- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Statement and assertion-reason questions on the Congress: spotting the traps
Solve statement and assertion-reason questions on the Moderates, Extremists and the early Congress, and spot the common traps.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
In statement questions the facts are usually correct, but they are attached to the wrong person, year or place. In assertion-reason questions, both sentences can be true while the reason does not explain the assertion. This lesson shows you six traps and gives worked examples.
Six traps
- Wrong group: boycott and swadeshi are linked above all with the Extremists and the Swadeshi movement; Moderates such as Surendranath Banerjea backed the 1905 boycott in Bengal, but petitions and speeches were the Moderate method.
- Wrong president: Bonnerjee presided in 1885, but Hume was the organiser, not the president.
- Wrong city: the Surat split took place at Surat; the Lucknow Pact at Lucknow. Calcutta in 1906 was the session that declared swaraj.
- Wrong year: the Muslim League was founded in 1906, not 1905; Partition of Bengal took effect on 16 October 1905.
- Extreme words: 'only', 'all' or 'never' usually make a statement false.
- Cause reversed: the Surat split came after the Calcutta session, not before.
Worked example 1: three statements
Question: Consider: (1) The Moderates relied on petitions and speeches. (2) Naoroji explained the drain theory in Poverty and Un-British Rule in India. (3) The Lucknow Pact was signed at Surat. Working: Statement 1 is true. Statement 2 is true. Statement 3 is false, because the pact was made at Lucknow in 1916. Answer: 1 and 2 only.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Question: Assertion: The Extremists favoured boycott. Reason: They wanted to move beyond petitions and rely on self-reliance and mass action. Does the reason explain the assertion? Working: The assertion is true. The reason is true and explains why they chose boycott, since boycott is a form of mass action and self-reliance. Answer: both true, and the reason explains the assertion.
Worked example 3: a reversed cause
Question: Assertion: The Surat split happened because the Muslim League was founded. Reason: The League was founded in 1906. Evaluate. Working: The League was indeed founded in 1906, so the reason is true. But the split at Surat (1907) arose from the disagreement between Moderates and Extremists over methods and the presidency, not from the founding of the League. Answer: the reason is true, but it does not explain the assertion, and the assertion is false.
Worked example 4: the standard options
Question: Assertion: The Moderates had limited mass support. Reason: They relied on petitions and the educated middle class. What are the options and which fits? Working: The standard options are (a) both true and the reason explains the assertion, (b) both true but the reason does not explain it, (c) assertion true, reason false, (d) assertion false, reason true. Here the assertion is true, the reason is true, and relying on petitions and the educated class explains the limited mass support. Answer: (a).
Apply the same four-step method to every such question: judge the assertion, judge the reason, then test the link between them. Do the first two steps before looking at the options, and you will not be led by the wording.
Check each statement separately. Beware 'only', 'all', 'never'. A true reason need not explain the assertion.
Key takeaways
- Check group, president, city and year in each statement.
- Test whether the reason truly explains the assertion.
- Extreme words often signal a false statement.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which statement is correct?
- The Moderates used petitions and speeches
- The Moderates demanded complete independence
- Hume was the first president of the Congress
- The Surat split took place in 1916
Show answer
Answer: A. The Moderates used petitions and speeches and sought reforms within British rule, not independence; Bonnerjee was the first president and the Surat split was in 1907.
-
2. Where was the Lucknow Pact of 1916 signed?
- Surat
- Lucknow
- Bombay
- Calcutta
Show answer
Answer: B. The pact between the Congress and the Muslim League was made at Lucknow in 1916.
-
3. The Muslim League was founded in
- 1905
- 1885
- 1906
- 1916
Show answer
Answer: C. The All India Muslim League was founded at Dhaka in 1906.
-
4. Assertion: Hume was the first president of the Congress. Reason: Hume organised the first session. The best judgement is that
- both are false
- both are true and the reason explains it
- the assertion is true, though the reason is false
- the assertion is false, though the reason is true
Show answer
Answer: D. Hume organised the first session, but W. C. Bonnerjee was the first president.
-
5. Which word in a statement most often signals that it is false?
- Many
- Some
- Only
- Often
Show answer
Answer: C. Absolute words such as 'only', 'all' and 'never' make a statement hard to defend, so they are often false.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.