- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Legislative relations: the three lists, residuary power and repugnancy
Apply Articles 245-254 to decide who may legislate on a subject, which law prevails in a conflict, and how the courts read overlapping entries.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions on Centre-State relations rarely ask you to recite an article number. They give you a situation - a state law and a Union law on overlapping subjects, a subject that appears in no list, a state law that received the President's assent - and ask which law survives. This lesson builds the decision path the Constitution itself follows, so you can settle such questions in a few seconds.
Where the rules live
Part XI of the Constitution deals with relations between the Union and the states. Chapter I (Articles 245 to 255) covers legislative relations and Chapter II (Articles 256 to 263) covers administrative relations. Financial relations sit in Part XII. The subjects themselves are distributed by the Seventh Schedule into List I (Union List), List II (State List) and List III (Concurrent List). Article 245 sets the territorial extent: Parliament may legislate for the whole or any part of India, and a state legislature for the whole or any part of its state. A Union law is not invalid merely because it operates outside India (extra-territorial operation).
Article 246: the order of priority
Article 246 creates a hierarchy. Parliament has exclusive power over List I, notwithstanding anything in the other two clauses. Both Parliament and the state legislatures may legislate on List III. The state has exclusive power over List II, but subject to the first two clauses. That wording gives the Union List priority when an entry in List I genuinely overlaps an entry in List II. Clause (4) lets Parliament legislate on any matter, even a State List matter, for a part of India that is not included in a state, such as a Union Territory.
Article 248 gives residuary power - any matter not in List II or List III, including any tax not mentioned in either - to Parliament, reinforced by the last entry of List I. Article 246A, inserted by the 101st Amendment (2016), is a special rule for goods and services tax: Parliament and the state legislatures both have power to make laws on GST, but Parliament alone legislates on GST on supplies in the course of inter-state trade or commerce.
How courts read overlapping entries
- Pith and substance: a law is classified by its true nature and character. If in substance it falls in a list the legislature may use, an incidental touch on another list does not invalidate it.
- Colourable legislation: a legislature cannot do indirectly what it cannot do directly. The label of a law does not decide its validity; its substance does.
- Harmonious construction: entries are read so that each list keeps its meaning, and an overlap is resolved by giving the Union List priority only where a real conflict remains.
Article 254: repugnancy on the Concurrent List
If a state law on a Concurrent List matter is repugnant to a Union law on the same matter, the Union law prevails and the state law is void to the extent of the repugnancy (Article 254(1)). The exception is Article 254(2): if the state law was reserved for the President's consideration and received his assent, it prevails in that state. Even then Parliament may later enact a law on the same matter that adds to, amends, varies or repeals the state law. Remember that repugnancy under Article 254 arises only on Concurrent List subjects; a conflict between a List I and a List II entry is settled by Article 246 itself.
Decision path: Which list? (Article 246 / 248) -> If Concurrent and conflicting, Union law wins (254(1)) -> unless the state law got the President's assent (254(2)) -> but Parliament can still override it later.
Worked example 1
A state passes a law on a Concurrent List subject after the President's assent under Article 254(2). Three years later Parliament passes a law on the same matter that expressly repeals the state law. Which prevails? Step 1: the subject is in List III, so Article 254 applies. Step 2: the state law prevailed in that state because of the President's assent. Step 3: the proviso to Article 254(2) lets Parliament add to, amend, vary or repeal it. So the later Union law prevails and the state law stands repealed.
Worked example 2
Parliament wants to levy a new tax on a kind of transaction that is named in no list. Can it? Step 1: check List II and List III - the tax is in neither. Step 2: Article 248 gives the residuary power, including any tax not mentioned in List II or List III, to Parliament. So Parliament may levy it; a state may not. A common wrong option says the residuary power belongs to the states, which is the position in some other federations, not India.
Key takeaways: Article 246 sets the priority List I > List III > List II; residuary power, including residuary taxation, is with Parliament (Article 248); repugnancy under Article 254 concerns the Concurrent List; a state law with the President's assent prevails in that state only until Parliament legislates again; GST has its own rule in Article 246A.
Check your understanding
-
1. Residuary powers of legislation in India are vested in
- The state legislatures
- Parliament
- Parliament and states jointly
- The President acting alone
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 248 and the residuary entry of List I give any matter not in List II or List III, including such taxes, to Parliament.
-
2. Under Article 254(2), a state law on a Concurrent List subject that is repugnant to an earlier Union law prevails in that state if
- It is passed by a two-thirds majority in the Assembly
- The Governor gives assent
- It was reserved for and received the assent of the President
- The Rajya Sabha passes a resolution approving it
Show answer
Answer: C. Only the President's assent, after reservation, saves the state law under Article 254(2); even then Parliament may later amend or repeal it.
-
3. Which doctrine classifies a law by its true nature, ignoring incidental effects on another list?
- Colourable legislation
- Pith and substance
- Eclipse
- Severability
Show answer
Answer: B. Pith and substance looks at the true nature and character of the law; incidental encroachment does not invalidate it.
-
4. Article 246A, inserted by the 101st Amendment, deals with
- Residuary taxation
- Goods and services tax
- Inter-state water disputes
- Extra-territorial laws
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 246A gives Parliament and state legislatures power over GST, with inter-state supply reserved to Parliament.
-
5. Consider: (1) Under Article 246(4) Parliament may legislate on a State List matter for a Union Territory. (2) Repugnancy under Article 254 is about conflict between a Union List law and a State List law. Which is correct?
- 1 only
- 2 only
- Both
- Neither
Show answer
Answer: A. Statement 1 is Article 246(4). Statement 2 is wrong: Article 254 repugnancy concerns Concurrent List matters; List I v List II overlap is settled by Article 246's priority clause.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.