- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Planning institutions and the Constitution: statement questions
Judge multi-statement questions on the Planning Commission, NDC, Finance Commission, local planning bodies and NITI Aayog using a three-way test.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Institution questions usually come as two or three statements with options such as 'only 1', 'both', 'neither'. One wrong word makes a statement false, so you need precise facts and a quick test. This lesson gives the test, the facts it needs, and practice on the commonest traps.
The three-way test
For any body, ask how it was created. Constitutional: an Article of the Constitution creates it. Statutory: an Act of Parliament creates it. Executive: a resolution or order of the government creates it. Most planning traps swap these labels.
| Body | Created by | Key facts |
|---|---|---|
| Planning Commission (1950) | Executive resolution | Chaired by the Prime Minister; prepared plans; allocated plan funds to states |
| National Development Council (1952) | Executive resolution | Prime Minister, Union Cabinet ministers, Chief Ministers and Planning Commission members; approved plans |
| Finance Commission | Article 280 (constitutional) | Recommends sharing of taxes between Centre and states |
| District Planning Committee | Article 243ZD (74th Amendment) | Consolidates panchayat and municipal plans into a district draft plan |
| Metropolitan Planning Committee | Article 243ZE (74th Amendment) | Draft development plan for a metropolitan area |
| NITI Aayog (2015) | Executive resolution | Think tank; cooperative federalism; no power to allocate funds |
Two more facts complete the toolkit. 'Economic and social planning' is entry 20 of the Concurrent List, so both the Centre and the states may legislate on it. Under the 73rd Amendment, panchayats prepare plans for economic development and social justice (Article 243G) on matters including those in the Eleventh Schedule (29 subjects); under the 74th, municipalities do so for the Twelfth Schedule (18 subjects).
Worked example 1: a three-statement question
Consider: (1) The Planning Commission was a statutory body. (2) The Finance Commission is a constitutional body. (3) The NDC was set up by an amendment to the Constitution. Apply the test. (1) It was executive, not statutory: false. (2) Article 280: true. (3) It was set up by an executive resolution in 1952: false. Only statement 2 is correct. Note the trap word 'statutory' in (1): many students know the Commission was 'not constitutional' and wrongly accept 'statutory'.
Worked example 2: NITI Aayog versus the Planning Commission
Consider: (1) Unlike the Planning Commission, NITI Aayog has no power to allocate funds to states. (2) NITI Aayog was created by an Act of Parliament. (3) NITI Aayog emphasises cooperative federalism. Statement 1 is true; statement 2 is false (it was an executive resolution, exactly like its predecessor); statement 3 is true. Answer: 1 and 3 only.
Worked example 3: counting Articles
How many of these are created directly by an Article of the Constitution: Finance Commission, District Planning Committee, Metropolitan Planning Committee, NDC? Finance Commission (280), DPC (243ZD), MPC (243ZE) are constitutional; the NDC is not. Answer: three. Many students answer 'one', forgetting that the 74th Amendment made the local planning committees constitutional.
Ask: Article, Act, or resolution? Planning Commission, NDC and NITI Aayog: resolution. Finance Commission 280, DPC 243ZD, MPC 243ZE: constitutional. Economic and social planning: Concurrent List.
Key takeaways: 'not constitutional' does not mean 'statutory'; the planning bodies at the centre were all executive creations, while the district and metropolitan committees are constitutional; NITI Aayog advises and does not allocate funds; read every adjective in a statement.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these was created by an executive resolution?
- Finance Commission
- District Planning Committee
- Metropolitan Planning Committee
- National Development Council
Show answer
Answer: D. The NDC was set up in 1952 by an executive resolution. The other three are constitutional (Articles 280, 243ZD, 243ZE).
-
2. Consider: (1) The Planning Commission was a statutory body. (2) The Finance Commission is constitutional. Which is correct?
- 2 only
- 1 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither
Show answer
Answer: A. The Planning Commission was neither constitutional nor statutory; it was executive. The Finance Commission is constitutional under Article 280.
-
3. Which Article provides for the District Planning Committee?
- Article 280
- Article 243G
- Article 243ZD
- Article 39
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 243ZD, inserted by the 74th Amendment. 243G concerns panchayat powers; 280 the Finance Commission.
-
4. Consider about NITI Aayog: (1) It allocates plan funds to states. (2) It emphasises cooperative federalism. (3) It replaced the Planning Commission. Which are correct?
- 1 and 2 only
- 2 and 3 only
- 1 and 3 only
- 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: B. NITI Aayog has no fund-allocation power, so 1 is false; 2 and 3 are true.
-
5. 'Economic and social planning' appears in:
- The Union List
- The State List
- The Eleventh Schedule only
- The Concurrent List
Show answer
Answer: D. It is entry 20 of the Concurrent List, so both the Centre and the states can legislate on it.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.