- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Telling the sources apart: Fa-Hien, Hiuen Tsang, inscriptions and coins
Practise choosing the right source for a Gupta question and avoid the look-alike traveller and monument distractors.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Source questions are popular because they test whether you can tell one traveller or inscription from another. A wrong choice is usually a familiar name belonging to another age. This lesson gives a set of rules for choosing the right source and a table of the usual distractors.
Travellers by age
| Traveller | From | Period of visit | Ruler or age |
|---|---|---|---|
| Megasthenes | Greek ambassador | About 300 BCE | Chandragupta Maurya |
| Fa-Hien (Faxian) | China | Early fifth century CE | Chandragupta II (Gupta) |
| Hiuen Tsang | China | Seventh century CE | Harsha |
| I-tsing | China | Late seventh century CE | After Harsha |
| Al-Biruni | Central Asia | Early eleventh century CE | Mahmud of Ghazni |
A question that says 'Chinese pilgrim ... Gupta' has one answer, Fa-Hien. The others come from different ages, so they are distractors.
Sources by type
- Prayaga Prashasti (Allahabad Pillar): Samudragupta's conquests; composed by Harishena.
- Mehrauli Iron Pillar: a king named Chandra; metallurgy.
- Junagadh rock inscription: Skandagupta and the Sudarshana lake.
- Gupta coins: dinaras; archer, lyre, Ashvamedha, lion-slayer and peacock types.
- Literature: the plays of Kalidasa and Shudraka, and the Puranas.
Rules for choosing a source
- Find the period of the question. A source from another period is a distractor.
- Match the type of evidence to the question: coins for images, inscriptions for names and conquests, a traveller for daily life.
- If the question says 'foreign visitor', find the visitor's country and period.
Worked example 1: choose the source
Question: Which source is best for finding what daily life was like in the Gupta age as seen by a foreigner? (a) Megasthenes (b) Fa-Hien (c) Hiuen Tsang (d) Al-Biruni. Working: Megasthenes belongs to the Mauryan age, Hiuen Tsang to Harsha's age, Al-Biruni to the eleventh century. Fa-Hien visited during Chandragupta II's reign. Answer: (b) Fa-Hien.
Worked example 2: time gaps
Question: About how many years separate Fa-Hien's visit (about 400 CE) from Hiuen Tsang's visit (about 630 CE)? Working: 630 - 400 = 230 years, nearly as long as the whole Gupta rule. This also shows why the two pilgrims cannot have seen the same empire.
Worked example 3: what each source cannot tell
Question: Why can the Prayaga Prashasti not be taken alone as a full account of Samudragupta's reign? Working: It is a praise-poem by a court poet, so it stresses success and leaves out failures. It also does not give the dates of campaigns. A historian therefore checks it against coins and other records. Answer: because it is a eulogy.
Worked example 4: eliminate step by step
Question: A source describes the court of Chandragupta Maurya. Is it Fa-Hien or Megasthenes? Working: Chandragupta Maurya ruled around 300 BCE. Fa-Hien visited about 400 CE, which is roughly 700 years later, so he cannot describe that court as an eyewitness. Megasthenes was an ambassador at the Mauryan court at that time. Answer: Megasthenes. A gap of about 700 years is a quick signal that a source cannot be an eyewitness.
Fa-Hien = Gupta (Chandragupta II). Hiuen Tsang = Harsha. Megasthenes = Maurya. Al-Biruni = Mahmud of Ghazni.
Key takeaways
- Place the question in a period before choosing a traveller.
- Use inscriptions for names and conquests and coins for images.
- A prashasti is a eulogy and must be cross-checked.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Chinese pilgrim who visited India in Chandragupta II's reign was
- Hiuen Tsang
- Fa-Hien
- I-tsing
- Al-Biruni
Show answer
Answer: B. Fa-Hien visited in the early fifth century CE. Hiuen Tsang came in Harsha's time.
-
2. Which source is the main record of Samudragupta's conquests?
- The Prayaga Prashasti
- The Junagadh inscription
- The Mehrauli Iron Pillar
- The Rihla of Ibn Battuta
Show answer
Answer: A. The Allahabad Pillar inscription, composed by Harishena, lists Samudragupta's campaigns.
-
3. About how many years separate Fa-Hien (about 400 CE) and Hiuen Tsang (about 630 CE)?
- 200 years
- 130 years
- 330 years
- 230 years
Show answer
Answer: D. 630 - 400 = 230 years.
-
4. Which source would you use to find the image a Gupta king wished to project?
- A land grant of a later king
- His coins
- The Mehrauli Iron Pillar's metal
- A traveller from the Mauryan age
Show answer
Answer: B. Coin designs, such as the archer, lyre and lion-slayer types, show how a king wished to be seen.
-
5. Why must a prashasti be checked against other sources?
- It was written centuries after the king died
- It was written in a foreign language
- It is a praise-poem that may leave out failures
- It contains only dates and prices
Show answer
Answer: C. A prashasti is a eulogy composed by a court poet, so it stresses the ruler's successes.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.