• Practice
  • About 11 min
  • 5 practice questions

Direct and indirect taxes: classification practice

Tell direct from indirect taxes by who bears the burden, and apply the idea of incidence and shifting.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The first skill in taxation questions is classification. The test is simple: can the person who pays the tax to the government pass the burden on to someone else? This lesson drills that test.

The test

Direct tax: impact and incidence fall on the same person; the burden cannot normally be shifted (income tax, corporation tax, wealth taxes). Indirect tax: impact is on the seller or importer, but incidence falls on the consumer through the price (taxes on goods and services, customs and excise duties).

Direct versus indirect
FeatureDirect taxIndirect tax
BurdenBorne by the person who paysPassed on to the buyer
Link to incomeUsually progressive with incomeUsually the same rate for rich and poor, so regressive in effect
EvasionEasier to evade by hiding incomeHarder, since tax is built into price
CollectionFewer, larger payersWide base, small amounts

Progressive: the tax rate rises as income rises. Proportional: the same rate at all incomes. Regressive: the share of income paid falls as income rises.

Worked example 1

Suppose a goods tax of 10% is charged on a product costing Rs 500 before tax. The consumer pays Rs 550. Suppose two buyers, one earning Rs 20,000 a month and one earning Rs 2,00,000, each buy it. The tax of Rs 50 is 0.25% of the first buyer's income and 0.025% of the second's: the same rupee tax weighs more on the poorer buyer, so indirect taxes are regressive in effect.

Worked example 2

Suppose a simple slab structure taxes the first Rs 3,00,000 at 0%, the next Rs 3,00,000 at 5%, and the rest at 10%. On Rs 8,00,000: 0 on the first slab, 5% x 3,00,000 = 15,000 on the second, and 10% x 2,00,000 = 20,000 on the remaining Rs 2,00,000. Tax = Rs 35,000. The rate applies to each slice, not to the whole income, which is the trap in slab questions. These slabs are only for practice.

Direct: burden stays with the payer. Indirect: burden is shifted to the consumer. Progressive tax: higher incomes pay a higher rate.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways: ask who bears the burden, remember that slab rates apply to slices, and see why indirect taxes can be regressive in effect.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these is an indirect tax?

    1. Income tax
    2. Excise duty
    3. Corporation tax
    4. Wealth tax
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Excise duty is levied on goods and passed on in the price. Income, corporation and wealth taxes are direct.

  2. 2. A 10% goods tax is charged on a product costing Rs 800 before tax. For a buyer earning Rs 40,000 a month, the tax is what share of income?

    1. 2%
    2. 0.02%
    3. 10%
    4. 0.2%
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Tax = 10% of 800 = Rs 80. 80 / 40,000 x 100 = 0.2%.

  3. 3. Practice slabs: 0% on the first Rs 3,00,000, 5% on the next Rs 3,00,000, 10% on the rest. Tax on Rs 9,00,000?

    1. Rs 45,000
    2. Rs 90,000
    3. Rs 30,000
    4. Rs 60,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 0 + 5% of 3,00,000 (15,000) + 10% of 3,00,000 (30,000) = Rs 45,000. Applying 10% to the whole income (90,000) is the trap.

  4. 4. A tax is progressive when

    1. The same rate applies at all incomes
    2. The share of income paid falls as income rises
    3. The tax rate rises as income rises
    4. It is collected through the price of goods
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Progressive: higher incomes face higher rates. Same rate is proportional; falling share is regressive.

  5. 5. Which is a feature of direct taxes?

    1. Their burden is passed to the buyer through the price
    2. They are built into the price of goods
    3. They can be evaded by hiding income
    4. They take the same rupee amount from rich and poor buyers of an item
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Direct taxes are borne by the payer and are easier to evade by concealing income. The other features describe indirect taxes.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Canons of taxation and tax terms

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery