- Advanced
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Structural change arithmetic: shares that move
Predict how sector shares change when sectors grow at different rates, and work backwards from a target share or overall growth rate to the growth a sector needs.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions on the services sector rarely ask for a share directly. They give growth rates and ask what the share becomes, or give a target share and ask how fast services must grow to reach it. Both are solved with one formula and a little algebra. Master it here; later lessons on contribution to growth, productivity and trade all reuse it. Every figure in this course is illustrative, not real data.
The share-update formula
Let a sector have share s of total value added and grow at rate g_s, while the whole economy grows at rate g. Next year its share is s′ = s × (1 + g_s) ÷ (1 + g). The economy's growth is the weighted average of sector growth rates: g = Σ (share × growth). So you first find g from the weights, then update each share. If g_s > g the share rises; if g_s < g it falls.
Worked example 1: three sectors, one year
Shares: agriculture 20%, industry 26%, services 54%. Growth: agriculture 0%, industry 5%, services 8%. Step 1: g = 0.20 × 0 + 0.26 × 5 + 0.54 × 8 = 0 + 1.30 + 4.32 = 5.62%. Step 2: new services share = 54 × 1.08 ÷ 1.0562 = 58.32 ÷ 1.0562 ≈ 55.22%. Step 3: new agriculture share = 20 ÷ 1.0562 ≈ 18.94%, and industry = 26 × 1.05 ÷ 1.0562 = 27.30 ÷ 1.0562 ≈ 25.85%. Check: 55.22 + 18.94 + 25.85 = 100.01, equal to 100 apart from rounding. Notice that industry grew 5% yet lost share, because it grew slower than the 5.62% total.
Working backwards
Two reverse questions are common. (a) Find a sector's growth from overall growth. If services are a share s and the rest of the economy grows at g_r, then g = s × g_s + (1 − s) × g_r, so g_s = (g − (1 − s) × g_r) ÷ s. (b) Find the growth needed to reach a target share. If services have share s now and must reach share t next year, write the rest as R = 1 − s growing at g_r. Then services next year must equal t ÷ (1 − t) times the rest: S′ = t ÷ (1 − t) × R × (1 + g_r), and g_s = S′ ÷ s − 1.
Worked example 2: two reverse problems
(a) The economy grows 8%, services are 50% of it and the rest grows 5%. Then 8 = 0.5 × g_s + 0.5 × 5, so 0.5 × g_s = 5.5 and g_s = 11%. (b) Services are 50% and the rest (50%) will grow 4%. What services growth lifts the share to 52% next year? Rest next year = 50 × 1.04 = 52. Required services = 52 × 52 ÷ 48 = 2704 ÷ 48 ≈ 56.33. Growth = 56.33 ÷ 50 − 1 ≈ 12.7%. Check: total = 52 + 56.33 = 108.33, and 56.33 ÷ 108.33 ≈ 0.52.
Percent and percentage points with compounding
Over several years, use growth factors, not added rates. If services grow 9% a year for two years and the economy 6%, the share multiplies by (1.09 ÷ 1.06)² = (1.0283)² ≈ 1.0574. A 50% share becomes about 52.9%: a rise of 2.9 percentage points, or 5.7 percent. Adding '3 points a year' would give 56%, a classic wrong option.
New share = old share × (1 + sector growth) ÷ (1 + overall growth). Overall growth = Σ share × growth. A sector gains share only when it grows faster than the whole.
Key takeaways
- Always compute overall growth from the weights first, then update shares.
- A growing sector can still lose share if it grows slower than the economy.
- For a target share, size the rest of the economy first, then scale by t ÷ (1 − t).
- Over many years multiply growth factors; never add growth rates.
Check your understanding
-
1. Services are 60% of GVA and grow 10%; the rest grows 5%. What is the services share next year (to one decimal)?
- 63.1%
- 61.1%
- 66.0%
- 62.0%
Show answer
Answer: B. Overall g = 0.6 × 10 + 0.4 × 5 = 8%. New share = 60 × 1.10 ÷ 1.08 = 66 ÷ 1.08 ≈ 61.1%. The option 66% forgets that the whole economy also grew.
-
2. The economy grows 7%. Services are 60% of it and the rest grows 4%. How fast did services grow?
- 9%
- 7%
- 10%
- 11%
Show answer
Answer: A. 7 = 0.6 × g_s + 0.4 × 4 = 0.6 g_s + 1.6, so 0.6 g_s = 5.4 and g_s = 9%.
-
3. Industry grows 6% while the whole economy grows 7%. Which must be true?
- Industry's share rises
- Industry's share is unchanged
- Industry's share falls
- Services' share falls
Show answer
Answer: C. A sector growing slower than the total loses share, whatever its own growth. Nothing can be concluded about services without more data.
-
4. Services are 40% and the rest (60%) grows 5%. What services growth makes the share exactly 42% next year (nearest whole percent)?
- 5%
- 10%
- 14%
- 17%
Show answer
Answer: C. Rest next year = 60 × 1.05 = 63. Services must be 42/58 of that: 63 × 42 ÷ 58 = 2646 ÷ 58 ≈ 45.62. Growth = 45.62 ÷ 40 − 1 ≈ 14%. Check: 45.62 ÷ (45.62 + 63) ≈ 0.42.
-
5. For two years services grow 10% a year and the economy 5% a year. A 50% services share becomes about:
- 54.9%
- 60%
- 55%
- 52.4%
Show answer
Answer: A. Share factor = (1.10 ÷ 1.05)² = (1.04762)² ≈ 1.0975. New share ≈ 50 × 1.0975 ≈ 54.9%.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.