- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Cause and effect: statements and assertion-reason on why the English won
Test statements about the causes and consequences of European success in India, recognise common half-truths, and judge assertion-reason pairs.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The chapter has a central question: why did the English, and not the Portuguese, Dutch or French, become the leading power? Examination questions test this through statements and assertion-reason pairs. They want you to judge cause and consequence, and to spot statements that are partly true. The method is the same as before: check each part, watch for absolute words, and ask whether a reason really explains the claim.
Causes to remember
- Sea power: the English navy was strong, and control of the seas cut off French reinforcements.
- Bengal's wealth: after Plassey and the diwani, revenue from Bengal paid for armies and for the purchase of goods.
- Company organisation: shareholders and directors supported the company at home and the government gave diplomatic help.
- Indian politics: the weakness of the Mughal empire and quarrels among Indian rulers allowed the Europeans to take sides in disputes.
- Technique: disciplined, trained troops with modern firearms.
Worked example 1: judge the statements
(1) The French failed only because of Dupleix's faults. False: the word only is a warning; the French also lacked naval strength and support from home. (2) Plassey was important because of the political result more than the size of the battle. True: it was small but gave control of Bengal. (3) The grant of the diwani gave the Company the right to collect revenue. True. (4) Dual government made the Nawab responsible for revenue. False: the Company collected revenue while the Nawab was responsible for administration. Correct statements: (2) and (3).
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Case A. Assertion: the Portuguese could not keep their empire in the East. Reason: a small country could not support so many forts and fleets, and richer companies attacked them. Both are true and the reason explains the assertion. Case B. Assertion: the Battle of Buxar was more decisive than Plassey. Reason: Plassey was fought in 1764. The assertion is true (many historians consider it a test of strength against a coalition), but the reason is false, because Plassey was fought in 1757; Buxar was in 1764. Case C. Assertion: the English were successful in the Carnatic Wars. Reason: the Battle of Wandiwash was won by Robert Clive. The assertion is true; the reason is false, since Eyre Coote won Wandiwash. Always test the reason separately, because a small error of fact in R is the usual trap.
Common half-truths
- 'The diwani was granted by the Nawab of Bengal.' It was granted by the Mughal emperor.
- 'Plassey was a long battle.' It was a short battle, decided by betrayal.
- 'The Dutch won in India.' They were driven out of the competition.
- 'The Portuguese lost Goa to the English.' They held it until 1961.
Test each statement alone. Absolute words usually mean false. In assertion-reason, check the facts in R as carefully as those in A.
Key takeaways
- Success of the English came from sea power, Bengal's revenue, organisation and divided Indian rulers.
- Plassey mattered for its result, Buxar for the strength it showed.
- Dual government: revenue to the Company, administration to the Nawab.
- Check the reason in an assertion-reason pair for small factual errors.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which factor helped the English most after 1757?
- The end of all trade with Europe
- A decision of the Mughal emperor to leave India
- The revenue of Bengal, which paid for armies and trade
- The abolition of the Company's shareholders
Show answer
Answer: C. Revenue from Bengal financed English armies and the purchase of goods.
-
2. Assertion: Plassey was a small battle but had large results. Reason: it was followed by Mir Jafar being made Nawab and the Company gaining control of Bengal. Which is correct?
- Both are true but the reason does not explain it
- Both are true and the reason explains the assertion
- The assertion is true and the reason is false
- The assertion is false and the reason is true
Show answer
Answer: B. The political results (control of Bengal) made a small battle important.
-
3. Which of these statements is false?
- The grant of the diwani was made in the year 1765
- Shah Alam II was the emperor who granted the diwani
- The diwani was granted by the Nawab of Bengal
- The diwani covered Bengal, Bihar and Orissa together
Show answer
Answer: C. The grant came from the Mughal emperor Shah Alam II by the Treaty of Allahabad.
-
4. Assertion: Wandiwash decided the contest between the English and French. Reason: After Wandiwash the French lost Pondicherry, their main base, and never recovered. Which is correct?
- Both are false
- Both are true and the reason explains the assertion
- The assertion is false and the reason is true
- The assertion is true and the reason is false
Show answer
Answer: B. Wandiwash (1760), won by Eyre Coote, broke French power in the Carnatic; Pondicherry fell in 1761, which is why the battle was decisive.
-
5. Under dual government, the Company collected revenue while:
- The Peshwa ruled Bengal on the Company's behalf
- The Company took over all law and order work too
- The Mughal emperor himself collected the revenue
- The Nawab kept administration, with little real power
Show answer
Answer: D. The system gave the Company power without responsibility and the Nawab responsibility without power.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.