• Advanced
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Value of votes in the Presidential election

Compute the value of an MLA's vote and an MP's vote using the rounding rules of Article 55, and decide a Presidential count with the majority quota and elimination.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

In the election of the President, votes are not all equal. An MLA from a populous state with few seats carries a heavier vote than an MLA from a small state, and an MP's vote is heavier still. Article 55 sets out the formula and two slightly different rounding rules, which make excellent hard questions. All populations in this lesson are illustrative numbers chosen for practice, not real census figures.

The two principles of Article 55

Article 55(1) asks for uniformity in the scale of representation of the different states, and parity between the states as a whole and the Union. Uniformity is achieved by giving each MLA a vote proportional to the population he or she represents. Parity is achieved by making the total value of all MPs' votes equal (as nearly as possible) to the total value of all MLAs' votes. The 'population' used is the census figure that the Constitution specifies for this purpose.

Value of an MLA's vote

  1. Divide the population of the state by the number of elected members of its Legislative Assembly.
  2. Count how many complete thousands are in that quotient: that is the value of each MLA's vote.
  3. If the remainder after taking the thousands is not less than 500, add 1.

Value of an MP's vote

  1. Add up the total value of the votes of all elected MLAs of all the states (including Delhi and Puducherry).
  2. Divide by the total number of elected members of both Houses of Parliament.
  3. A fraction exceeding one-half is counted as one; any other fraction is disregarded.

Spot the difference: for MLAs a remainder of exactly 500 rounds up ('not less than 500'), but for MPs a fraction of exactly one-half is dropped ('exceeding one-half'). Examiners use precisely this boundary.

Worked example 1: MLA vote with a boundary remainder

A state has a population of 1,93,05,000 and 110 elected MLAs. Working: 1,93,05,000 ÷ 110 = 1,75,500. Complete thousands = 175; remainder = 500. Since 500 is not less than 500, add 1: each MLA's vote = 176. Total value of the state's MLAs = 176 × 110 = 19,360.

Worked example 2: no rounding up

A state has a population of 4,12,34,567 and 200 elected MLAs. Working: 4,12,34,567 ÷ 200 = 2,06,172.8. Complete thousands = 206; remainder 172.8, less than 500, so no change: each vote = 206, total = 206 × 200 = 41,200.

Worked example 3: an MP's vote

Suppose the total value of all MLAs' votes in the country is 4,50,300 and there are 750 elected MPs. Working: 4,50,300 ÷ 750 = 600.4. The fraction 0.4 does not exceed one-half, so it is disregarded: each MP's vote = 600. Total MP value = 600 × 750 = 4,50,000, almost exactly equal to the MLAs' total, which is the parity Article 55 aims for. Had the quotient been 600.5, the fraction would be exactly one-half, which does not exceed one-half, so the value would still be 600.

Deciding the result

Voting is by proportional representation by single transferable vote with secret ballot. Each elector marks preferences 1, 2, 3 and so on. To win, a candidate needs more than half of the total value of valid votes. If no one has that on first preferences, the candidate with the lowest value is excluded and each of his or her ballots is transferred, at its value, to the next preference shown. This continues until someone crosses the half-way mark.

Worked example 4: an elimination count

Total valid value 10,00,000, so a candidate needs more than 5,00,000. First preferences: P 4,80,000; Q 3,70,000; R 1,50,000. No one has crossed half, so R is excluded. R's ballots carry second preferences worth 1,10,000 for P and 40,000 for Q. New totals: P 5,90,000; Q 4,10,000. P has more than 5,00,000 and is elected. Note the trap: a candidate leading on first preferences is not elected merely for leading; he must cross half.

MLA vote = thousands in (population ÷ elected MLAs), +1 if remainder is 500 or more. MP vote = (total MLA value ÷ elected MPs), +1 only if the fraction exceeds one-half. Winner needs more than half the valid value.

Key takeaways

Key takeaways. Only elected members count in both divisors. Write the quotient in full before taking thousands, and check the two rounding rules separately. The President's election needs an absolute majority of value, achieved by excluding the lowest candidates and transferring ballots until someone crosses half.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A state has a population of 87,65,000 and 50 elected MLAs. What is the value of each MLA's vote in the Presidential election?

    1. 176
    2. 175
    3. 1,753
    4. 17
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 87,65,000 ÷ 50 = 1,75,300. Complete thousands = 175; the remainder 300 is less than 500, so no addition. Value = 175.

  2. 2. A state has a population of 1,20,60,000 and 80 elected MLAs. What is the total value of all its MLAs' votes?

    1. 12,000
    2. 12,060
    3. 12,080
    4. 151
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 1,20,60,000 ÷ 80 = 1,50,750. Thousands = 150, remainder 750 ≥ 500, so each vote = 151. Total = 151 × 80 = 12,080.

  3. 3. The total value of all MLAs' votes is 5,50,000 and there are 800 elected MPs. What is the value of each MP's vote?

    1. 687
    2. 688
    3. 690
    4. 686
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 5,50,000 ÷ 800 = 687.5. The fraction is exactly one-half, which does not exceed one-half, so it is disregarded: 687.

  4. 4. Total valid value is 8,00,000. First preferences: X 3,90,000; Y 2,90,000; Z 1,20,000. Z is excluded; Z's ballots give 1,00,000 to Y and 20,000 to X. What is the result?

    1. Y is elected with 3,90,000
    2. No one is elected and a fresh poll is held
    3. X is elected as he led on first preferences, without counting transfers
    4. X is elected with 4,10,000, which is more than half
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Half of 8,00,000 is 4,00,000. After the transfer X has 4,10,000 and Y 3,90,000. X exceeds half and is elected; leading on first preferences alone would not have been enough.

  5. 5. Why is an MP's vote given a value equal to the total MLA value divided by the number of elected MPs?

    1. To secure parity between the states as a whole and the Union
    2. To give nominated MPs a say
    3. To make every MP's vote equal to one MLA's vote
    4. To give larger states more MPs
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 55 requires parity between the states as a whole and the Union, so the MPs' combined value is made (nearly) equal to the MLAs' combined value.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery