- Advanced
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Deficit arithmetic: revenue, fiscal, primary and effective revenue deficits
Compute every budget deficit from a set of accounts, use the identities that link them, and read what each one says about the quality of government borrowing.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Almost every hard public-finance question starts from the same few definitions. A budget is given, often in disguised form, and you must compute a deficit, a ratio, or a missing item. The definitions below are standard, and the identities that connect them let you solve such questions in two or three lines. All amounts in this course are illustrative numbers chosen for practice; they are not actual budget figures of any government.
The building blocks
| Item | What it contains |
|---|---|
| Revenue receipts (RR) | Tax revenue (net of states' share for the Centre) and non-tax revenue such as interest received, dividends and fees; they create no liability and reduce no asset |
| Revenue expenditure (RE) | Spending that creates no asset: salaries, interest payments, subsidies, pensions, grants to states (including grants used for creating capital assets) |
| Capital expenditure (CE) | Spending that creates assets or reduces liabilities: buildings, roads, loans given, repayment of debt |
| Non-debt capital receipts (NDCR) | Recovery of loans given earlier and disinvestment proceeds; they do not create debt |
| Debt capital receipts | Borrowings and other liabilities: market loans, small savings, external loans |
The four deficits
- Revenue deficit RD = RE − RR.
- Fiscal deficit FD = (RE + CE) − (RR + NDCR) = total borrowing and other liabilities needed.
- Primary deficit PD = FD − interest payments.
- Effective revenue deficit ERD = RD − grants for creation of capital assets.
Two identities save time. First, FD = RD + CE − NDCR. Second, PD = FD − interest, so a primary deficit of zero means the government borrows only to pay interest on past debt, and a primary surplus means it borrows less than its interest bill. The ratio RD ÷ FD shows what fraction of borrowing is used for current consumption rather than asset creation, a standard measure of the quality of the deficit.
Worked example 1: a full set of accounts
Revenue receipts 200 (tax 170, non-tax 30). Revenue expenditure 260, including interest 60 and grants for creation of capital assets 15. Capital expenditure 50. Recovery of loans 5, disinvestment 5. Working: RD = 260 − 200 = 60. Total expenditure = 260 + 50 = 310; non-borrowed receipts = 200 + 10 = 210; FD = 310 − 210 = 100. Check with the identity: 60 + 50 − 10 = 100. PD = 100 − 60 = 40. ERD = 60 − 15 = 45. Quality: RD ÷ FD = 60 per cent, so three-fifths of the borrowing finances current spending. Interest ÷ RR = 60 ÷ 200 = 30 per cent of revenue goes on interest.
Worked example 2: working in ratios to GDP
Fiscal deficit 5.5 per cent of GDP, interest payments 3.5 per cent, revenue deficit 3.0 per cent, grants for capital assets 1.0 per cent. Working: PD = 5.5 − 3.5 = 2.0 per cent. ERD = 3.0 − 1.0 = 2.0 per cent. Share of RD in FD = 3.0 ÷ 5.5 = 54.5 per cent. If capital expenditure is 3.0 per cent, the identity gives NDCR = RD + CE − FD = 3.0 + 3.0 − 5.5 = 0.5 per cent.
Worked example 3: traps
(a) A government with a revenue surplus can still have a fiscal deficit, if capital spending exceeds the surplus plus non-debt capital receipts. (b) Borrowings are capital receipts; if you include them on the receipts side, total receipts always equal total expenditure, which is why the deficit is measured before borrowing. (c) Repayment of a loan by the government is capital expenditure, but recovery of a loan given by the government is a non-debt capital receipt. (d) Interest paid is revenue expenditure; it is never part of capital expenditure.
FD = RD + CE − NDCR. PD = FD − interest. ERD = RD − grants for capital assets. RD ÷ FD measures how much borrowing pays for current spending.
Key takeaways
Key takeaways. Classify each item first: revenue or capital, debt or non-debt. Compute RD and FD, then the others follow by subtraction. Use the identity as a check. A falling RD ÷ FD ratio and a primary surplus are signs of better fiscal quality, while a high interest-to-revenue ratio signals a heavy debt burden.
Check your understanding
-
1. Revenue receipts 500, revenue expenditure 620, capital expenditure 180, non-debt capital receipts 30. What is the fiscal deficit?
- 300
- 120
- 240
- 270
Show answer
Answer: D. FD = (620 + 180) − (500 + 30) = 800 − 530 = 270. Check: RD = 120, and 120 + 180 − 30 = 270.
-
2. Fiscal deficit is 6.4 per cent of GDP and interest payments are 3.9 per cent. What is the primary deficit?
- 2.5 per cent
- 10.3 per cent
- 3.9 per cent
- 1.6 per cent
Show answer
Answer: A. PD = FD − interest = 6.4 − 3.9 = 2.5 per cent of GDP.
-
3. Revenue deficit is 2.9 per cent of GDP, of which grants for creation of capital assets are 1.1 per cent. What is the effective revenue deficit?
- 4.0 per cent
- 1.8 per cent
- 2.9 per cent
- 1.1 per cent
Show answer
Answer: B. ERD = RD − grants for creation of capital assets = 2.9 − 1.1 = 1.8 per cent.
-
4. If the primary deficit is zero, which statement is correct?
- The government has no debt
- The fiscal deficit is zero
- Borrowing in the year equals interest payments on past debt
- Revenue receipts equal revenue expenditure
Show answer
Answer: C. PD = FD − interest. If PD = 0, FD equals interest payments: the year's borrowing just covers interest on past debt.
-
5. Which of these is a non-debt capital receipt?
- Disinvestment proceeds
- Market borrowings
- Small savings collections
- Treasury bill issues
Show answer
Answer: A. Disinvestment proceeds do not create a liability. Market loans, small savings and treasury bills are all borrowing.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.