- Advanced
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Reading Article 368 clause by clause
Analyse each clause of Article 368 and its link with Article 13, including the clauses added by the 24th and 42nd Amendments and their fate in court.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, questions quote a clause and ask where it came from, what it does, or whether it still stands. That requires knowing Article 368 as a structured text rather than as a summary. This lesson walks through it clause by clause and connects each clause to the Article 13 debate that shaped it.
Clause (1): the power and its nature
Clause (1) says that, notwithstanding anything in the Constitution, Parliament may in exercise of its constituent power amend by way of addition, variation or repeal any provision of the Constitution in accordance with the procedure in the Article. The words 'constituent power' and the non-obstante opening were inserted by the 24th Amendment (1971). Their purpose was to make clear that an amendment is an exercise of constituent power, not ordinary legislative power, and so is not a 'law' under Article 13. Note the three modes - addition, variation, repeal - an option claiming that Parliament can only 'add' or only 'vary' is wrong.
Clause (2) and its proviso: procedure and entrenchment
Clause (2) lays down the procedure: initiation only by a bill in either House; passage in each House by a majority of total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting; presentation to the President, who shall give assent (the mandatory 'shall' is also from the 24th Amendment). The proviso adds ratification by not less than one-half of the state legislatures, before presentation to the President, for amendments to: (a) Articles 54, 55, 73, 162, 241 or 279A; (b) Chapter IV of Part V, Chapter V of Part VI or Chapter I of Part XI; (c) any list in the Seventh Schedule; (d) the representation of states in Parliament; or (e) the provisions of Article 368.
Clause (3) and Article 13(4)
Clause (3) says nothing in Article 13 applies to an amendment made under Article 368. The 24th Amendment added the mirror image to Article 13 itself as clause (4): nothing in Article 13 applies to an amendment made under Article 368. Together they reversed Golak Nath, which had treated an amendment as a 'law' that could not abridge Fundamental Rights. Kesavananda Bharati upheld both clauses but read in the implied limit of the basic structure.
Clauses (4) and (5): added, then struck down
The 42nd Amendment (1976) added clause (4), saying no amendment could be called in question in any court on any ground, and clause (5), declaring that there is no limitation whatever on Parliament's constituent power. In Minerva Mills (1980) the Supreme Court struck down both, holding that judicial review and limited amending power are themselves basic features. The clauses remain printed in the text with a note, but they are not operative law.
| Clause | Content | Origin and status |
|---|---|---|
| 368(1) | Constituent power; addition, variation, repeal | Reworded by the 24th Amendment; valid |
| 368(2) | Procedure; President shall assent; proviso on ratification | 'Shall assent' from 24th; 279A added to proviso by 101st |
| 368(3) | Article 13 does not apply | 24th Amendment; valid (subject to basic structure) |
| 368(4), (5) | No judicial review; no limit on power | 42nd Amendment; struck down in Minerva Mills |
24th built the fortress (constituent power, 'shall assent', 13(4), 368(3)); Kesavananda put the basic-structure wall around it; 42nd tried to remove the wall (368(4), (5)); Minerva Mills put it back.
Worked example 1
Assertion: Article 368(5) shows that Parliament's amending power is unlimited. Reason: the 42nd Amendment inserted clause (5). Evaluate: the Reason is true as history. The Assertion is false as law, because Minerva Mills struck down clause (5). So the correct choice is 'Assertion false, Reason true'. The trap is to treat the printed text as current law.
Worked example 2
Which of the following, if amended, would need state ratification: (1) Article 162, (2) Article 13, (3) Chapter I of Part XI, (4) Article 368(3)? Article 162 is named in (a), Part XI Chapter I in (b), and any part of Article 368 falls in (e). Article 13 is not listed. Answer: 1, 3 and 4.
Key takeaways: clause (1) defines a constituent power to add, vary or repeal; clause (2) and its proviso fix the procedure and the entrenched list; clause (3) and Article 13(4) keep Article 13 away from amendments; clauses (4) and (5) were struck down in Minerva Mills.
Check your understanding
-
1. The expression 'in exercise of its constituent power' in Article 368(1) was inserted by the
- 42nd Amendment
- 24th Amendment
- 44th Amendment
- 1st Amendment
Show answer
Answer: B. The 24th Amendment (1971) reworded Article 368(1) and added the words.
-
2. Article 13(4), stating that Article 13 does not apply to amendments under Article 368, was inserted by the
- 24th Amendment
- 25th Amendment
- 42nd Amendment
- 44th Amendment
Show answer
Answer: A. The 24th Amendment inserted Article 13(4) and Article 368(3).
-
3. Which clauses of Article 368 were struck down in Minerva Mills?
- Clauses (1) and (2)
- Clause (3) only
- Clauses (4) and (5)
- The proviso to clause (2)
Show answer
Answer: C. Clauses (4) and (5), inserted by the 42nd Amendment, were struck down in 1980.
-
4. Which article was added to the ratification list in the proviso to Article 368(2) by the 101st Amendment?
- Article 246A
- Article 269A
- Article 280
- Article 279A
Show answer
Answer: D. The 101st Amendment added Article 279A (GST Council) to clause (a) of the proviso.
-
5. Under Article 368(1) Parliament may amend a provision by way of
- Addition only
- Variation only
- Addition, variation or repeal
- Repeal only with state consent
Show answer
Answer: C. The clause expressly allows addition, variation or repeal of any provision.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.