• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Shramana world in depth: rival teachers, Ajivikas, materialists and the Magadhan setting

Place the Buddha and Mahavira among the rival Shramana teachers, identify each teacher's doctrine, and explain the social setting that let these movements grow.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the advanced level, questions stop asking 'who founded Buddhism?' and start asking which teacher held which view, how the Shramanas differed from the Brahmanical tradition, and why Magadha became the cradle of these movements. This lesson widens the picture beyond the two founders.

The six rival teachers

The Buddhist Samaññaphala Sutta tells how King Ajatashatru of Magadha asked six well-known teachers about the fruits of the ascetic life before he questioned the Buddha. The text reports their views from a Buddhist point of view, so it is a record of how Buddhists saw their rivals, but it is the standard starting point.

The six teachers of the Samaññaphala Sutta
TeacherView as reported in Buddhist texts
Purana KassapaDeeds bring neither merit nor demerit
Makkhali GosalaFate (niyati) decides everything; souls pass through a fixed series of births - leader of the Ajivikas
Ajita KesakambaliMaterialism: a person is made of physical elements and nothing survives death
Pakudha KaccayanaA set of unchanging elements exists; nothing truly kills or is killed
Sanjaya BelatthiputtaScepticism: refused to say yes or no to any proposition
Nigantha NataputtaThat is, Mahavira - the leader of the Niganthas (Jainas)

The Ajivikas

The Ajivikas, led by Makkhali Gosala, were an important Shramana order for several centuries. Their key doctrine was niyati, strict determinism: human effort cannot change one's destiny. Jain texts say Gosala was for some years a companion of Mahavira before they parted. The Ajivikas received royal favour under the Mauryas: Ashoka dedicated rock-cut caves in the Barabar hills of Bihar to them, and his grandson Dasharatha gave caves in the nearby Nagarjuni hills. The order later declined and disappeared.

Materialists

Teachers such as Ajita Kesakambali rejected rebirth, karma and the afterlife altogether. This line of thought was later called Lokayata or Charvaka. It mattered historically because it shows that the age was one of open debate, not a contest between only two new faiths.

Why Magadha and the middle Ganga plains?

  • Surplus and towns: iron tools and wet-rice farming supported cities such as Rajagriha, Shravasti, Vaishali and Kaushambi.
  • Merchants and guilds: wealthy traders (setthis) such as Anathapindika became major donors; guilds (shrenis) organised crafts.
  • Money: punch-marked coins made donation and trade easier.
  • Kingship: Magadhan rulers like Bimbisara and Ajatashatru welcomed and supported many teachers.
  • Distance from Vedic heartland: the eastern Ganga region was less firmly bound by the older Vedic ritual order.

Shramana and Brahmana

The two traditions shared some ideas that were developing at the same time, including karma, rebirth (samsara) and the search for liberation, which also appear in the Upanishads. The difference lay in authority: Shramanas rejected the Vedas and the priest's role, and they valued renunciation over householder ritual. Even so, Ashoka's edicts urge respect for both brahmanas and shramanas, showing that both were recognised religious groups.

Worked example 1: match teacher and doctrine

Match: (a) Makkhali Gosala (b) Ajita Kesakambali (c) Sanjaya Belatthiputta with (1) scepticism (2) materialism (3) determinism. Working: Gosala taught niyati, so a-3; Ajita taught that nothing survives death, so b-2; Sanjaya refused to commit to any answer, so c-1. Answer: a-3, b-2, c-1.

Worked example 2: evaluate statements

Statements: (1) The Barabar caves were dedicated to the Ajivikas. (2) The Ajivikas taught that human effort can overcome fate. Working: (1) is correct - Ashoka dedicated them. (2) contradicts niyati, which denies that effort can change destiny, so it is wrong. Answer: 1 only.

Gosala - niyati (Ajivika). Ajita - materialism (Lokayata). Sanjaya - scepticism. Nigantha Nataputta - Mahavira. Barabar caves - Ajivikas, under Ashoka.

Key takeaways: the Buddha and Mahavira were two of many Shramana teachers. Know the doctrines linked with the six teachers, the Ajivikas and their Mauryan caves, and the urban, mercantile, Magadhan setting that gave these movements patrons.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Buddhist texts, 'Nigantha Nataputta' refers to:

    1. Makkhali Gosala
    2. Ajita Kesakambali
    3. Mahavira
    4. Ananda
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Nigantha Nataputta is the name Buddhist texts use for Mahavira, leader of the Niganthas (Jainas).

  2. 2. The doctrine of niyati (strict determinism) is associated with:

    1. The Ajivikas
    2. The Jainas
    3. The Theravada Buddhists
    4. The Lokayata materialists
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Niyati, the doctrine that fate decides everything, was taught by Makkhali Gosala, leader of the Ajivikas.

  3. 3. Consider: (1) Ashoka dedicated caves in the Barabar hills to the Ajivikas. (2) Ashoka's edicts urge respect for both brahmanas and shramanas. Which is correct?

    1. 1 only
    2. 2 only
    3. Both 1 and 2
    4. Neither 1 nor 2
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Both are correct: Ashoka gave the Barabar caves to the Ajivikas, and his edicts ask people to respect brahmanas and shramanas alike.

  4. 4. Which teacher refused to say yes or no to any proposition?

    1. Purana Kassapa
    2. Pakudha Kaccayana
    3. Makkhali Gosala
    4. Sanjaya Belatthiputta
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Sanjaya Belatthiputta is described as a sceptic who would not commit to any answer.

  5. 5. Which factor is LEAST connected with the rise of Shramana movements in the middle Ganga plains?

    1. Growth of towns and merchant donors
    2. Spread of Persian as a court language
    3. Use of punch-marked coins
    4. Support from Magadhan kings
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Towns, merchant donors, coinage and Magadhan royal support all helped the Shramanas. Persian as a court language belongs to a much later period.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery