• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Types of unemployment: case identification and traps

Identify the type of unemployment in exam-style cases, measure disguised unemployment from an output table, and separate the natural rate from cyclical unemployment.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Most questions on types of unemployment are short cases: a sentence about a worker and four type names. The traps are near-misses - seasonal versus disguised, structural versus cyclical, frictional versus structural. This lesson gives a decision test for each, a numerical method for disguised unemployment, and the idea of the natural rate, using the measurement ideas of lesson 3.

A decision test

  1. Is the person counted as working but adds nothing to output? Disguised.
  2. Is work missing only in certain months, year after year? Seasonal.
  3. Is the person between two jobs for a short time, with skills that are in demand? Frictional.
  4. Do the person's skills or location no longer match the jobs that exist, after a change in technology or the pattern of demand? Structural (technological unemployment is a form of it).
  5. Have jobs disappeared across the economy because total demand fell in a slowdown? Cyclical (also called demand-deficient or Keynesian).
  6. Is the person working, but fewer hours than wished or far below their skills? Underemployment.

Measuring disguised unemployment

Disguised unemployment means the marginal product of extra workers - the output each extra worker adds - is zero. Given a table of output against workers, find the smallest number of workers that already produces the maximum output. Everyone beyond that number is disguisedly unemployed. Workers whose marginal product is small but positive are not disguisedly unemployed.

Worked example 1: an output table

A family farm
Workers123456
Output (quintals)203545505050
Marginal product201510500

Six family members work the farm. Output reaches its maximum, 50, with 4 workers; the 5th and 6th add nothing. So 2 people are disguisedly unemployed. The 4th worker adds only 5 quintals, but that is positive, so he is not disguisedly unemployed. Note that surveys count all six as employed: disguised unemployment does not appear in the unemployment rate.

Natural rate versus cyclical unemployment

Even in a healthy economy some unemployment remains, because people change jobs and skills take time to match new jobs. Frictional plus structural unemployment is called the natural rate of unemployment. Unemployment above it, caused by a fall in total demand, is cyclical. If frictional unemployment is 2%, structural 3% and the actual rate 6.5%, the natural rate is 5% and cyclical unemployment 1.5%. Policies that raise demand reduce cyclical unemployment; retraining and better job information reduce the natural rate.

Worked example 2: near-miss cases

Case (a): a potter's sales collapse permanently as plastic and steel vessels replace clay pots. Demand for his product has shifted for good, so this is structural, not cyclical; waiting for the economy to recover will not bring the work back. Case (b): construction workers lose jobs during a general slowdown and are rehired when it ends. The cause is a temporary fall in total demand, so this is cyclical. Case (c): farm hands are idle every summer before the monsoon. The idleness follows the calendar, so it is seasonal, not disguised; in the busy season every one of them is needed.

Case (d): a newly qualified nurse spends a month choosing between two hospital offers. Her skills are in demand and the gap is short, so this is frictional. Case (e): seven brothers share the work of a small shop that three could run. Output would not fall if four left, so four are disguisedly unemployed, even though all seven look busy. Case (f): a qualified accountant works two hours a day keeping accounts for a shop because nothing better is available. He has work, so he is not unemployed in the survey sense; he is underemployed, both in hours and in the use of his skills.

Notice how the key words decide the answer. 'Permanently', 'replaced' and 'no longer needed' point to structural. 'Slowdown', 'recession' and 'rehired when demand returns' point to cyclical. 'Every year' or a named season points to seasonal. 'Between jobs' or 'choosing an offer' points to frictional. 'Same output with fewer people' points to disguised. In statement questions, also remember that disguised unemployment and underemployment are not captured by the unemployment rate, because the people concerned are counted as working.

Disguised = marginal product zero, counted as employed. Natural rate = frictional + structural. Cyclical = the extra unemployment caused by a fall in total demand.

Key takeaways

  • Permanent shifts in demand or technology cause structural unemployment; temporary slowdowns cause cyclical.
  • Count disguised unemployment from the point where output stops rising.
  • Disguised unemployment is invisible in survey unemployment rates.
  • Seasonal and disguised unemployment are typical of rural India.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Output with 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 workers is 40, 48, 52, 52 and 52. If 7 family members work the farm, how many are disguisedly unemployed?

    1. 3
    2. 2
    3. 4
    4. 0
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Output stops rising at 5 workers (52). The 6th and 7th add nothing, so 2 are disguisedly unemployed. The 5th adds 4, which is positive.

  2. 2. The natural rate of unemployment consists of:

    1. Cyclical and seasonal unemployment
    2. Disguised and cyclical unemployment
    3. Only cyclical unemployment
    4. Frictional and structural unemployment
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The natural rate is the unemployment that remains in a normal economy: frictional plus structural.

  3. 3. Hand-loom weavers lose work permanently as power looms spread. This is:

    1. Structural unemployment
    2. Cyclical unemployment
    3. Frictional unemployment
    4. Seasonal unemployment
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A lasting change in technology makes their skills unmatched to the available jobs: structural (technological) unemployment.

  4. 4. In an employment survey, members of a family farm who are disguisedly unemployed are counted as:

    1. Unemployed
    2. Not in the labour force
    3. Employed
    4. Seasonally unemployed
    Show answer

    Answer: C. They are working on the farm, so surveys count them as employed; that is why disguised unemployment is hidden.

  5. 5. Frictional unemployment is 1.5%, structural 2.5% and the actual rate 6%. What is cyclical unemployment?

    1. 4%
    2. 2%
    3. 6%
    4. 1.5%
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Natural rate = 1.5 + 2.5 = 4%. Cyclical = 6 − 4 = 2%.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery