• Practice
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Which is NOT a Fundamental Duty? Odd-one-out and sorting drills

Learn the popular non-duties (voting, paying taxes, respecting elders, working) and sort duties from rights and directive principles, using a three-step test.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The favourite trap in this topic is the 'which is not' question. The examiner lists three real duties and one that sounds like a duty but is not in Article 51A. Candidates choose wrongly because the false option is a good thing to do. The remedy is to test every option against the actual list rather than against common sense.

A three-step test

  1. Is it addressed to the citizen? If it is addressed to the State, it is a Directive Principle, not a duty.
  2. Is it in Article 51A? Check it against the eleven themes: Constitution, freedom ideals, integrity, defence, harmony and women, heritage, environment, scientific temper, public property and non-violence, excellence, education of a child.
  3. Is it a right? A thing the citizen may do or claim, such as voting or speaking, belongs to Part III or to other laws.

Popular non-duties

  • Voting in elections. The right to vote is given by Article 326 and the law, but voting is not listed as a Fundamental Duty.
  • Paying taxes. A legal duty under tax laws. The Swaran Singh Committee suggested adding it, but it was not included.
  • Respecting parents and elders. A moral duty.
  • Promotion of international peace. This is Article 51, a Directive Principle addressed to the State, not Article 51A.
  • Providing free legal aid. Article 39A, a directive to the State.
  • Right to work, family planning, helping accident victims. None is a duty in Article 51A.

Sorting by Part

Which Part?
StatementPart and kind
Protect public property and give up violencePart IVA, duty (i)
Equal pay for equal work for men and womenPart IV, directive to the State (Article 39(d))
Freedom of speech and expressionPart III, Fundamental Right (Article 19(1)(a))
The State shall endeavour to protect the environmentPart IV, directive (Article 48A)
Every citizen shall protect and improve the natural environmentPart IVA, duty (g)

Worked example 1: odd one out

Question: Which is NOT a Fundamental Duty: (a) to safeguard public property, (b) to vote in every election, (c) to protect forests and wildlife, (d) to develop scientific temper? Working: (a) is clause (i). (c) belongs to clause (g). (d) is clause (h). (b), voting, is not in Article 51A. Answer: (b).

Worked example 2: right, directive or duty?

Question: Classify: (1) 'to defend the country', (2) 'the State shall promote international peace', (3) 'freedom to practise any profession'. Working: (1) is clause (d), addressed to citizens: a Fundamental Duty. (2) is Article 51, addressed to the State: a Directive Principle. (3) is Article 19(1)(g): a Fundamental Right. Answer: duty, directive, right.

Worked example 3: the tax trap

Question: 'Every citizen must pay taxes according to law.' Is this a Fundamental Duty? Working: Step 1, the statement is addressed to the citizen, so it passes the first test. Step 2, it is not among the eleven themes of Article 51A, so it fails the second test. Step 3, it is a legal obligation created by tax laws made under the powers of Parliament. The Swaran Singh Committee had suggested a duty of this kind, but the 42nd Amendment did not include it. Answer: not a Fundamental Duty; it is a legal duty.

Test each option three ways: who is addressed, is it in Article 51A, is it a right. Voting and paying taxes are never on the list.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Voting, taxes, respecting elders and promoting international peace are not Fundamental Duties.
  • If the sentence begins 'The State shall', it is a directive.
  • Check every option against the eleven themes.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these is NOT a Fundamental Duty?

    1. To safeguard public property
    2. To develop the scientific temper
    3. To pay income tax
    4. To value the composite culture
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Paying tax is a legal duty under tax laws, not a Fundamental Duty.

  2. 2. 'The State shall endeavour to promote international peace and security' is found in:

    1. Article 51A
    2. Article 51
    3. Article 21A
    4. Article 19
    Show answer

    Answer: B. It is Article 51, a Directive Principle addressed to the State.

  3. 3. Voting in elections is:

    1. a Fundamental Duty in clause (d)
    2. a Fundamental Duty in clause (j)
    3. not listed as a Fundamental Duty
    4. a Directive Principle
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Voting is not listed in Article 51A.

  4. 4. Which statement is a duty and not a directive?

    1. The State shall protect forests
    2. Every citizen shall protect forests
    3. The State shall promote peace
    4. The State shall give legal aid
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A duty begins 'It shall be the duty of every citizen'. Article 51A(g) says citizens must protect forests.

  5. 5. Freedom to form associations is a:

    1. Fundamental Duty
    2. Directive Principle
    3. legal duty
    4. Fundamental Right
    Show answer

    Answer: D. It is part of Article 19(1)(c) in Part III, a Fundamental Right.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery