- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Statement and assertion-reason questions on the services sector
Break compound statements into testable parts, spot absolute words, check numerical statements, and decide whether a reason really explains an assertion.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Many questions on the services sector do not ask for a number. They give two or three statements and ask which are correct, or give an assertion and a reason and ask how they relate. The knowledge needed is the same as for the other chapters, but a clear method saves marks and time. This lesson sets out that method with solved examples.
Method for statement questions
- Read each statement alone and mark it true, false or doubtful before looking at the options.
- Underline absolute words: always, never, only, all, none. A statement with an absolute word is usually false, because one counter-example breaks it.
- Soft words such as may, can, tends to and often are usually safe.
- If a statement contains a number, calculate it. If it contains two claims joined by 'and', both must be true.
- Only then match your marks with the options, and eliminate.
Method for assertion-reason questions
An assertion (A) is a claim and a reason (R) is offered to explain it. First decide whether A is true. Then decide whether R is true. Only if both are true ask the third question: does R actually explain A? There are four outcomes: both true and R explains A; both true but R does not explain A; A true and R false; A false and R true.
Worked example 1: statements
Consider: (1) Services are perishable, so they cannot be stored for later sale. (2) The share of services in output must always equal its share in employment. (3) Retail trade is a part of the tertiary sector. Statement 1 is true: an empty seat today cannot be sold tomorrow. Statement 2 is false: the word must always is a warning, and the course has shown sectors with 55% of output but only 30% of jobs. Statement 3 is true. So only statements 1 and 3 are correct. Suppose one more statement said: 'A service firm's value added is its sales minus its inputs bought from other firms.' That is true, and would be included. A statement saying that a government school adds nothing to GDP because it charges no fees is false, since non-market services are valued at cost.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Case A. Assertion: employment in services can grow slowly even when services output grows fast. Reason: output per worker can rise. A is true, since employment elasticity can be low. R is true, and R explains A: if each worker produces more, the same extra output needs few extra workers. Result: both true, R explains A. Case B. Assertion: Baumol's cost disease makes personal services such as teaching costlier relative to goods over time. Reason: productivity in services grows faster than in manufacturing. A is true, but R is false, because the disease arises when productivity in those services grows slower than in goods while wages rise together. Result: A true, R false.
Checking a numerical statement
Statement: 'If total GVA is 2,000 and services GVA is 1,100, services contribute 55% and an extra 10% growth in services adds 5.5 points to the economy's growth.' The share, 1,100 ÷ 2,000 = 55%, is correct. A 10% rise in services adds 0.55 × 10 = 5.5 percentage points to overall growth. Both parts hold. If the statement had said 'adds 10 points', it would fail, because the contribution is share × growth.
Test each statement alone. Absolute words usually make it false. For assertion and reason, check A, then R, and only then ask whether R explains A.
Key takeaways
- Judge every statement separately before touching the options.
- Words like always, never and only are warning signs; may, can and tends are usually safe.
- Calculate any number given in a statement; both parts of a compound statement must be right.
- A true reason does not have to explain a true assertion.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement about services is correct?
- Services never need workers to be present
- Services can always be stored for later sale
- Services are often produced and used at the same time
- All services are provided only by the government
Show answer
Answer: C. Inseparability means many services are produced and consumed together. 'Always', 'never' and 'only' make the other statements false.
-
2. Total GVA is 2,000 and services GVA is 1,100. Services grow 10%. What do they add to overall growth, in percentage points?
- 1.1
- 10
- 55
- 5.5
Show answer
Answer: D. Contribution = share × growth = 0.55 × 10 = 5.5 percentage points.
-
3. Assertion: a government school adds to GDP although it charges no fee. Reason: non-market services are valued at the cost of producing them. Which is correct?
- Both are true but the reason does not explain it
- Both are true and the reason explains the assertion
- The assertion is true and the reason is false
- The assertion is false and the reason is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Government services without a market price are valued at cost (compensation of employees plus consumption of fixed capital), so the school's value added is counted in GDP.
-
4. Assertion: a high share of services in output proves that services provide most of the jobs. Which flaw makes this assertion false?
- Output shares and employment shares can differ a great deal
- Services never create any jobs in any economy at all
- Output cannot be measured in the services sector at all
- Jobs are always exactly equal to output in every sector
Show answer
Answer: A. A sector can produce more than half of the output and still employ much less than half of the workers, so one share does not prove the other.
-
5. Assertion: Baumol's cost disease raises the relative price of teaching over time. Reason: teaching productivity grows faster than factory productivity. Which is correct?
- Both are false
- Both are true and the reason explains the assertion
- The assertion is true and the reason is false
- The assertion is false and the reason is true
Show answer
Answer: C. The relative price rises because productivity in teaching grows more slowly than in factories while wages rise together, so the reason as stated is false.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.