• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Doctrine and attitude: statement and assertion-reason questions on Bhakti and Sufism

Test statements about beliefs and attitudes carefully, spot absolute words and half-true claims, and handle assertion-reason questions step by step.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

In the later stages of exams, the facts are the same but the questions get trickier. A statement may be half right, an assertion may be true but not explained by the reason, or a single word such as 'only' may turn a good sentence into a wrong one. This lesson gives you a method for such questions and a list of the claims that are most often built to mislead.

Claims that look right but are wrong

  • 'Bhakti saints ended the caste system.' Wrong: they softened barriers in devotion, but caste continued.
  • 'All Bhakti saints worshipped a god with form.' Wrong: nirguna saints such as Kabir and Nanak taught devotion to a formless God.
  • 'Sufism is a branch of Bhakti.' Wrong: they are parallel traditions within different religions, with shared emphasis on love.
  • 'The Chishtis took posts under the state.' Wrong: they kept distance from rulers; the Suhrawardis were more willing to accept patronage.
  • 'Ramanuja taught that the self and Brahman are identical.' Wrong: that is Shankara's Advaita.
  • 'Tulsidas was a nirguna saint.' Wrong: he is a saguna devotee of Rama.

A method for statement questions

  • Split the statement into separate claims and test each.
  • Underline words like only, all, never and always; these make a statement hard to defend.
  • If a question asks which statements are correct, mark each as T or F before looking at the options.
  • If one statement is certain, strike the options that disagree.

How assertion-reason questions work

An assertion-reason question gives two statements: an assertion (A) and a reason (R). You decide three things in order: is A true, is R true, and if both are true, does R actually explain A? The standard options are: both true and R explains A; both true but R does not explain A; A true and R false; A false and R true.

Worked example 1: a statement question

Question. (1) Kabir was a nirguna saint. (2) Chaitanya popularised kirtan in Bengal. (3) Suhrawardis avoided state patronage. Which are correct? Working. Statement 1 is true. Statement 2 is true. Statement 3 is false, because it is the Chishtis who avoided state patronage; the Suhrawardis accepted it. So 1 and 2 are correct.

Worked example 2: assertion and reason

Question. A: Bhakti saints composed in regional languages. R: This made their message accessible to ordinary people. Working. A is true. R is true. R explains A because local speech could be understood by all. So both are true and R explains A.

Worked example 3: a false pair

Question. A: Ramanuja taught Advaita. R: Ramanuja was influenced by the Alvars. Working. A is false, because Ramanuja taught Vishishtadvaita. R is true. So A is false and R is true.

Split the statement. Watch absolute words. For A and R: check A, check R, then check whether R explains A.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways. Keep the list of common wrong claims in mind. Mark each statement T or F separately. Remember that Bhakti and Sufism are parallel, not the same, and that neither ended caste.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which statement is correct?

    1. Tulsidas taught nirguna devotion
    2. Kabir was a nirguna saint
    3. Chishtis accepted royal posts willingly
    4. Ramanuja taught Advaita
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Kabir was nirguna. Tulsidas was saguna, Chishtis avoided rulers, and Ramanuja taught Vishishtadvaita.

  2. 2. 'Bhakti saints ended caste.' This statement is

    1. false, as they supported caste fully
    2. true, as no caste remained
    3. true, as Kabir abolished it by law
    4. false, as caste continued in society
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The saints softened barriers in devotion but did not end caste.

  3. 3. A: Ramanuja taught Advaita. R: Ramanuja was influenced by the Alvars. Choose

    1. both false
    2. both true, R explains A
    3. A false, R true
    4. A true, R false
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Ramanuja taught Vishishtadvaita; he was influenced by the Alvars.

  4. 4. How are Sufism and Bhakti best described?

    1. They had no features in common
    2. Sufism grew out of Bhakti
    3. Bhakti grew out of Sufism
    4. Parallel, with shared themes
    Show answer

    Answer: D. They arose in different religions but shared love, music and local languages.

  5. 5. Why is 'only' a warning word in 'Ellora has only Buddhist caves'?

    1. It shows that the claim is surely true
    2. It makes the claim easy to disprove
    3. It points to an order in time
    4. It names the builder of the caves
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Absolute words such as only or all often make a statement false.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery