- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Direct and indirect taxes: incidence and shifting
Classify taxes, work out who really bears them, and distinguish impact from incidence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Taxes are compulsory payments to the state without a direct quid pro quo. The legal payer and the person who finally bears the burden can differ. That difference is the heart of tax incidence questions. No current rates are quoted here; the numbers are illustrative.
Direct versus indirect
| Feature | Direct tax | Indirect tax |
|---|---|---|
| Burden | Cannot be shifted: impact and incidence on the same person | Can be shifted to the buyer or consumer |
| Examples | Income tax, corporation tax | Tax on goods and services, customs, excise-type levies |
| Nature | Usually progressive | Usually regressive in effect (the same rupee amount weighs more on the poor) |
| Evasion | Easier to evade by hiding income | Harder to evade at the point of sale |
Impact and incidence
Impact is on the person who first pays the tax to the government. Incidence is on the person who ultimately bears it after prices adjust. For an indirect tax on sellers, the buyer bears part of it through a higher price.
Worked example 1: split of a tax
Before a ₹10 per-unit tax on sellers the market price is ₹100. After the tax the price paid by buyers rises to ₹106. Buyers bear ₹6 per unit; sellers' net price falls to 106 - 10 = ₹96, so sellers bear ₹4. Buyers bear 60% and sellers 40%. Buyers bear more when demand is less elastic than supply.
Worked example 2: revenue from a tax
At a tax of ₹10, quantity falls from 500 to 440. Revenue = 10 x 440 = ₹4,400. If the tax were doubled to ₹20 and quantity fell to 350, revenue = 7,000. If it were ₹40 and quantity fell to 100, revenue would be 4,000. Revenue first rises and then falls as the tax grows, which is the idea behind the Laffer curve.
Good tax principles
- Equity: ability to pay (vertical equity) and equal treatment of equals (horizontal equity).
- Certainty: the taxpayer knows how much, when and how to pay.
- Convenience of payment and economy of collection.
- Productivity and elasticity: yields enough revenue and grows with income.
- Neutrality: does not distort choices more than needed.
Direct taxes: the payer bears the burden. Indirect taxes: the burden can be shifted, and more falls on the side with the less elastic curve.
Key takeaways: classify by shiftability; incidence follows elasticity; revenue need not rise as the tax rate rises.
Check your understanding
-
1. A ₹10 per-unit tax on sellers raises the market price from ₹100 to ₹107. What share of the tax do buyers bear?
- 30%
- 70%
- 7%
- 100%
Show answer
Answer: B. Buyers pay ₹7 more, which is 7 / 10 = 70%. Sellers bear the remaining ₹3 (30%).
-
2. In the same case (price ₹100 rising to ₹107 with a ₹10 tax), what net price do sellers keep?
- ₹107
- ₹90
- ₹100
- ₹97
Show answer
Answer: D. Net price = 107 - 10 = ₹97, so sellers bear ₹3 per unit.
-
3. A per-unit tax and the quantity sold: ₹10 sells 450 units, ₹20 sells 380, ₹40 sells 150, ₹60 sells 50. Which tax raises the most revenue?
- ₹20
- ₹10
- ₹40
- ₹60
Show answer
Answer: A. Revenue = tax x quantity: 4,500; 7,600; 6,000; 3,000. It peaks at ₹20 and then falls, the idea behind the Laffer curve.
-
4. Equal treatment of people in equal circumstances is called
- Vertical equity
- Neutrality
- Horizontal equity
- Certainty
Show answer
Answer: C. Horizontal equity treats equals equally; vertical equity relates tax to ability to pay.
-
5. A neutral tax is one that
- Collects the same rupee amount from everyone
- Falls only on the rich
- Does not distort people's choices more than needed
- Is always shifted to buyers
Show answer
Answer: C. Neutrality means the tax interferes as little as possible with economic decisions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.