- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Plans and missions compared: August Offer to Mountbatten Plan
Compare the British proposals of 1940 to 1947 by year, proposer, main feature and result, and avoid the usual mix-ups.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A favourite type of question lists a proposal and asks you to name its year or proposer. Because several proposals contain similar words, it is best to compare them in one table. Learn the table, then study the traps that follow.
The comparison table
| Proposal | Year | Proposer | Main feature | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| August Offer | 1940 | Viceroy Linlithgow | Dominion status as an aim after the war; expansion of the Executive Council; assurance to minorities | Rejected by the Congress; the League welcomed the assurance to minorities but held that partition was the only solution |
| Cripps Proposals | 1942 | Stafford Cripps | Dominion status after the war; a Constituent Assembly; provinces could stay out | Rejected by the Congress and the League |
| CR Formula | 1944 | C. Rajagopalachari | A plebiscite in Muslim-majority areas after the war to decide on separation | The Gandhi-Jinnah talks failed |
| Wavell Plan, Simla Conference | 1945 | Viceroy Wavell | Executive Council with equal numbers of caste Hindus and Muslims | Broke down over naming Muslim members |
| Cabinet Mission Plan | 1946 | Pethick-Lawrence, Cripps and Alexander | Loose union, groups of provinces, Constituent Assembly, interim government | Not fully accepted; riots followed |
| Mountbatten Plan | 1947 | Lord Mountbatten | Partition, referendum or votes in the provinces, earlier date | Accepted; independence on 15 August 1947 |
Why each plan failed or succeeded
- August Offer: the Congress wanted a firm promise of freedom, while the League, though given an assurance that no constitution would be imposed without the minorities, now wanted partition.
- Cripps: the offer was for after the war and allowed provinces to stay out, which satisfied neither side.
- CR Formula: the two leaders could not agree on the terms of the plebiscite.
- Wavell Plan: the League insisted on naming all Muslim members, and the Congress would not accept that.
- Cabinet Mission: the parties read the grouping clauses differently.
- Mountbatten Plan: it settled the matter by accepting partition and a fixed date.
Traps to avoid
- Two Cripps. Cripps came in 1942 with proposals made when Japan threatened India, and in 1946 as a member of the Cabinet Mission.
- Wavell. He was the Viceroy during 1943 to 1947, and the Wavell Plan was his 1945 plan. A question that lists Wavell as a member of the Cabinet Mission is wrong.
- CR Formula and the Gandhi-Jinnah talks belong together (1944).
- Attlee announced the date on 20 February 1947, but the Mountbatten Plan came on 3 June 1947.
Worked examples
Example 1. Match the proposals to the years: CR Formula, Wavell Plan, Cripps Proposals. Working: Cripps Proposals 1942, CR Formula 1944, Wavell Plan 1945. So the order is Cripps, CR, Wavell.
Example 2. Which of these proposed a plebiscite in Muslim-majority areas: CR Formula, Wavell Plan, Cabinet Mission Plan? Working: the CR Formula of 1944 proposed a plebiscite after the war. The Wavell Plan dealt with the Executive Council, and the Cabinet Mission Plan proposed a loose union. The answer is the CR Formula.
Example 3. Which proposal did not accept Pakistan but did allow groups of provinces: Cabinet Mission or Mountbatten Plan? Working: the Cabinet Mission rejected a sovereign Pakistan and proposed groups within a loose union. The Mountbatten Plan accepted partition. So the answer is the Cabinet Mission.
1940 August Offer; 1942 Cripps; 1944 CR Formula; 1945 Wavell Plan (Simla); 1946 Cabinet Mission; 1947 Mountbatten. Cabinet Mission = loose union; Mountbatten = partition.
Key takeaways. Learn the table. Remember the two meanings of Cripps and the difference between Wavell as Viceroy and the Wavell Plan.
Check your understanding
-
1. The CR Formula of 1944 suggested
- the division of Punjab at once
- an immediate transfer of power to the Muslim League
- a plebiscite in Muslim-majority areas after the war
- a Constituent Assembly of princes
Show answer
Answer: C. The CR Formula proposed a plebiscite after the war to decide on separation.
-
2. Which proposal talked about equal numbers of caste Hindus and Muslims in the Executive Council?
- The Cripps Proposals of 1942
- The Wavell Plan of 1945
- The Cabinet Mission Plan of 1946
- The Mountbatten Plan of 1947
Show answer
Answer: B. The Wavell Plan at the Simla Conference had that feature.
-
3. The Cabinet Mission rejected
- a Constituent Assembly
- an interim government
- groups of provinces
- a sovereign Pakistan
Show answer
Answer: D. The Mission rejected a separate sovereign Pakistan and proposed a loose union.
-
4. Which one was NOT a member of the Cabinet Mission?
- Pethick-Lawrence
- Lord Wavell
- Alexander
- Stafford Cripps
Show answer
Answer: B. Wavell was the Viceroy, not a member of the Mission.
-
5. The August Offer of 1940 was made by
- Lord Wavell
- Lord Mountbatten
- Stafford Cripps
- Viceroy Linlithgow
Show answer
Answer: D. Linlithgow was the Viceroy in 1940.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.