• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

How the provinces and districts decided: Punjab, Bengal, the Frontier and Sylhet

Learn how the Mountbatten Plan was put into practice in provinces and districts, and what the boundaries of 1947 divided.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The 3 June Plan did not draw a line itself. It set a method for each province to decide. This lesson explains the method, the places involved and the main outcomes. Take it step by step with a map in mind: Punjab in the north-west, Bengal in the east, the Frontier in the far north-west and Sylhet in Assam.

The method of the plan

  • The provincial assemblies of Punjab and Bengal would meet in two parts: members from the Muslim-majority districts and members from the other districts. If either part voted for partition, the province would be divided.
  • The North-West Frontier Province and the Sylhet district of Assam would hold a referendum on whether to join Pakistan.
  • Sind and Baluchistan took their decisions by votes of their own bodies.
  • A boundary commission would draw the lines for the divided provinces.

What happened

Provincial decisions, June to July 1947
PlaceOutcome
PunjabThe assembly voted for partition; the province was divided into West Punjab (Pakistan) and East Punjab (India)
BengalThe assembly voted for partition; the province was divided into East Bengal (Pakistan) and West Bengal (India)
North-West Frontier ProvinceThe referendum favoured Pakistan
SylhetThe referendum favoured East Bengal; most of the district joined Pakistan, but the Karimganj area stayed in Assam
SindThe assembly voted to join Pakistan

The Radcliffe Line

Sir Cyril Radcliffe, a lawyer who had not visited India before 1947, chaired the boundary commissions. He had very little time. The principle was to divide on the basis of contiguous Muslim-majority and non-Muslim-majority areas, but other things were also considered, such as canals, railways and the position of towns. Lahore went to Pakistan and Amritsar to India. Calcutta stayed in India. The Chittagong Hill Tracts went to East Pakistan. Many people found that their homes lay on the other side of a line that they had not expected.

Why the line caused hardship

The line cut through districts where communities were mixed. Farms were cut off from markets, canals were separated from the fields that they watered, and railways and roads had to be re-planned. Because the awards were published only on 17 August, many people did not know where they lived until after independence. That uncertainty added to fear and to movement across the line.

Worked examples

Example 1. Which method decided the future of the North-West Frontier Province? Working: a referendum in July 1947, not a vote of the assembly.

Example 2. The plan said that if either half of the assembly of a province voted for division, it would be divided. In Punjab and Bengal, did this mean both halves had to agree? Working: no. The vote of one half was enough to divide the province.

Example 3. Which of these was in India after the award: Amritsar, Lahore, Calcutta? Working: Amritsar and Calcutta were in India, and Lahore was in Pakistan.

Punjab and Bengal: assemblies voted in two halves, one vote for division was enough. Frontier and Sylhet: referendums. Sind: vote. Boundary: Radcliffe, awards on 17 August 1947.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways. Each region used its own method of deciding. The Radcliffe Line divided Punjab and Bengal in a few weeks. The delay in publishing the awards added to confusion.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which province held a referendum in July 1947 to decide whether to join Pakistan?

    1. Bombay Province
    2. Madras Province
    3. Frontier Province
    4. Orissa Province
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Frontier Province held a referendum. Punjab and Bengal voted in their assemblies, and Sind decided by a vote of its assembly.

  2. 2. In Punjab and Bengal, a province would be divided if

    1. a referendum held in each district
    2. both halves voted for partition
    3. the Viceroy agreed to it alone
    4. either half voted for partition
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The plan allowed the vote of either half to divide the province.

  3. 3. Which district of Assam held a referendum?

    1. Sylhet
    2. Kamrup
    3. Cachar
    4. Lushai Hills
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Sylhet held a referendum in July 1947.

  4. 4. Who chaired the boundary commissions?

    1. Lord Mountbatten
    2. Lord Wavell
    3. Sir Cyril Radcliffe
    4. Sir Stafford Cripps
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Sir Cyril Radcliffe chaired the commissions for both provinces.

  5. 5. The boundary awards were published on

    1. 17 August 1947
    2. 3 June 1947
    3. 15 August 1947
    4. 18 July 1947
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The awards were announced two days after independence, on 17 August 1947.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery