- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Kingdoms versus gana-sanghas: statement questions and common confusions
Judge statements about monarchies and gana-sanghas correctly, and avoid the usual confusions about republics, the Shakyas and the Licchavis.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Statement-type questions test whether you understand how kingdoms and gana-sanghas actually worked, not just their names. The traps are predictable: calling gana-sanghas democracies, counting the Shakyas among the sixteen, and mixing up the Vajjis and the Licchavis.
Key facts in one table
| Feature | Monarchy (rajya) | Gana-sangha |
|---|---|---|
| Ruler | One king; throne passed in the family | Many rajas of the ruling clans |
| Decision | King with ministers and officials | Discussion in an assembly |
| Examples among the sixteen | Magadha, Kosala, Vatsa, Avanti and most others | Vajji, Malla |
| Other examples | - | Shakyas of Kapilavastu (not one of the sixteen) |
| Excluded people | Ordinary subjects | Women, dasas (slaves), karmakaras (labourers) |
Five confusions to avoid
- 'Gana-sanghas were democracies.' Wrong. Only men of the ruling clans took part; women, slaves and labourers were excluded.
- 'The Shakyas were one of the sixteen mahajanapadas.' Wrong. The Shakyas were a gana-sangha, but they are not in the Anguttara Nikaya list.
- 'Vajji and Licchavi are two separate states.' Not quite. The Licchavis were the leading clan within the Vajji confederacy, with Vaishali as capital.
- 'All gana-sanghas were in the north-west.' Wrong. Vajji and Malla lay in the middle Ganga plain, in present-day Bihar and eastern Uttar Pradesh.
- 'Kings in this age needed no taxes.' Wrong. Kings collected taxes, including bhaga, a share of the crop, to pay for armies and forts.
The Buddha's link with gana-sanghas
The Buddha was born a Shakya and spent his last days among the Mallas; he passed away at Kushinara. Buddhist texts report that he praised the Vajjis for meeting often in full assemblies and acting together, saying that they would prosper as long as they kept up such habits. This shows how the assembly was seen as the strength of a gana-sangha. Mahavira, the twenty-fourth Jaina tirthankara, was born near Vaishali; his mother is described in Jaina tradition as a Licchavi princess.
Worked example 1
Question: Consider: 1. Vajji was a gana-sangha. 2. The Shakyas were one of the sixteen mahajanapadas. 3. In gana-sanghas, labourers voted in the assembly. Which is correct? Working: Statement 1 is right. Statement 2 is wrong: the Shakyas were a gana-sangha but not among the sixteen. Statement 3 is wrong: labourers (karmakaras) were excluded. Answer: 1 only.
Worked example 2
Question: A passage describes a state where 'many rajas met in the hall to decide on war'. Which is it more likely to be, Avanti or Malla? Working: Many rajas deciding together in an assembly is the mark of a gana-sangha. Avanti was a kingdom under Pradyota; Malla was a gana-sangha. Answer: Malla.
Gana-sangha = many rajas in an assembly, not a democracy. Among the sixteen: Vajji (Licchavis, Vaishali) and Malla. Shakyas: a gana-sangha but not one of the sixteen.
Frequently asked questions
Were the Mallas a kingdom or a gana-sangha?
A gana-sangha, with centres at Kushinara and Pava.
Is Kapilavastu the capital of one of the sixteen mahajanapadas?
No. Kapilavastu was the centre of the Shakya gana-sangha, which is not in the list of sixteen.
Key takeaways
- Most mahajanapadas were monarchies; Vajji and Malla were gana-sanghas.
- The Licchavis were the leading clan of the Vajji confederacy.
- The Shakyas were a gana-sangha outside the list of sixteen.
- Gana-sanghas excluded women, slaves and labourers.
Check your understanding
-
1. Consider: 1. The Licchavis were the leading clan of the Vajji confederacy. 2. Vaishali was the capital of the Vajjis. Which is correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: C. Both are correct: the Licchavis led the Vajji confederacy, whose capital was Vaishali.
-
2. Which statement about the Shakyas is correct?
- They were a monarchy ruled by Bimbisara
- They were a gana-sangha, but not one of the sixteen mahajanapadas
- They were the leading clan of the Vajji confederacy
- Their capital was Ujjain
Show answer
Answer: B. The Shakyas, the Buddha's clan, were a gana-sangha centred at Kapilavastu; they are not in the list of sixteen. The Licchavis led the Vajjis, and Ujjain was Avanti's capital.
-
3. Which group could take part in a gana-sangha assembly?
- Dasas
- Karmakaras
- Women of the ruling clans
- Men of the ruling clans
Show answer
Answer: D. Only men of the ruling clans, the rajas, took part. Dasas (slaves), karmakaras (labourers) and women were excluded.
-
4. Where did the Buddha pass away?
- Kushinara
- Kaushambi
- Shravasti
- Taxila
Show answer
Answer: A. The Buddha passed away at Kushinara, a capital of the Malla gana-sangha.
-
5. Consider: 1. Avanti was a gana-sangha. 2. Malla was a gana-sangha. 3. Kosala was a monarchy. Which are correct?
- 1 and 2 only
- 2 and 3 only
- 1 and 3 only
- 1, 2 and 3
Show answer
Answer: B. Malla was a gana-sangha and Kosala a monarchy. Avanti was a monarchy under kings such as Pradyota, so statement 1 is wrong.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.