- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Services and economic development
Explain why the services sector grows as economies develop, using the three-sector idea of Fisher and Clark, and describe the main drivers of service growth.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
As countries grow richer, the kind of work people do changes. Fewer people farm, more work in factories for a time, and more and more work in shops, offices, schools and hospitals. Economists noticed this pattern long ago and built a simple theory around it. This lesson explains that theory, the reasons services expand, and some features of how this change has been discussed for India.
The three-sector idea
Economists Allan Fisher and Colin Clark, writing in the 1930s and 1940s, described how an economy's activity shifts as income rises: first from the primary sector to the secondary sector, and then increasingly to the tertiary sector. This is often called the Fisher-Clark three-sector hypothesis. The French economist Jean Fourastié developed similar ideas. The core reasons are simple. As people get richer they spend a smaller part of their income on food, so the farm sector's share falls. Industry grows as people buy more manufactured goods. At still higher incomes, people spend more on services such as education, health, travel, entertainment and finance.
Why services grow
- Rising incomes: richer households spend more on education, health care, eating out, travel and insurance.
- Specialisation: firms buy services such as cleaning, security, accounting and IT from specialist companies instead of doing them in-house. The same work is now counted in services.
- Growth of other sectors: more goods need more transport, storage, trade, banking and insurance.
- Government: public administration, defence, schools and hospitals expand as the state takes on more tasks.
- Technology: communication and computing create new services and allow some services to be sold across long distances.
Worked example 1: a shifting economy
An imaginary economy's value added (₹ crore) is primary 400, secondary 300 and services 300 in one decade, total 1,000. Twenty years later it is primary 500, secondary 700 and services 1,300, total 2,500. Shares then: primary 40, secondary 30, services 30 per cent. Shares now: primary 500 ÷ 2,500 = 20 per cent, secondary 700 ÷ 2,500 = 28 per cent, services 1,300 ÷ 2,500 = 52 per cent. Notice that primary output grew (400 to 500) but its share fell. A falling share does not mean the sector shrank.
Worked example 2: why job shares move slowly
In the same imaginary economy, suppose 60 of every 100 workers were in the primary sector in the first decade and 45 of every 100 later. The primary share of output fell by half (40 to 20 per cent), but its share of jobs fell by only 15 points (60 to 45). When output shifts faster than jobs, many workers remain in a sector where output per worker is low. This gap is a common theme in discussions of developing economies.
Features often discussed for India
A point frequently made about India's development is that services grew to a large share of output relatively early, while a much larger share of workers stayed in agriculture, and manufacturing's role in employment was smaller than in many East Asian economies at a similar stage. Exam questions use this as a concept (a 'service-led' pattern of growth); they do not need particular shares for particular years, and you should not memorise such figures from old sources.
Beyond the tertiary sector
Some writers split services further. Quaternary activities are knowledge-based: research, information technology, data and consulting. Quinary activities are the highest-level decision making, such as top executives, senior government officials and leading researchers. These labels are descriptive and are not separate sectors in national accounts.
As income rises, activity moves from primary to secondary to tertiary (Fisher-Clark). A sector's share can fall while its output still grows.
Key takeaways
The three-sector hypothesis says economies shift towards services as they develop, because of changing spending patterns, specialisation, growth of other sectors, government and technology. Output shares can change much faster than job shares. India is often described as following a service-led path. Quaternary and quinary activities are a finer, descriptive split of knowledge-based services.
Check your understanding
-
1. The idea that economic activity shifts from the primary to the secondary and then to the tertiary sector as incomes rise is associated with:
- Adam Smith and David Ricardo
- Allan Fisher and Colin Clark
- Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels
- Alfred Weber and Walter Christaller
Show answer
Answer: B. This is the Fisher-Clark three-sector hypothesis.
-
2. A company stops employing its own cleaners and hires a cleaning firm instead. What happens to measured services output?
- It rises, because the cleaning is now bought from a service firm
- It falls
- It does not change in any way
- It moves to the primary sector
Show answer
Answer: A. Specialisation moves such work into separate service firms, so it is now counted as services output.
-
3. Primary output grows from ₹400 crore to ₹500 crore while total output grows from ₹1,000 crore to ₹2,500 crore. What happens to the primary share?
- It rises from 40 to 50 per cent
- It stays at 40 per cent
- It falls from 40 to 20 per cent
- It falls from 50 to 25 per cent
Show answer
Answer: C. Before: 400 ÷ 1,000 = 40 per cent. After: 500 ÷ 2,500 = 20 per cent. Output grew but the share fell.
-
4. Research laboratories and IT consulting are sometimes called:
- Primary activities
- Secondary activities
- Quinary activities
- Quaternary activities
Show answer
Answer: D. Knowledge-based activities such as research and IT are described as quaternary; quinary refers to top-level decision making.
-
5. Why do people spend a larger share of their income on services as they become richer?
- Because food becomes more expensive
- Because once basic needs are met, they spend more on education, health, travel and entertainment
- Because goods stop being produced
- Because services are always cheaper than goods
Show answer
Answer: B. Spending on food takes a smaller share at higher incomes, and the extra income goes increasingly to services.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.