreciation is 1% and v = 4. s = 4 × (5 + 2 + 1) = 4 × 8 = 32%. If domestic saving is 28%, the gap of 4% of income must come from foreign saving or from a lower v (better use of capital); otherwise per-head growth will be (28 ÷ 4) − 1 − 2 = 4%.

Worked example 3: a rising ICOR

Saving stays at 30% but the capital-output ratio rises from 4 to 5 (projects take longer and cost more). Growth falls from 7.5% to 6%, a drop of 1.5 percentage points, or 20% of the original rate. A rising ICOR is the arithmetic face of poor implementation.

Warranted and natural growth

Harrod called s ÷ v the warranted rate: the growth at which firms find their investment exactly justified. The natural rate is set by growth of the labour force plus labour-augmenting technical progress: the fastest growth the economy's labour can sustain. Nothing forces the two to be equal, because s, v and n are decided separately. Harrod also argued that if actual growth departs from the warranted rate, firms' reactions push it further away, the so-called knife-edge instability. For planners the lesson was that saving and investment needed to be guided, not left to chance.

The rule of 70

A quantity growing at r% a year doubles in about 70 ÷ r years. At 7% income doubles in about 10 years; with 2% population growth income per head grows about 5% and doubles in about 14 years. The rule is an approximation (exact doubling at 7% takes 10.2 years) and is accurate enough for options spaced apart.

g = s ÷ v − δ; s = v × (per-head target + n + δ). Warranted rate = s ÷ v; natural rate = labour-force growth + technical progress. Doubling time ≈ 70 ÷ growth rate.

Key takeaways: derive from ΔK = sY − δK; subtract depreciation and add population growth before multiplying by v; a rising ICOR cuts growth for the same saving; warranted and natural rates need not coincide; use the rule of 70 for doubling questions.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Gross saving 27%, capital-output ratio 4.5, depreciation 1%. What is the growth rate?

    1. 6%
    2. 5%
    3. 7%
    4. 4.5%
    Show answer

    Answer: B. g = 27 ÷ 4.5 − 1 = 6 − 1 = 5%.

  2. 2. Target: income per head grows 4% a year. Population grows 1.5%, there is no depreciation and v = 4. What saving rate is needed?

    1. 16%
    2. 10%
    3. 18%
    4. 22%
    Show answer

    Answer: D. s = v × (p + n) = 4 × (4 + 1.5) = 4 × 5.5 = 22%.

  3. 3. In Harrod's analysis, the natural rate of growth is determined by:

    1. Growth of the labour force plus technical progress
    2. The saving rate divided by the capital-output ratio
    3. The rate of inflation
    4. The government's plan target
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The natural rate is the growth the labour force (in efficiency units) can sustain: labour-force growth plus labour-augmenting technical progress. s ÷ v is the warranted rate.

  4. 4. Per-head income grows at 5% a year. By the rule of 70, roughly how long does it take to double?

    1. 10 years
    2. 35 years
    3. 14 years
    4. 7 years
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 70 ÷ 5 = 14 years.

  5. 5. Saving is 32%. The ICOR rises from 4 to 5. By how much does growth fall?

    1. 1 percentage point
    2. 1.6 percentage points
    3. 2 percentage points
    4. 20 percentage points
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 32 ÷ 4 = 8%; 32 ÷ 5 = 6.4%. Fall = 1.6 percentage points (which is 20% of the original rate, not 20 points).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery