- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Mapping constitutional bodies: articles, status and the classic traps
Build an exact map of which bodies the Constitution itself creates, under which Article, who appoints and who removes them, and spot the bodies that changed status.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, questions on constitutional bodies are rarely about a single fact. They mix two or three bodies in one statement, swap an Article number, or quietly describe a statutory body as constitutional. The fastest way through is a precise mental map: which bodies the Constitution itself creates, the Article that creates each one, and the asymmetries in appointment and removal that examiners love. This lesson builds that map and the elimination habits that go with it.
What makes a body constitutional
A constitutional body is one whose existence and core features are written into the Constitution. It cannot be abolished, and its protected features cannot be changed, by an ordinary law; that needs a constitutional amendment. A statutory body is created by an Act of Parliament or a state legislature, and the legislature can amend or repeal that Act. An executive (non-statutory) body is created by a government resolution or order. The test is always the same: ask where the body's existence comes from, not how important it is.
| Body | Article(s) | Appointed by |
|---|---|---|
| Election Commission of India | 324 | President |
| Union Public Service Commission | 315-323 | President |
| State Public Service Commission | 315-323 | Governor |
| Finance Commission | 280 | President |
| Goods and Services Tax Council | 279A | Composition fixed by Article 279A |
| Comptroller and Auditor General | 148-151 | President |
| Attorney General of India | 76 | President |
| Advocate General of a state | 165 | Governor |
| National Commission for Scheduled Castes | 338 | President |
| National Commission for Scheduled Tribes | 338A | President |
| National Commission for Backward Classes | 338B | President |
| Special Officer for Linguistic Minorities | 350B | President |
Bodies whose status changed
- National Commission for Backward Classes: set up as a statutory body in 1993, made constitutional by the 102nd Amendment (2018), which inserted Article 338B.
- Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes: Article 338 first provided for a Special Officer; the 65th Amendment (1990) created a multi-member national commission for both; the 89th Amendment (2003) split it into two, with Article 338A for Scheduled Tribes.
- GST Council: created by the 101st Amendment (2016), which inserted Article 279A.
- Special Officer for Linguistic Minorities: Article 350B was inserted by the 7th Amendment (1956).
Provided for, but created by order
The Inter-State Council is the standard trap. Article 263 says that if it appears to the President that the public interest would be served, the President may establish such a council. The Article is permissive, not compulsory, and the council was actually established in 1990 by a Presidential order, following the Sarkaria Commission's recommendation. So the power comes from the Constitution, but the body itself was created by an executive order. Read the exact wording of any statement about it.
Worked example 1: a three-statement question
Consider: (1) The Finance Commission and the GST Council are both constitutional bodies. (2) The National Commission for Backward Classes has been constitutional since its creation. (3) Members of a State Public Service Commission are appointed and removed by the Governor. Statement 1 is correct: Articles 280 and 279A. Statement 2 is wrong: it was statutory from 1993 and became constitutional only in 2018. Statement 3 is wrong: the Governor appoints, but Article 317 lets only the President remove. Answer: 1 only. Notice that each wrong statement hides exactly one false word: 'since its creation' and 'removed'.
Worked example 2: elimination by asymmetry
Question: for which office are the appointing and the removing authority different? Options: (a) Attorney General; (b) Advocate General; (c) member of a State Public Service Commission; (d) none of these. Tabulate before reading too much into the options. The Attorney General is appointed by the President and holds office during the President's pleasure, so the President both appoints and removes. The Advocate General is appointed by the Governor and holds office during the Governor's pleasure, so the same authority does both. An SPSC member is appointed by the Governor but, under Article 317, removed only by the President. Answer: (c). The Chief Election Commissioner is a second example of the same pattern: appointed by the President, but removable only through the Supreme Court-judge procedure involving Parliament. Always write down appoint/remove for each office first; the odd one out then shows itself.
Ask where the body comes from: the Constitution (constitutional), an Act (statutory) or a resolution or order (executive). Then check the two asymmetries: SPSC members are appointed by the Governor but removed by the President; the CEC is appointed by the President but removed like a Supreme Court judge.
Key takeaways
Memorise the Article for each body in one table, together with the appointing authority. Track the four status changes: 338B in 2018, 338A in 2003, 279A in 2016 and 350B in 1956. Treat any statement about the Inter-State Council with care, because the Constitution only enables it. In multi-statement questions, look for the single word that makes a statement false.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which body became a constitutional body through the 102nd Constitutional Amendment?
- National Commission for Scheduled Tribes
- National Commission for Backward Classes
- National Commission for Scheduled Castes
- National Human Rights Commission
Show answer
Answer: B. The 102nd Amendment (2018) inserted Article 338B and gave the National Commission for Backward Classes constitutional status. The Scheduled Tribes commission came from the 89th Amendment, and the NHRC is statutory.
-
2. Article 338A of the Constitution provides for the:
- National Commission for Scheduled Castes
- National Commission for Backward Classes
- National Commission for Scheduled Tribes
- Special Officer for Linguistic Minorities
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 338 is for Scheduled Castes, 338A for Scheduled Tribes (89th Amendment, 2003), 338B for Backward Classes and 350B for the Special Officer for Linguistic Minorities.
-
3. A member of a State Public Service Commission is appointed by the Governor. Who can remove that member?
- The President
- The Governor
- The Chief Justice of the High Court
- The state legislature by resolution
Show answer
Answer: A. Under Article 317, members of a State Public Service Commission can be removed only by the President, even though the Governor appoints them.
-
4. Which one of the following is NOT a constitutional body?
- GST Council
- Finance Commission
- Central Vigilance Commission
- Comptroller and Auditor General
Show answer
Answer: C. The GST Council (Article 279A), Finance Commission (Article 280) and CAG (Article 148) are constitutional. The Central Vigilance Commission is a statutory body under an Act of Parliament.
-
5. Consider: (1) The Inter-State Council was established by a Presidential order using the power in Article 263. (2) Article 263 makes it compulsory to establish an Inter-State Council. Which is correct?
- Both 1 and 2
- Only 2
- Neither 1 nor 2
- Only 1
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 263 is permissive: the President may establish such a council if the public interest would be served. The council was established in 1990 by Presidential order. So statement 1 is correct and statement 2 is wrong.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.