- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Articles 12 and 13: State, void laws and key doctrines
Understand who counts as the State, when a law becomes void, and the doctrines of eclipse, severability and waiver that exam questions test.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Part III of the Constitution (Articles 12 to 35) contains the Fundamental Rights. Before any right can be claimed, two questions must be answered: against whom is the right available, and what happens to a law that violates it? Articles 12 and 13 answer them.
Article 12: who is the State?
For Part III, the State includes the Government and Parliament of India, the Government and Legislature of each State, and all local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India. Courts have read 'other authorities' to include bodies that exercise governmental functions or are deeply controlled by the government. Fundamental rights are mostly enforceable against the State; some, like Article 15(2), 17, 23 and 24, also operate against private persons.
Article 13: laws inconsistent with fundamental rights
- Article 13(1): pre-Constitution laws are void to the extent they are inconsistent with Part III.
- Article 13(2): the State shall not make any law that takes away or abridges the rights conferred by Part III; a law contravening this is void to that extent.
- Article 13(3): 'law' includes ordinances, orders, bye-laws, rules, regulations, notifications, customs and usages having the force of law.
- Article 13(4): added by the 24th Amendment, saying that Article 13 does not apply to a constitutional amendment made under Article 368.
Doctrines
| Doctrine | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Eclipse | A pre-Constitution law inconsistent with a fundamental right is not dead but overshadowed; it becomes enforceable again when the inconsistency is removed |
| Severability | Only the part of a law that violates a fundamental right is void, if the rest can stand on its own |
| Waiver | A fundamental right cannot be waived by a citizen; the rights are public policy, not just personal privileges |
An important contrast: the doctrine of eclipse applies to pre-constitutional laws, which are merely overshadowed. A post-constitutional law that violates Part III is void from the start (void ab initio), although later cases refined how this works for non-citizens.
Worked example 1: eclipse
A pre-1950 law restricts a freedom in a way that Article 19 does not permit. On 26 January 1950 it is overshadowed. If Parliament later amends Article 19 so that such a restriction becomes permitted, the law revives without being re-enacted. Reason: it was never dead, only eclipsed.
Worked example 2: severability
A statute has ten sections; section 6 violates Article 14, and the other nine can work independently. Under severability, only section 6 is declared void. If the valid and invalid parts are so mixed that removing one defeats the whole purpose, the entire statute falls.
Article 12 defines the State; Article 13 voids inconsistent laws; eclipse applies to pre-Constitution laws; a fundamental right cannot be waived.
Key takeaways: know the definition of State, the four clauses of Article 13 and the three doctrines.
Check your understanding
-
1. Article 13(4), saying Article 13 does not apply to amendments made under Article 368, was added by
- the 24th Amendment
- the 25th Amendment
- the 42nd Amendment
- the 44th Amendment
Show answer
Answer: A. The 24th Amendment (1971) inserted Article 13(4).
-
2. Which doctrine says a pre-Constitution law inconsistent with Fundamental Rights is only overshadowed, not dead?
- Doctrine of severability
- Doctrine of eclipse
- Doctrine of waiver
- Doctrine of pith and substance
Show answer
Answer: B. Under eclipse, the law becomes enforceable again once the inconsistency is removed, for example by a constitutional amendment.
-
3. Can a citizen voluntarily give up a Fundamental Right?
- Yes, by a written agreement
- Yes, but only with the court's permission
- No, Fundamental Rights cannot be waived
- Yes, for rights in Article 19 only
Show answer
Answer: C. Courts treat Fundamental Rights as matters of public policy, so they cannot be waived.
-
4. Which of these is included in 'law' under Article 13(3)?
- A constitutional amendment under Article 368
- A private contract between two persons
- A political party's manifesto
- An ordinance
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 13(3) includes ordinances, orders, bye-laws, rules, regulations, notifications and customs having the force of law. Amendments are excluded by Article 13(4).
-
5. A statute has ten sections; only section 6 violates Article 14, and the rest can stand alone. What happens?
- Only section 6 is void, under the doctrine of severability
- The whole statute is void
- The whole statute is eclipsed
- The statute is valid because most of it is lawful
Show answer
Answer: A. Severability strikes down only the offending part when the rest can work independently.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.