- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Doctrine and attitude: statement and assertion-reason questions on Bhakti and Sufism
Test statements about beliefs and attitudes carefully, spot absolute words and half-true claims, and handle assertion-reason questions step by step.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In the later stages of exams, the facts are the same but the questions get trickier. A statement may be half right, an assertion may be true but not explained by the reason, or a single word such as 'only' may turn a good sentence into a wrong one. This lesson gives you a method for such questions and a list of the claims that are most often built to mislead.
Claims that look right but are wrong
- 'Bhakti saints ended the caste system.' Wrong: they softened barriers in devotion, but caste continued.
- 'All Bhakti saints worshipped a god with form.' Wrong: nirguna saints such as Kabir and Nanak taught devotion to a formless God.
- 'Sufism is a branch of Bhakti.' Wrong: they are parallel traditions within different religions, with shared emphasis on love.
- 'The Chishtis took posts under the state.' Wrong: they kept distance from rulers; the Suhrawardis were more willing to accept patronage.
- 'Ramanuja taught that the self and Brahman are identical.' Wrong: that is Shankara's Advaita.
- 'Tulsidas was a nirguna saint.' Wrong: he is a saguna devotee of Rama.
A method for statement questions
- Split the statement into separate claims and test each.
- Underline words like only, all, never and always; these make a statement hard to defend.
- If a question asks which statements are correct, mark each as T or F before looking at the options.
- If one statement is certain, strike the options that disagree.
How assertion-reason questions work
An assertion-reason question gives two statements: an assertion (A) and a reason (R). You decide three things in order: is A true, is R true, and if both are true, does R actually explain A? The standard options are: both true and R explains A; both true but R does not explain A; A true and R false; A false and R true.
Worked example 1: a statement question
Question. (1) Kabir was a nirguna saint. (2) Chaitanya popularised kirtan in Bengal. (3) Suhrawardis avoided state patronage. Which are correct? Working. Statement 1 is true. Statement 2 is true. Statement 3 is false, because it is the Chishtis who avoided state patronage; the Suhrawardis accepted it. So 1 and 2 are correct.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Question. A: Bhakti saints composed in regional languages. R: This made their message accessible to ordinary people. Working. A is true. R is true. R explains A because local speech could be understood by all. So both are true and R explains A.
Worked example 3: a false pair
Question. A: Ramanuja taught Advaita. R: Ramanuja was influenced by the Alvars. Working. A is false, because Ramanuja taught Vishishtadvaita. R is true. So A is false and R is true.
Split the statement. Watch absolute words. For A and R: check A, check R, then check whether R explains A.
Key takeaways. Keep the list of common wrong claims in mind. Mark each statement T or F separately. Remember that Bhakti and Sufism are parallel, not the same, and that neither ended caste.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement is correct?
- Tulsidas taught nirguna devotion
- Kabir was a nirguna saint
- Chishtis accepted royal posts willingly
- Ramanuja taught Advaita
Show answer
Answer: B. Kabir was nirguna. Tulsidas was saguna, Chishtis avoided rulers, and Ramanuja taught Vishishtadvaita.
-
2. 'Bhakti saints ended caste.' This statement is
- false, as they supported caste fully
- true, as no caste remained
- true, as Kabir abolished it by law
- false, as caste continued in society
Show answer
Answer: D. The saints softened barriers in devotion but did not end caste.
-
3. A: Ramanuja taught Advaita. R: Ramanuja was influenced by the Alvars. Choose
- both false
- both true, R explains A
- A false, R true
- A true, R false
Show answer
Answer: C. Ramanuja taught Vishishtadvaita; he was influenced by the Alvars.
-
4. How are Sufism and Bhakti best described?
- They had no features in common
- Sufism grew out of Bhakti
- Bhakti grew out of Sufism
- Parallel, with shared themes
Show answer
Answer: D. They arose in different religions but shared love, music and local languages.
-
5. Why is 'only' a warning word in 'Ellora has only Buddhist caves'?
- It shows that the claim is surely true
- It makes the claim easy to disprove
- It points to an order in time
- It names the builder of the caves
Show answer
Answer: B. Absolute words such as only or all often make a statement false.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.