- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Land revenue settlements: matching people, years and regions
Match each land revenue system with its originator, year, region and payer, and handle the statement questions that mix up their features.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Land revenue systems are one of the most frequently tested parts of this topic. Questions usually match a system with a person, a year or a region, or test one feature such as whether the demand was fixed. The secret is a single grid that you can redraw in thirty seconds.
The master grid
| Point | Permanent Settlement | Ryotwari | Mahalwari |
|---|---|---|---|
| Other name | Zamindari system | - | Village settlement |
| Associated with | Lord Cornwallis | Alexander Read, Thomas Munro | Holt Mackenzie |
| Year to remember | 1793 | Tried first in Baramahal by Read; extended by Munro in Madras | 1822 |
| Main regions | Bengal, Bihar, Orissa | Madras, Bombay | North-Western Provinces, Punjab, parts of central India |
| Owner recognised | Zamindar | Ryot (cultivator) | Village community / landholders jointly |
| Who paid the state | Zamindar | Ryot directly | Village through its headman |
| Demand | Fixed for ever | Revised periodically | Revised periodically |
| Middleman | Yes (zamindar) | No | No individual landlord; village collective |
Background details worth knowing
- Before the Permanent Settlement, under Warren Hastings, the right to collect revenue was auctioned to the highest bidder (the farming system). It led to oppression and unstable collections.
- Cornwallis first made a ten-year (decennial) settlement with zamindars, which was declared permanent in 1793.
- The Permanent Settlement had a sunset law: revenue had to be paid by sunset on the due date, or the estate could be sold.
- Ryotwari did not remove oppression: the state itself acted as a heavy landlord, and the ryot had to pay even in a bad year.
Common confusions
| Wrong idea | Correct fact |
|---|---|
| Munro introduced Mahalwari | Munro is linked with Ryotwari; Mahalwari is Holt Mackenzie's |
| Ryotwari revenue was permanent | Only the Permanent Settlement fixed revenue for ever |
| Mahalwari was used in Bengal | Bengal had the Permanent Settlement; Mahalwari was in the north-west |
| Zamindars were only collectors under Cornwallis | Cornwallis made them owners of the land |
Worked example 1: matching
Match: (a) Permanent Settlement, (b) Ryotwari, (c) Mahalwari with (1) Holt Mackenzie, (2) Lord Cornwallis, (3) Thomas Munro. Working: Cornwallis made the Permanent Settlement, so a-2; Munro is the name of Ryotwari, so b-3; Holt Mackenzie proposed Mahalwari in 1822, so c-1. Answer: a-2, b-3, c-1.
Worked example 2: a two-statement question
Statement 1: "Under the Mahalwari system, revenue was settled with the village community as a whole." Statement 2: "Under the Permanent Settlement the government could raise the revenue whenever crop prices rose." Working: joint settlement with the village is the definition of Mahalwari, so 1 is right. The point of the Permanent Settlement was that the demand could never be raised, so 2 is wrong. Answer: 1 only.
Cornwallis 1793 - zamindar - Bengal - fixed for ever. Read and Munro - ryot - Madras and Bombay - revised. Holt Mackenzie 1822 - village - North-Western Provinces and Punjab - revised.
Key takeaways
Ask three questions of any clue: who paid, where, and was it fixed? Those three answers identify the system every time. Remember the sunset law and zamindar ownership for Bengal, direct payment for Madras and Bombay, and the village unit for the north-west.
Check your understanding
-
1. Match the systems with the persons: (a) Permanent Settlement (b) Ryotwari (c) Mahalwari; (1) Holt Mackenzie (2) Thomas Munro (3) Lord Cornwallis.
- a-1, b-2, c-3
- a-3, b-1, c-2
- a-2, b-3, c-1
- a-3, b-2, c-1
Show answer
Answer: D. Cornwallis introduced the Permanent Settlement (a-3), Munro is linked with Ryotwari (b-2) and Holt Mackenzie proposed Mahalwari in 1822 (c-1).
-
2. What was the 'sunset law' of the Permanent Settlement?
- Peasants could not work after sunset
- Revenue had to be paid by sunset on the due date, or the estate could be sold
- Zamindars had to live on their estates
- Revenue was collected only at harvest time
Show answer
Answer: B. Under the sunset law a zamindar who did not pay by sunset on the fixed date could have his estate sold. Many old estates changed hands this way.
-
3. In which year did Holt Mackenzie propose the Mahalwari system?
- 1822
- 1793
- 1813
- 1857
Show answer
Answer: A. Holt Mackenzie proposed the Mahalwari system in 1822 for the North-Western Provinces.
-
4. Consider: 1. In Ryotwari areas the revenue demand was fixed for ever. 2. In Ryotwari areas the cultivator paid the state directly. Which is/are correct?
- 1 only
- Both 1 and 2
- 2 only
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: C. The ryot paid the state directly, so statement 2 is correct. The Ryotwari demand was revised periodically, so statement 1 is wrong.
-
5. Which region was mainly under the Mahalwari system?
- Bengal
- North-Western Provinces
- Madras
- Bombay
Show answer
Answer: B. Mahalwari applied mainly in the North-Western Provinces, and later Punjab and parts of central India. Bengal had the Permanent Settlement; Madras and Bombay had Ryotwari.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.