- Advanced
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
The Shunga phase reassessed: sources, Brahmanical revival, Bhagavatism and Buddhist art
Weigh the sources for the Shungas, judge the claim that Pushyamitra persecuted Buddhists, and connect the period with Bhagavatism and early Buddhist art.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, the Shungas are not just a name in a list. Questions ask how we know about them, whether the hostile picture of Pushyamitra in Buddhist writing holds up, and why monuments such as Bharhut and the Heliodorus pillar matter. The answer in each case depends on reading several kinds of source together.
The sources and what each contributes
| Source | Type | What it tells us |
|---|---|---|
| Puranas | Dynastic lists | Names and order of Shunga and Kanva kings |
| Patanjali's Mahabhashya | Grammar | Its examples speak of Yavana (Greek) attacks on Saketa and Madhyamika, read as Greek raids in Patanjali's time |
| Kalidasa's Malavikagnimitram | Later drama | Agnimitra at Vidisha; his son Vasumitra defeats Yavanas on the Sindhu |
| Divyavadana | Buddhist text | Portrays Pushyamitra as a destroyer of monasteries |
| Ayodhya inscription of Dhanadeva | Inscription | Calls Pushyamitra the performer of two horse sacrifices |
| Bharhut gateway inscription | Inscription | Records the gateway as built in the reign of the Shungas |
| Besnagar pillar | Inscription | A Greek envoy at a central Indian court, devoted to Vasudeva |
Notice the caution needed with each. Kalidasa wrote centuries later, so his play is a late source. Patanjali's examples are grammatical sentences, not chronicles. The Divyavadana was written by Buddhists with a reason to cast Pushyamitra as a villain. Inscriptions are contemporary and so carry more weight, but they record only what their authors chose to say.
Did Pushyamitra persecute Buddhists?
The case for: the Divyavadana and later Buddhist tradition describe him destroying monasteries and killing monks, and he openly revived Vedic ritual with the Ashvamedha. The case against: the Bharhut stupa received its carved railings and gateway in the Shunga period, and the great stupa at Sanchi was enlarged with a stone casing and railing at about this time. Large Buddhist building does not fit a policy of persecution across the kingdom. A balanced answer says the evidence is mixed: there may have been local hostility, but Buddhism continued to flourish under Shunga rule.
Bhagavatism and the Heliodorus pillar
The pillar at Besnagar near Vidisha was set up by Heliodorus, son of Dion, a native of Taxila and envoy of the Indo-Greek king Antialcidas to a king called Bhagabhadra. It is a Garuda pillar dedicated to Vasudeva, the god of gods, and Heliodorus calls himself a Bhagavata. The inscription also names three steps to immortality: self-restraint, generosity and watchfulness. Three conclusions follow: devotion to Vasudeva (early Vaishnavism) was established in central India by the second century BCE; Greeks were adopting Indian religions; and Indo-Greek and Indian kingdoms exchanged envoys, not only armies.
Art: the aniconic phase
At Bharhut the Buddha is never shown in human form. His presence is marked by symbols: the Bodhi tree, the wheel of law, footprints, an empty throne or a stupa. The railings carry labelled scenes from the Jatakas, as well as yakshas and yakshis, local nature spirits absorbed into Buddhist art. This aniconic stage is the background against which the Buddha image appears later at Gandhara and Mathura.
Worked examples
Example 1. Statement: "The Shunga period saw the end of Buddhist building in central India." Is it correct? Working: Bharhut's railings and gateway date to the Shunga period, and an inscription there names the reign of the Shungas; Sanchi was enlarged. So the statement is incorrect.
Example 2. What can the Heliodorus pillar tell us about religion? Working: a Greek calls himself a Bhagavata and dedicates a Garuda pillar to Vasudeva. So devotion to Vasudeva existed by the second century BCE and attracted foreigners - evidence for early Bhagavatism.
Weigh sources by date and motive: inscriptions are contemporary; Kalidasa is late; the Divyavadana is partisan. Bharhut and Sanchi show Buddhism thriving under the Shungas.
Key takeaways: the Shungas are known from Puranas, Patanjali, a late play, a hostile Buddhist text and a few inscriptions. The persecution story is contested by the evidence of Bharhut and Sanchi. The Heliodorus pillar is key evidence for early Bhagavatism and for Greek adoption of Indian faiths. Shunga-period Buddhist art shows the Buddha only through symbols.
Check your understanding
-
1. Consider the following statements: 1. Pushyamitra Shunga performed the Ashvamedha sacrifice. 2. Patanjali, author of the Mahabhashya, is traditionally placed in Pushyamitra's reign. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: C. Both are correct. An inscription from Ayodhya credits Pushyamitra with horse sacrifices, and Patanjali is traditionally his contemporary.
-
2. Consider the following statements about the Besnagar pillar: 1. Heliodorus was an envoy of the Indo-Greek king Antialcidas. 2. The pillar is dedicated to Shiva. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: A. Only statement 1 is correct. The pillar is a Garuda pillar dedicated to Vasudeva, not Shiva.
-
3. In the carvings of the Bharhut stupa, the Buddha is represented mainly through:
- Standing human figures in Greek dress
- Symbols such as the Bodhi tree, the wheel and footprints
- Bronze images placed in niches
- Paintings on plastered walls
Show answer
Answer: B. Bharhut belongs to the aniconic phase: the Buddha is shown by symbols such as the Bodhi tree, the wheel, footprints and an empty throne.
-
4. Which source portrays Pushyamitra Shunga as a persecutor of Buddhists?
- Malavikagnimitram
- Mahabhashya
- Hathigumpha inscription
- Divyavadana
Show answer
Answer: D. The Buddhist text Divyavadana portrays Pushyamitra as hostile to Buddhism. Historians treat it with caution because Buddhist building continued under the Shungas.
-
5. Consider the following statements: 1. Kalidasa was a contemporary of Agnimitra. 2. Malavikagnimitram is used, with caution, as a source for conflict between the Shungas and the Yavanas. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
Show answer
Answer: B. Only statement 2 is correct. Kalidasa lived centuries after Agnimitra, so his play is a late source, used with caution for the Shunga-Yavana conflict.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.